Mouthpieces Focused vs spread mouthpiece

Just because you have been playing for many years, playing the same type of mouthpiece and reed over the years, same genre and styles, holding your practice regimen .... doesn't mean you know best for all sax players. I knew/know rock & roll sax players (some of them very professional) that is keen on trying new/differnt mouthpieces ans reeds and also to change to achieve their goals.

Obviously if you pick a Dukoff, getting a mellow dark sound to blend in an orchestra will be tough, just as if you pick a Caravan, the screaming rock and roll solo will be tough.
A Dukoff LD 10 (.130" tip opening, big round chamber) is a nice piece for big band. My friend can play a Dukoff D8 in a classical sax quartet. Another guy, wild and extrovert R&B style, can play a Morgan classical mouthpiece on stage.

The saxophone is capable, WITHOUT CONSTANTLY CHANGING SETUPS, of a vast array of sounds. Your assignment as a musician, should you choose to accept it, is to learn how to elicit these sounds.
To change/swap the same type of mouthpiece (brand, manufacturer, design ...), ligature and reeds can be very refreshing for me as player. I think it's harmless if I play a Rovner Deep-V #8, #9 or #10 mouthpieces. If I play a plasticover baritone or tenor reed with buzzzzzz or ..... .

I'm not an orthodox sax player. Not even an orthodox amateur/hobby honker. I have done lots of things over the years. Why is it so dangerous to go or do it in your own way? We will probably end up in the same solution. As a teacher I was openminded and wanted my students to come to their own decisions even if it was hard to watch that they were doing it in the wrong way.
 
In an ideal world i.e. if i had a music room choices would be so much easier. I find metal pieces more compfortable to play and with regular reeds the lakshmi is a great versatle piece. I know i cant play cane all summer so have decided playing the same set up all year may be best..It will have to be a piece that plays either plasticovers or legere sigs to a tone im comfortable / happy with..not ideal..
 
I knew/know rock & roll sax players (some of them very professional) that is keen on trying new/differnt mouthpieces ans reeds and also to change to achieve their goals.
I agree there are plenty, it's what keeps many mouthpiece manufacturers in business.
Why is it so dangerous to go or do it in your own way?
It can be very good, but I don't think anyone would argue with that
As a teacher I was openminded and wanted my students to come to their own decisions even if it was hard to watch that they were doing it in the wrong way.
When I was teaching I found the biggest thing to learn (for me) was that you can'y have a one size fits all approach. It's important to know what works for specific students and some of them do need to get it wrong before they realise there is a better way.
 
Just because you have been playing for many years, playing the same type of mouthpiece and reed over the years, same genre and styles, holding your practice regimen .... doesn't mean you know best for all sax players. I knew/know rock & roll sax players (some of them very professional) that is keen on trying new/differnt mouthpieces ans reeds and also to change to achieve their goals.

Try all the mouthpieces you like - I have. Then I practice on that mouthpiece so I know how to make it respond to every whim that pops into my head. If I am not confident on that mouthpiece, I don’t take it to a gig. And I don’t switch mouthpieces during the gig just because the tempo or dynamics change.

A Dukoff LD 10 (.130" tip opening, big round chamber) is a nice piece for big band. My friend can play a Dukoff D8 in a classical sax quartet. Another guy, wild and extrovert R&B style, can play a Morgan classical mouthpiece on stage.

Yep. And many years ago, I played an entire two hour rehearsal with my classical quartet on my jazz setup, a Lamberson J8 (.120”) to see if I could make it work. I was exhausted because of the effort to throttle that mouthpiece enough to blend, and the difficulty of controlling intonation at very soft dynamic levels. Around that same time, I got a call to sit in on a dance band gig, so I played it on my Morgan 6C (.090”). That was much more doable because I had been working on developing my projection. Those two experiences underscored my practices since then. Classical mouthpiece when playing classical, other mouthpiece for everything else.
 
Just because you have been playing for many years, playing the same type of mouthpiece and reed over the years, same genre and styles, holding your practice regimen .... doesn't mean you know best for all sax players. I knew/know rock & roll sax players (some of them very professional) that is keen on trying new/differnt mouthpieces ans reeds and also to change to achieve their goals.


A Dukoff LD 10 (.130" tip opening, big round chamber) is a nice piece for big band. My friend can play a Dukoff D8 in a classical sax quartet. Another guy, wild and extrovert R&B style, can play a Morgan classical mouthpiece on stage.


To change/swap the same type of mouthpiece (brand, manufacturer, design ...), ligature and reeds can be very refreshing for me as player. I think it's harmless if I play a Rovner Deep-V #8, #9 or #10 mouthpieces. If I play a plasticover baritone or tenor reed with buzzzzzz or ..... .

I'm not an orthodox sax player. Not even an orthodox amateur/hobby honker. I have done lots of things over the years. Why is it so dangerous to go or do it in your own way? We will probably end up in the same solution. As a teacher I was openminded and wanted my students to come to their own decisions even if it was hard to watch that they were doing it in the wrong way.
You're mixing different things here.

First of all, I was responding to the idea of a different mouthpiece being used for each individual song in a set, where all the songs listed were rather conventional pop songs. No professional saxophonist would do this except in the most unusual circumstances. This is a very different thing from trying out different setups to see if one prefers a different one; it's also very different from having different setups for widely different situations - while it would be rare and weird for a professional saxophonist to swap mouthpieces between two standard pop songs in a set, it would NOT be rare, in fact it's the most common thing - for such a person to have a setup for the occasional classical engagement, another one for general jazz and commercial work, and even a third one for loud screaming rock and roll gigs.

Finally, I did not say it is IMPOSSIBLE to play a "classical" setup for rock and roll or a "rock" setup for classical stuff. Of COURSE you responded to the absolute statement I didn't make with the inevitable examples of the unicorn player who would play a rock gig on a Caravan MP or a classical sax quartet with a Dukoff. (I'm going to reserve judgement on whether they actually sounded any good.) Be that as it may, no one with actual bandstand experience is likely to dispute that mouthpiece designs exist as they are for reasons, and if you are looking for a soft rounded blending tone, you're going to find it far more readily accessible with a Caravan piece than a Dukoff; and if you're looking for a bright powerful piercing tone, the other way round.
 
This is a very different thing from trying out different setups to see if one prefers a different one;
My take on this is also that it's fine to experiment and to be experimenting with sounds. I do believe that it's best coming from within than from the gear. But that isn't always possible as you say you aren't going to get a screaming rock sound from a Caravan (mouthpiece not the trailer) very easily.

Where it goes wrong though is when someone keeps changing all the time, especially when that person has relatively undeveloped embouchure (and by that I mean they have been playing less than two or three hours a day for less than 10 years). I'd always advise sticking to a mouthpiece at least a few years unless there is a very good reason to experiment and switch to others. But still ASAP find on and stick to it.

I agree that even the players that experiment a lot do not switch mouthpieces between during a set unless maybe there is such a difference, e.g. a classical piece follows by a screaming rock piece. Even then I think there are certain mouthpieces that are more versatile and possibly can do that. It's the kind of mouthpiece I have been using most of my life and the only time it didn't seem to work was when I went through a period of playing a Guardala.

I'm going to find a recording if I can of some extremes...
 
My take on this is also that it's fine to experiment and to be experimenting with sounds. I do believe that it's best coming from within than from the gear. But that isn't always possible as you say you aren't going to get a screaming rock sound from a Caravan (mouthpiece not the trailer) very easily.

Where it goes wrong though is when someone keeps changing all the time, especially when that person has relatively undeveloped embouchure (and by that I mean they have been playing less than two or three hours a day for less than 10 years). I'd always advise sticking to a mouthpiece at least a few years unless there is a very good reason to experiment and switch to others. But still ASAP find on and stick to it.

I agree that even the players that experiment a lot do not switch mouthpieces between during a set unless maybe there is such a difference, e.g. a classical piece follows by a screaming rock piece. Even then I think there are certain mouthpieces that are more versatile and possibly can do that. It's the kind of mouthpiece I have been using most of my life and the only time it didn't seem to work was when I went through a period of playing a Guardala.

I'm going to find a recording if I can of some extremes...
Tbf i havent chopped and changed only when circumstances have i.e.the need to play synthetics. I have only had 2 tenors in several years and have changed mpces when i moved onto the yam..i do aim for 2 hours during the week and often spend 4 hoursvsat and sunday playing..
 
have i.e.the need to play synthetics.
That actually makes no sense to me. Although I do play synthetic reeds, there is never a "need to" and also it makes no sense to switch mouthpiece in order to play synthetics, even if it was a necessity.
 
That actually makes no sense to me. Although I do play synthetic reeds, there is never a "need to" and also it makes no sense to switch mouthpiece in order to play synthetics, even if it was a necessity.
Lol i didnt change mouthpiece to play synthetics..i had to change to synthetics as 100 degs plus in the van in the summer. Cane was warping..
 
You were talking about how you have been chopping and changing mouthpieces the necessary, ie in order to play synthetics, that what made no sense. Nor does playing synthetics due to the weather as people have done fine on cane in whatever weather long before synthetic reeds were invented.

I used cane reeds when I lived in Morocco and temperatures higher than 100 degs (Fahrenheit presumably)
 
You were talking about how you have been chopping and changing mouthpieces the necessary, ie in order to play synthetics, that what made no sense. Nor does playing synthetics due to the weather as people have done fine on cane in whatever weather long before synthetic reeds were invented.

I used cane reeds when I lived in Morocco and temperatures higher than 100 degs (Fahrenheit presumably)
But tbf they were probably curled up like the slippers anyway...lol..i tried in the van and they just kept splitting..no air con...I would prefer the flexibility cane gives as long as they sound ok with either plasticovers or legeters for a month or so..
 
but practising with one or playing into a mirror is bad because it flatters your sound.
Does it? Flatter our sound... I thought it just reflected it so we heard it as it is rather than diluted after hitting whatever reflected it in the room...

I like my flattered sound better, so am I actually not sounding like that? 😳

I'm kind of troubled by this... I don't understand how it flatters our sound!?
 
I had an Alexander Technique teacher who lives in LA.
He told me a story about Bennie Wallace (for a while Bennie was his neighbor).
From time to time, Bennie buys mouthpieces, plays them (practises), finds new sounds, possibilities - then returns to the MPC he has been playing on for a long time, because he finds that all these new things are also possible with his old MPC. He just could not imagine them before.
 
Where it goes wrong though is when someone keeps changing all the time, especially when that person has relatively undeveloped embouchure (and by that I mean they have been playing less than two or three hours a day for less than 10 years).
Damn, it's kinda hard to swallow that I'll probably never get to a "developed embouchure" with my current time investment, around five hours a week.

I'm going to find a recording if I can of some extremes...
That would be interesting to hear.
 
From time to time, Bennie buys mouthpieces, plays them (practises), finds new sounds, possibilities - then returns to the MPC he has been playing on for a long time, because he finds that all these new things are also possible with his old MPC. He just could not imagine them before.

I had exactly this experience when I, after two years of playing, first tested a few new mouthpieces. With one of those I could easily play 5th, 6th, 7th and even higher harmonics.
When I put back my regular mouthpiece, I was suddenly finally able to hit those high altissimo notes I never could reach before.
 
It is widely accepted that a player would have a different setup for some different genres such as classical and jazz but its not impossible to use one mouthpiece for all, a pro player I know uses a Guardala for everything including classical.

It's all about the player and his/hers ability to make the setup work, I used to hear some players say " you need a high baffle mouthpiece and a hard reed to get the best altissimo" I would say mines fine with a low or rollover baffle with a soft reed.
One word of caution @eb424 I had a period of time a long time ago on Plasticovers they were the worst reeds to warp and they warped bad they might have changed but it's worth noting ready for your summer playing in the van.
 
I had a period of time a long time ago on Plasticovers they were the worst reeds to warp and they warped bad
Funny, that's not my experience. I've playing plasticovers since the late 80's (tenor and baritone) and they don't wrap. The black plastic coat can be worn out, but wrapping ..... . Two of my 4 plasticovers reeds and I've been playing them since November 2023. After I've been playing I just wipe/clean them and store them in an ordinary reedgard. Me like Plasticovers.
IMG_4846.JPG
 
Funny, that's not my experience. I've playing plasticovers since the late 80's (tenor and baritone) and they don't wrap. The black plastic coat can be worn out, but wrapping ..... . Two of my 4 plasticovers reeds and I've been playing them since November 2023. After I've been playing I just wipe/clean them and store them in an ordinary reedgard. Me like Plasticovers.
View attachment 25546
Mine were on alto and it was about 30 years, everyone that I tried warped badly but a quick soak for a few mins sorted it out, I also used to get the black coating come off quite quickly.
This might have been been a faulty batch, but I never gave them another chance.
 

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,070
Messages
578,524
Members
8,132
Latest member
LouisJR
Back
Top Bottom