Saxophones Glissotar - Swanee for the 21st Century

greenstripe

Member
Messages
950
Location
UK
A new product that seems to address the key failings of the Swanee although not strictly a saxophone (one is planned). Jim from Sax does a good job of explaining but not so much playing it. The inventor himself makes it sound much more credible.

View: https://youtu.be/hkvN9NLU6Gw?si=pJOQNiexIHadrEqT



View: https://youtu.be/3L-7ZnhD7vI?si=dauk5jMLtIWblvsp
 
That's a really cool concept. I'm looking forward to see other variants. Alto, tenor, etc.

I'm also surprised that no one responded to this post.

Quite cool but not for me at that price.

I think that the size for this concept is constrained by the natural spacing of fingers, so I am not sure that larger models would work without a major rethink.

Rhys
 
Quite cool but not for me at that price.

I think that the size for this concept is constrained by the natural spacing of fingers, so I am not sure that larger models would work without a major rethink.

Rhys
It will be interesting to see what they come up with, as Jim says in the video, the natural finger placement is given towards chromatic spacing (if you're used to playing Saxophone) -so roughly a semitone apart, I appreciate what you're saying and as the instrument gets bigger this interval will get smaller, but there's nothing stopping you moving your hands or even swapping over left and right to do a run.

Perhaps they could develop some sort of hybrid with keys as well, who knows?
 
Interesting that in the video of the inventor, he's using the pipers grip - like low D tin whistle etc. so that's probably as low as.he can go while keeping chromatic intervals? The spacing getting bigger, surely? Still
even swapping over left and right to do a run.
Interesting point!

I'd think one would have to learn some tricky finger jumping as you can't do cross fingering...

€2000!
I'm aure Yamaha could churn out "student" models for €200 .. YGS23 anyone? I would.
 
I think that the size for this concept is constrained by the natural spacing of fingers, so I am not sure that larger models would work without a major rethink.
You're absolutely right. I should have considered this.

Perhaps alto would still be feasible, but larger would require very long arms... 🦍
 
But, unlike unkeyed tubes, you don't have to keep all the holes above closed, finger by finger.
The strip, with magnetic rails, above your lowest finger seals everything above. No?
So you could play it as a one string double base.
That is my understanding too. But reaching the low notes would be a long way down on a tenor version of this I guess.
 
That is my understanding too. But reaching the low notes would be a long way down on a tenor version of this I guess.
Sure. Just saying the finger-spread problem could be solved like that. And, I guess, (fretless) base players use a mixture of relative between finger and dead reckoning?
But they don't have the scroll stuffed in their mouths!
 
But, unlike unkeyed tubes, you don't have to keep all the holes above closed, finger by finger.
The strip, with magnetic rails, above your lowest finger seals everything above. No?
So you could play it as a one string double base.

Yes, that is true. A whole different technique with some constraints and possible issues around the position of the mouthpiece relative to the hand(s). And also the bore size Vs the opening size and the speed and precision of the opening/closing of the magnetic strip.

Some clever people could probably make it work.

Rhys
 
But, unlike unkeyed tubes, you don't have to keep all the holes above closed, finger by finger.
The strip, with magnetic rails, above your lowest finger seals everything above. No?
So you could play it as a one string double base.

Double bass players seem to be able to deal with big spaces between notes.

Thinking about this some more, double bass (and fretless bass) players deal with this by having four differently-tuned strings that can be fingered from a single position of the hand.

@mizmar is right that the Glissotar instruments could be compared to a single string instrument, so it would be much less agile to play than a four string counterpart.

Maybe the developers could think about a Glissotar with one mouthpiece and more than one tube. Or tubes filled with different gases and so different speeds of sound !

Rhys
 
Maybe the developers could think about a Glissotar with one mouthpiece and more than one tube. Or tubes filled with different gases and so different speeds of sound !
How many years and prototypes did he say they needed to get to this point!

I guess it just comes down to how a player gets creative/expressive with the tool at hand. Like any instrument?
 
@saxyjt can resolve the Question
There was no question and I'm tired of resolving problems.

Maybe the developers could think about a Glissotar with one mouthpiece and more than one tube. Or tubes filled with different gases and so different speeds of sound !

Now, what is nice about this 'thing' is it's relative simplicity. Complexifying it would kill the concept. KIS!
 

Similar threads... or are they? Maybe not but they could be worth reading anyway 😀

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,070
Messages
578,521
Members
8,132
Latest member
LouisJR
Back
Top Bottom