Four on Six Questions

redmancba

Member
Messages
50
Hi guys. I'm trying to learn Wes Montgomery's "Four on Six" and I had a few questions about the chords in it.

I was wondering the theory behind chords like a D7(sharp 9). Wouldn't the sharp nine cause it to have a conflict of major and minor tonalities? Or am I getting the chord formula wrong? I'm asking because I can't get the chord to sound good at all on the guitar, but it sounds good in the recording.

Also, in the lead sheet I have of the song (from the Real Book, Vol. 5), the time signature says it is in C, but it seems to me like it would be in Bb (because of the melody and chords). I'm sure it moves through a few different keys in the song, but how do I know what scale to use to construct the chords with (I'm trying to figure out the fingerings for the chords on my own before looking at a chord book)? Does it really matter the scale as long as the major/minor and dominant 7th/major 7th parts are there?

I know there are a lot of questions. Sorry about that. Thanks for the help,
Conor.
 
At 21:55:17 26/03/06, redmancba wrote:
Hi guys. I'm trying to learn Wes Montgomery's "Four on Six" and I had a few questions about the chords in it.

I was wondering the theory behind chords like a D7(sharp 9). Wouldn't the sharp nine cause it to have a conflict of major and minor tonalities? Or am I getting the chord formula wrong? I'm asking because I can't get the chord to sound good at all on the guitar, but it sounds good in the recording.
Think of the #9 a modified 9th, an extra 'blue' note rather than an added minor 3rd. The presence of both the #9th and the M3 gives that blues sound, that 'conflict' is part of the sound of the chord. You wouldn't voice the chord with both the M3 and #9 right next to each other, you'd put the #9 on top of the chord. It's used a lot in funk and blues songs.
How are you voicing the chord? Here's a couple of voicings for D7#9:
-
5
4
5
6
-
or
-
9
10
10
10
-
Also, in the lead sheet I have of the song (from the Real Book, Vol. 5), the time signature says it is in C, but it seems to me like it would be in Bb (because of the melody and chords). I'm sure it moves through a few different keys in the song, but how do I know what scale to use to construct the chords with (I'm trying to figure out the fingerings for the chords on my own before looking at a chord book)? Does it really matter the scale as long as the major/minor and dominant 7th/major 7th parts are there?
It's in G minor: the first 4 bars, bars 9-11 and 15 are in G-, and bars 14 and 16 are derived from G-. BbM7 is the relative major of G-. The key (not time) signature should be 2 flats (same as Bb).

If you have the 'unofficial' Real Book, then that's very common (in fact it's common for the chords to be wrong too).

It's very important to know what scales go with what chords when you come to improvise. From a guitarists' point of view I'd say that's essential since you'll be forming your chords based on those scales. It's good you're trying to figure out the chords by yourself thought.
Let us know how you get on.
 
I don't know the song so I can't help much, but yes D7 #9 has a conflict of major and minor. It's a chord. You can leave out the 5th and if there is a bass player leave out the root, so on guitar just play F# C and E# (F). Sounds cool. Jimi hendrix plyed this chord a lot (in a different context to Wes Montgomery), but it's a good bluesy chord because blues is all about juxtaposing minor onto major very often.
 
Thanks guys. Philippe, I looked in the chord book and tried out the first voicing that you gave and it sounds pretty good. It is the "official" Real Book distributed by Hal Leonard. The chords and melody seem right, there is just no key sig.

Also, I had another question: I understand that the scale is very important, but if a song goes through a key change and it isn't apparent immidiately what scale to use to build the chord from, how would I determine it? (I'm wondering mainly about Major vs. Lydian with the differing 4th and Phygian with the minor 2nd/9th and minor 6th). Thanks again,
Conor.
 
Also, I had another question: I understand that the scale is very important, but if a song goes through a key change and it isn't apparent immidiately what scale to use to build the chord from, how would I determine it? (I'm wondering mainly about Major vs. Lydian with the differing 4th and Phygian with the minor 2nd/9th and minor 6th). Thanks again,
Conor.

If I understand correctly, you'd like to find one scale from which a series of chords is derived, and find out what scale to move to when there's a key change?

Well, you could look at this in two ways:
1) You need to aim towards knowing what scale to play over any chord. So that you're not so concerned by the overall key but by the particular chord in the moment. Think of each chord as having it's own key. For example Gm: instead of thinking "Gm, I can play an Eb major scale", think Gm, I can play G natural minor (or G harmonic minor, G melodic minor, G minor blues...). Even in tunes that don't change key, often each chord will be associated with a different scale anyway.
2) Jazz harmony is pretty straightforward and mostly very repetitive, so once you've learnt to recognise a few patterns you'll be able to tell rapidly what key a passage is in. That comes with practice and a little knowledge of harmony...

Basically, one way or the other, you need to learn the relationship between chords and scales. That's a big subject; there's a lot on Pete's site obviously, and I would recommend 'The Jazz Theory Book' by Mark Levine.

Hope I understood your question OK.
 

Similar threads... or are they? Maybe not but they could be worth reading anyway 😀

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,059
Messages
578,308
Members
8,127
Latest member
PJ2116
Back
Top Bottom