Miscellaneous Guilty! I often skip bass and drum solos

Working with a good drummer is part of the great joy of playing music and it makes all the difference to your improvising having someone who's listening and reacting
I've spent enough time in the company of drummers to know that they're not just bashing away for the sake of it, they're thinking about structure and dynamics and the general feel of the music, where to emphasise things and where to lay back... tension and release can come from rhythm as well as harmony... it's not just about keeping time, it can be part of a group conversation, swapping idea back and forth.

drum solos I can understand the point of - if you were stuck at the back all night playing behind everyone else having fun with their solos, wouldn't you want to have some of that fun as well?
Of course some solos tend to be a showy display of drum technique, but that's an occupational hazard of any kind of soloing on any instrument, particularly in jazz which evolved with all those cutting contests and jam sessions where players tried to out do each other.

But then there are drum solos that add something to the music and are an integral part of it and the music continues it's natural ebb and flow while the other band members lay out for a while. I can't imagine what 'Gone' would sound like without Philly Joe's drum breaks.
 
I'm not listening to it, I just scanned it to see what you were talking about. I own and have owned a lot of Trane albums, but I never cared for Olé, regardless of its worth as art. It doesn't do it for me. You can't love every recording anyone has ever done, as the teams on the "Coltrane Murders Summertime" post clearly shows. I don't recall which team you joined, but that doesn't matter. There was a strong subjective polarization there, it's called taste. Someone once to told me to listen to Mahler, "I assure you, it's very good!" she opined.
I wasn't referring to this song in particular or suggesting you should think it is a great piece of music, all I was saying was, that if a person is listening to what they consider to be a great piece of music, I don't understand how they can start pressing the fast forward button part way through.
 
Lots of homework here, it'll take some time to check out and digest all this. I have heard the jungle joke many times, usually reduced to the punchline: "Drums stop. Very bad. Bass solo." but the cartoon is new and gets a laugh.

I don't think anyone has mentioned trading fours, which is usually very pleasant, especially live. The inherent structure of four bars and the question-answer interplay is a great feature of jazz. The rhythm section can be featured in a painless moment that nicely sets up the return to the head of the tune.

It's a feature in funk to have intros that begin with drums and add bass, rhythm guitar, etc in order. It's also common to break down to bass and drums, or just one or two other instruments. Or in blues, take it down to the harmonica playing a "freight train" rhythm.

I like to tell new players about the combinations of instruments because, after all, in binary math, four musicians gives you 16 possible combinations (trio is 8). The two most common are zero (not too useful) and all four (which is much of the time). The next four consist of each individual player. In a jazz quartet, looking at the example I gave at the top of this post, Sonny features Wilber Ware. The intro is bass with some tasty brush work. And later Wilber's solo, very nice part of this live recording. I mentioned elsewhere Coltrane's version of this same standard which has an extended intro with the piano trio before Trane makes his dramatic entrance.

Bass and drum solos are a small sample of the possible combinations. I agree with the comments about drum solos that "play" or refer to the tune, it's way better than a series of riffs. On drums, though, a series of grooves does work for me.
 
listening to what they consider to be a great piece of music, I don't understand how they can start pressing the fast forward button part way through.
To be honest, there's a lot of great playing out there in jazz, but I do not consider a large portion of it to be "great music". More like a lot of great playing. A huge amount of great playing on all instruments. Even bass. This may not be a popular opinion, but a lot of Bill Evans recordings are only great when he's playing. All that extended fast thumb position stuff would be ok if it wasn't 5 minutes long. The potential greatness of such things is diminished if the solos are too long.
 
Does that make me a bad person? Or just a bad listener? T
"I am a bass player....I tend to forward past all of those busy-bee horn solos in jazz tunes so I can get to the rhythm section solos.
Does that make me a bad person, or bad listener?".


The answer to these 2 questions is the same.

Does my version sound a bit absurd to you ?


I'd appreciate links or references to your favorite bass or, (shudder), even drum solos.

Continuing down your road....Me (the bass player) then asks...

"am I missing something ? Can anyone recommend any GOOD horn solos on jazz tunes that I might listen to ?"

Good answers to this can fill probably 100 pages of a thread. Same with asking that of rhythm section solos.


As a start, listen to anything Paul Chambers plays, say with Miles' classic groups.
Buster Williams.
Bob Cranshaw on Lee Morgan's "Sidewinder".
Listen to the Curtis Counce Group.
Butch Warren on Joe Henderson's "Page One " album.
Sam Jones's work on the classic Donald Byrd albums....

But my real suggestion is THIS: IF you are truly interested in developing your ear on this...STOP doing what you have been doing. You already listen to Jazz...just listen to the whole song. There's a point to bass a drums solos beyond "it's those guys' turn now" :cheers:
 
Last edited:
This gets to a bigger, very interesting point....your question does.

You see, as a rhythm section player foremost, sax only entering the scene much later in my musical life....there is a MASSIVE difference in the musical conception of a rhythm section player and a lead player...particularly the bass and drum players, as piano and guitar (as the most obvious examples) have one foot in each.

In most instances, a horn player can transcribe a jazz piano or guitar solo and play it, and it'll sorta sound 'right'...as if it's a 'horn solo'.

Bass players will, like other players, throw in quotes and licks from well known 'lead' solos....and it can sound kinda hip.

I would invite anyone to transcribe a classic straight ahead jazz bass solo and play it (on their sax). It is gonna sound...well....for lack of a better word....odd. It's gonna beg the question "what is the horn player up to here ???"

You will see how the structure and conception is very different from what a horn player would produce.

It has been the most challenging part of a lifelong rhythm section player trying to play a lead instrument. The basic 'jazz language' I have learned is the same as what a sax player probably knows, but the dynamics of a 'conventional' jazz bass solo (my familiar zone) vs. that of a horn solo (new ground) are significantly different.

Interesting stuff, actually.
 
Last edited:
(Oh.....

Slam Stewart, too.....)


I am sticking to pretty straight 'in-the-pocket' straight-ahead examples. We can start getting into stuff like the Two Charlies, fo course (Mingus and Haden) if you desire to start going more outside...but I find the classic straight-ahead contexts easier to digest for those who inquire)
 
Dunno why I thought of this Keith Jarrett tune, probably because an interesting example of where the bass occupies the solo space which, conventionally, one would have expected the sax to fill. I dunno why I cannot find it on YT, it used to be there but now I find only covers or live versions. Great song but the best version is the originally recorded one.

Perhaps try to find for the original studio version of "Country" (If you do, pleas post it here, thx).

There is NO sax solo on this tune.
 
Last edited:
I love the way Steve Swallow plays bass as an integral part of the trio with Carla Bley and Andy Sheppard. Melodic and interesting solos, for example:

Or:

You certainly wouldn't want to skip Steve's Swallow's contributions and I'm very much looking forward to seeing this trio live (first time for me) in October.

Rhys
 
Last edited:

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,079
Messages
578,714
Members
8,136
Latest member
peterdehelegrote
Back
Top Bottom