Playing the saxophone Finger position

Chas

Member
Messages
169
Location
England
Hello Dear saxophone players.
Could some one answer me this question please .When I'm playing saxophone do I need to keep my fingers close to the keys in fact almost on them .Is it wrong to be lifting my fingers of the keys Cheers Charlie.
 
Leaving your fingers of the key makes your action slower and can be a cause of pressing the wrong keys.
I just keep my pinkies on the G# and Eb key and the rest of the fingers follow automatically.
 
Hello woodpad
Thank you but my saxophone teacher says I'm playing not tight enough to the keys but trying to re justify this is like starting again . Thanks for your advice much appreciated Charlie
 
Practice s-l-o-w-l-y - concentrate on letting your fingers be relaxed and on the keys. Slow so you don’t have to think about fingering, or what note is next. Precise and relaxed, that’s what you want. Speed up slowly over time.

Unfortunately many (most?) of us rarely achieve that. It takes years to unlearn the flying fingers syndrome.
 
Hello Dear saxophone players.
Could some one answer me this question please .When I'm playing saxophone do I need to keep my fingers close to the keys in fact almost on them .Is it wrong to be lifting my fingers of the keys Cheers Charlie.
I think the answer is that you will get by without keeping your fingers on or close to the keys, but you progress better by striving to do so.
 
Practice s-l-o-w-l-y - concentrate on letting your fingers be relaxed and on the keys. Slow so you don’t have to think about fingering, or what note is next. Precise and relaxed, that’s what you want. Speed up slowly over time.

Unfortunately many (most?) of us rarely achieve that. It takes years to unlearn the flying fingers syndrome.
Thanks for info much appreciated Charlie.
 
Of course it's mechanically more efficient not to waste milliseconds in extra finger travel, but there's something to be said for the visual appeal of a flurry of expressive finger movement, (albeit a more masterful and effortless appearance derives from minimal movement). Ultimately, unless you're aiming to play frantically fast, the amount of finger travel you employ is down to your individual style, a form of native personal gesticulation. I find my hands tend to imitate the raised pinky style of parodied posh English tea drinkers.
 
Rubber Cement? 👍👍
Seems as though with Internet learning, by just watching videos, as opposed to an in person teacher, problems that rarely existed, are now abundant.
Audio/video lessons, done right, are more helpful, if the teacher checks for everything.

If keeping your fingers on the pearls, is too difficult, slow down, take control of your body, and practice correctly.
If you can't control your hands, might be that your breath support and other things, might need attention as well.
 
Last edited:
Keep those fingers down. Key to any activity involving manual dexterity is the reduction of tension, limiting muscle forces and travel to the minimum required to do the job. When your hands are completely relaxed, the fingers are lightly curved. Stay as close as possible to that when holding your instrument, and only flex the muscles in the fingers that are needed, and only when it's needed.
 
Play looking into a mirror and watch your fingers. You'll see how inefficient it is. If you're not ready to play without the dots, try it during scale/arpeggio practice.

It'll train your ear to finger coordination too.
Thanks Colin always take your advice on board,but it's hard when you have a saxophone teacher learning you .Your only learning of that one person and they could be passing on bad habits, albeit that's he's 94 played with some jazz greats and was also tutored by Eugene
Rousseau .So it's good to hear other people's opinions Thanking you Charlie Sheffield.


Play looking into a mirror and watch your fingers. You'll see how inefficient it is. If you're not ready to play without the dots, try it during scale/arpeggio practice.

It'll train your ear to finger coordination too
 
Keep those fingers down. Key to any activity involving manual dexterity is the reduction of tension, limiting muscle forces and travel to the minimum required to do the job. When your hands are completely relaxed, the fingers are lightly curved. Stay as close as possible to that when holding your instrument, and only flex the muscles in the fingers that are needed, and only when it's needed.
Thanking you Charlie Sheffield
 
Play looking into a mirror and watch your fingers
This is great advice I was going to mention this. I started with a little fold out mirror that I could put on a music stand so I could keep an eye on my embouchure from time to time, I've since put a couple on the walls where I practice, can be a big help.

When I started up playing again I had similar comments from my teacher, it wasn't something I'd thought about or particularly noticed I was doing. With the exception of when the palm keys get involved (still work in progress), I was able to improve this. I don't focus or think about hand positioning most of the time I am playing, too much else going on, but when working on long tones or other things at a slow pace that's where I find there is opportunity to check and correct myself. For me at least, having awareness of it and spending multiple short periods in practice sessions being deliberate about checking and correcting helped me find the right position and not have to think about it. Of course ramp up the difficulty of the situation and all bets are off.
 
I agree that the ideal is to have finger travel at a minimum. But I think it’s a worse habit if playing an open-holed instrument like clarinet or open-holed flute.
A secondary pitfall on the clarinet can then be “finger slap” - a percussive noise from the fingers closing heavily.

Brecker played with a high finger action - some say due to his playing of the wind synth (EWI) which has touch-sensitive keys (I can account for this too - a mere leaning on something can see changes of notes by a tone or semitone and you have no idea why). It could be folklore, but it makes sense.

The main thing is that your fingers aren’t really (or at all) tense, and whatever height they stand poised is uniform, rather than all over the place. That’s the main thing, as rogue finger positions could be an answer for uneven playing.
 

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,063
Messages
578,425
Members
8,129
Latest member
Bartman
Back
Top Bottom