Playing the saxophone From the Inside Out

6441

Well-Known Member
Messages
5,846
Mark Watkins - I heard about him on the Everything Saxophone Podcast - has a series of videos you won't want to watch at breakfast, as I'm doing now. They are video recordings made inside people's mouths.

Book blurb: "With a doctorate in five woodwind instruments and decades as both a performer and a teacher, Dr. Mark Watkins has long been interested in the production of sound."

He took a number of videos of the mouths of saxophone players in action, showing palate, tongue . Although at my early level of sax education (see what I did there?) a lot of it is way too advanced, there is a lot about sound production and articulation that rubs off, even as a beginner. Articulation exercises, for example, looks like something anyone can practice. I'm posting this because the number of subscribers and views are very low, suggesting many of you haven't seen them.

The podcast episode link above is an extended interview with Ben Britton, who explains how he worked on his sound production at length and recommends the book, a $50 tome. Britton studied with or met Watkins and has studied the book. Again, not something the beginner would want, probably, but the concepts are sound and if even a little rubs off, that's a good thing.

The podcast has proved to be very interesting and you do not need to have a special app to listen to the episodes. You can hear them on the web on any browser.

 
Thank you for that link. I am familiar with Dr. Mark Watkins through his relationship with Dr. Ray Smith who teaches at BYU Utah. I was interested in watching chapter 3 duplicating Santy Runyon's theramin experiment. I did a similar test several years ago although not as sophisticated using a tuner to produce the frequency in place of a theramin and got exactly the same results. It remains a mystery why Santy Runyon would fabricate such a story to make his point about mouthpiece pitch. Mouthpiece Pitch Revisited

Restored link to sound file The first sound is the small speaker by itself. The second sound is the speaker attached to the cut off mouthpiece. The third sound is the mouthpiece attached to the saxophone. The fourth sound is the saxophone being fingered.
 
Last edited:
Good morning,

Nobody reading the book in the meantime?
Nobody interested in the truth about hot and cold air, air speed, air focusing? 🙂
TMI! It's hard enough to get emotion out these things without intellectualising about how to produce the sound. No language can really express this stuff adequately. Yes, you can accurately describe anything with math and science, that does not necessarily lead to progress.
 
TMI! It's hard enough to get emotion out these things without intellectualising about how to produce the sound. No language can really express this stuff adequately. Yes, you can accurately describe anything with math and science, that does not necessarily lead to progress.

Let's take a moment and think about the meaning of this post.

In the negative sense, to 'intellectualize' means to give an intellectual character to something in a way that isn't really relevant. One imagines a teacher telling a student "blow at .2 psi" and this would of course be ridiculous. 6441 seems to think this is the only meaning for the term, as its implications in the post are entirely negative.

But there is also the positive sense of approaching something in an intellectual manner, meaning to use reason, to think and analyze something. This is the process that created saxophones, reeds, music, the car you drive to lessons, gigs, concerts, the computing device you use to visit this forum, pretty much every good thing.

"No language can really express this stuff adequately." Communication is challenging and difficult, but this does not mean that we should give up on language or that there is an alternative. Music teachers depend on language to explain things to students, in fact it is coaching by means of language that a good teacher uses to help a student learn "how to produce the sound". There is not a player alive today for whom words were not part of their process of learning "how to produce the sound".

"Yes, you can accurately describe anything with math and science, that does not necessarily lead to progress."

In the long run it absolutely does, and its opposite absolutely leads to misinformation and stagnation. Mark Watkins' book brought an epic amount of much-needed reality to saxophone pedagogy. He uses math and science (mostly the simple quantification of observation) to gather data about what competent players actually do. Mark's book is a tremendous good for the saxophone world.

Yes its organization is daunting, its approach is exhaustive, it feels like "TMI", but revolutions require solid foundations, and this book is a revolution, although it will take decades for it to diffuse fully into the saxophone world. Don't let the overwhelming nature of the book lead you to start rationalizing about not reading it (which is your right without need to explain), lest your rationalizations come off as attacks on things that are good.
 

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,076
Messages
578,681
Members
8,136
Latest member
peterdehelegrote
Back
Top Bottom