Saxophone beginners First Foray Into Tenor for An Alto Player

cjR

Sax via Horn, Trumpet, Guitar, Bass, Music Tech
Messages
91
Location
London, UK
After a ten or so year hiatus, I've been back playing Alto for coming up for a couple of years. For the whole time I've played (and while not playing) I've always wondered about playing Tenor - love the sound and some of my favourite players are all on Tenor.

So no longer being able to resist, I took the plunge. Having read that the embouchure was a bit different, and having been given a Soprano a few months back that took me a couple of days to even get a sound from, I was braced for a humbling experience.

I was pretty surprised to be able to get notes to sound over the whole range straight away. I didn't put much thought into my embouchure but seems to be working so far. I had thought the bell notes might prove elusive but they are coming out nice and clearly. That all felt pretty positive, the less good news my sound in the 2nd 8ve is pretty poor, maybe because I'm thinking or have expectations rooted in my Alto concept. I can also see there's a challenge with playing a note and thinking eg. "A" - that throws out my ear and voicing when the result is unexpected. Hopefully all solved with a few hundred hours of long tones 😀.

Grateful for any advice or tips folks have that they think will be helpful.
 
From my experience tenor is easier to blow than alto in terms of what your mouth is doing but needs more lung power if that makes sense.

It's encouraging that you're able to get down to the low notes easily, generally a sign of a nice relaxed embouchure.

Yes the different key Eb to Bb is confusing.

Aside from any potential regulation issues with the sax, it's probably something that will resolve itself by playing more. Mouthpiece choice can influence some of this, so it may be something to look in to when you're more comfortable and confident on tenor.

Worth noting: what you hear while playing might be different from what others would listening to you. Perhaps try playing facing a wall or purchase a sound reflector that clips on the bell of the sax.
 
There are subtle differences between the various saxes due to their size and voice range, but it all the same fingerings. Glad to see you are enjoying tenor and by playing it, removed some of the mystique from it.

For another true thrill, if you ever want to take the dive, the baritone sax is another to handle with pure joy.
 
Congrats! I remember my first tenor after two years of alto.

Having read that the embouchure was a bit different,
I don't know where you read that, but beware of getting into bad habits because of what someone wrote (wrong) on the internet.

Apart from the obvious fact of the mouthpiece and reed being bigger it can be different embouchure if you want but it doesn't need to be.
 
Last edited:
Apart from the obvious fact of the mouthpiece and reed being bigger it can be different embouchure if you want but it doesn't need to be.
That is what makes my switching between instruments easy.

The nice thing about the old Berg Larson metal mouthpieces of the 1970's was the narrower cross section due to sturdy metal construction. Might be helpful with someone with a smaller mouth.

Maybe 6 years ago, I bought a generic made in the Orient metal mouthpiece for around $20 US on an Internet auction. It was chambered like a beginner mouthpiece and played like one. It only looked like a Berg Larson.

Plus, shortly after using it, its chrome plating peeled from the brass body, now sits idle in one of my cases. Made me more careful to stay away from no-name mouthpieces.
 
This is why I play a hard rubber mouthpiece on alto and a metal mouthpiece on tenor. They are similar sizes, though reed size and facing length are not the same. I do find I need a slightly looser embouchure on tenor; though embouchure muscles remain as firm, jaw pressure on the reed is less. And the break point of the reed is a few mm farther from the tip, so more mouthpiece in my mouth.

FWIW, learning to get a good tenor tone did wonders for my alto tone. My embouchure was too tight, coming as I did from the clarinet.
 
You could always try the maverick route I have taken, after a recent discovery prompted by a discussion online, that with a suitable neck and mouthpiece combination you can get a tremendous result playing alto with a tenor mouthpiece, in tune, with all the compactness and weight benefits of the alto, but with a powerful and rich quasi-tenor sound. Mind you, I have two altos and only specific neck and mouthpiece combos work on each. Vintage all. A fascinating notion to explore.
 
From my experience tenor is easier to blow than alto in terms of what your mouth is doing but needs more lung power if that makes sense.
I find the opposite, I really have to work on tenor, voicing (particularly octave A), breath support... Alto I can pick up and play, and potentially be a little lazy with it.

As for embochure, I try to play all my horns quite loose, Soprano seems to be exception.
 
When I did that by accident the tremendous result was the neighbour banging on the wall.
Was it like:

2022-05-24 Seniors Guitar Celebration2.webp
 
After a ten or so year hiatus, I've been back playing Alto for coming up for a couple of years. For the whole time I've played (and while not playing) I've always wondered about playing Tenor - love the sound and some of my favourite players are all on Tenor.

So no longer being able to resist, I took the plunge. Having read that the embouchure was a bit different, and having been given a Soprano a few months back that took me a couple of days to even get a sound from, I was braced for a humbling experience.

I was pretty surprised to be able to get notes to sound over the whole range straight away. I didn't put much thought into my embouchure but seems to be working so far. I had thought the bell notes might prove elusive but they are coming out nice and clearly. That all felt pretty positive, the less good news my sound in the 2nd 8ve is pretty poor, maybe because I'm thinking or have expectations rooted in my Alto concept. I can also see there's a challenge with playing a note and thinking eg. "A" - that throws out my ear and voicing when the result is unexpected. Hopefully all solved with a few hundred hours of long tones 😀.

Grateful for any advice or tips folks have that they think will be helpful.
I've only ever played tenor sax but I've tried out a sop, alt and bari from time to time.

I bow to the experience of multi-sax players. From my (very limited) experience, moving down from sop to alt/tenor or from alt to tenor/bari is easier (more relaxed) on the embouchure than moving up.

My (inexperienced and uneducated guess is that's a question of:
- getting used to the differences in embouchure, breath control, voicing, etc. on each sax (muscle control)
- getting used to switching between saxes (embouchure, breath control, voicing, etc)

From my 'tenor', I've found it much easier to play bari (lower) than alt or sop (higher and much higher)
 
I was trying to figure out where to start mouthpiece wise here:


With the help of some careful eBaying I think I've finally settled on an Tone Edge 6* for Tenor. A Selmer Soloist was in pole position for a couple of weeks. Java Reds 3 won out in my reed trials (I play v16 2.5s on Alto) quite significantly, I hope it wasn't just a one off great reed in the multi pack 🙂
 
Regarding switching from different saxophones, I've done it often enough that I do it with ease. But then, I've been playing off and on since 6th grade in 1965, starting with Bb clarinet.

In high school, I switched between Bb Clarinet, Oboe and Alto Sax. After, with the military bands both active and reserve, switched between clarinet and alto, tenor and bari saxes.

Then as a pensioner from 12 years ago, gained a beginners (ebonite) Eb sopranino clarinet and a Bb soprano sax. Since I switch often enough, it has become with relative ease. Everyone is different, but I have no problems with. Also, have now an Artley C Flute, just a starter, so will take me time to come up to speed on it.

It is good for one to become proficient in one instrument before moving to another. But, when it is time, there is a certain amount of joy in trying something with the same fingering or similar like in a clarinet. By then, one would have mastered a certain proficiency in playing, have a developed embouchure, which leads them onto a new discovery.

Recently I ordered this on Dec. 28:

https://www.sweetwater.com/store/de...-mkm-7-metalite-tenor-saxophone-mouthpiece-m7

D'Addario Rico Metalite M7 mouthpiece (Tip Opening: 0.095" (2.41mm), Facing: 0.905" (23mm)) is due to arrive Saturday. When I get a chance to use it, will post a report in the mouthpiece section, or continue a thread on this mouthpiece.
 
I know a clarinet player who swaps between clarinet, alto and flute during a concert, that's just witchcraft to me.
Rather than witchcraft, perhaps instead it is mayhem?


(Sorry, I just love how effective the tenor sax, trumpet, organ, trapset, etc. backing is along with an excellent singer who is able to connect with the crowd, even video's herself by a cellphone passed by a fan to her.)
 

Similar threads... or are they? Maybe not but they could be worth reading anyway 😀

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,063
Messages
578,425
Members
8,129
Latest member
Bartman
Back
Top Bottom