Beginner Saxes Entry student tenor vs used YST 275/280

Tonyd

Member
Messages
12
Location
United Kingdom
Hi all

i’ve been playing alto for a couple of years and thought I might dip my toe in the tenor waters. I’ve looked at and play tested the TJ classic II and the Elkhart 100TS. I thought the TS was good, but disliked the Elkhart. I spoke to a bloke at sax.co.uk about the `Jean `Paul TS 400, he said it was a bit better than the TJ. Given than the prices of these horns comparable with a used 275/280, would I be better off going along the used route If a can find a good one?

Any thou would be appreciated

tony
 
I think the TJ's get a bit of a bad rap sometimes, I personally think they are very good and well made horns and, are sold at a reasonable price. If you want nice and shiny new then I would vote for the TJ, but agree with Colin, a used 25 would be perfect if you not worried about that new car smell!
 
Vote:
Upvote 0
Hi Tony, where in Bucks are you? I'll keep an eye out for a Yamaha for you.
How far are you prepared to travel to buy one?
I won't suggest distance buying (buying blind, based on private seller's description) as it's dicey unless buying from a reputable seller or retailer.

PS. I just sold a TJ Classic II tenor to a gigging player and he messaged to say he's over the moon with it after his first gig with it. It was used, beat up, but just repaired/serviced by Paul Carrington to bring it back to life.
Oh... and a Yamaha will hold it's value better than a TJ, which will hold its value better than a Jean Paul. In fact, buy a 25 wisely and you won't lose a penny on resale.
 
Last edited:
Vote:
Upvote 0
I have a 25 tenor. I paid very little for it last year. It needed a clean, pad or two and a bit of cork.
A few minor scratches in the lacquer don't show from about six feet. Looks like new from ten.
275 made in Japan. 280 made in Indonesia.
If that's relevant to you.
Be patient they come along frequently.
 
Vote:
Upvote 0
Thanks both. I don’t mind a used instrument. The 25 is not as common as the 275/280 on the popular auction site. I’ll keep and eye on it

tony
OK, so first:

I am a tech and refurber. I was surprised that the Jean Pauls were NOT garbage....when I serviced my first one, I wanted to hate it and come onto Forums and declare they were just another cheapo asian thing which people were all happy about solely because they were cheap.

They are...better than that, I had to grudgingly admit. The ones I serviced had been played hard by HS/college kids, realtively serious about their music, and had been holding together quite respectably; none of the 'red flag' sorta conditions common to cheapo saxes did I find during servicing.
So, IF someone in the know (who is NOT trying to push you to buy one of their horns) says it's a bit better than a TJ, just by connecting the dots I would say, get the JP not the TJ (admittedly I have never even held a latter in my hands).

With that said, the JP isn't a Yamaha. The thing about the Yama, however, is: IF you are buying used, are the price points you are looking at for horns which are serviced and guaranteed to be in PLAY SHAPE ?

Or are they just listings which say things like "pads look good, everything looks good" or "I am not a player but there appears to be no significant issues"...or the like

Because those sort of descriptions...are meaningless and provide no info, really. You could buy one of those and end up having to blow 200-300quid on servicing ebcause although they aren't beat up, they are significantly out of regulation and will need several hours of tech work.

Or you may luck out and one only needs 50 quid of work.

It is a roll of the dice. So, if buying used, get a confirmation from the seller that the horn does play up and down, or you can return it. If they will not do that, hold back at least £150 for repairs, because repairs will be likely.
 
Vote:
Upvote 1
Hi @DavidUK , I am in Amersham. I’m in no hurry. My budget is around £800. I have Prozone down the road in Chesham, they get used horns in, but mostly alto. The online shop UK Horns has a 275, but I thought that a bit expensive at £900, but maybe it isn’t?
 
Vote:
Upvote 0
Pete at UK Horns will move a little bit and seems to be one of the good guys. Chat him up?
You'll find an excellent 25/275/280 tenor at around £6-700 privately, if you wait.
I'll find one at £2-400 whilst not looking for one!
Jean Paul's are few and far between used. I think I've only ever seen one used alto in the years, but I don't look on eBay often.
I'm not a TJ fan personally.
 
Vote:
Upvote 0
Quick search brings up the following private ads (if still available), in the order I'd consider them. You'd need to travel...




Be VERY wary dealing on Facebook Marketplace. You can generally tell a lot from the way the ad is written. Hence the first one seems genuine and will meet you half way (travel, not price!).

There will always be more coming up for sale, so bide your time if in no rush.
 
Vote:
Upvote 0
@DavidUK , that first one is one I’ve been looking at on eBay. The seller gets good reviews. The only difference is that the eBay listing is for £825! Not sure why he had it for £700 on FB. On eBay there is a video of him playing it
eBay and PayPal fees will bring the net incoming amount down to pretty close to £700, so for him the earning is pretty similar.
 
Vote:
Upvote 0
@DavidUK , that first one is one I’ve been looking at on eBay. The seller gets good reviews. The only difference is that the eBay listing is for £825! Not sure why he had it for £700 on FB. On eBay there is a video of him playing it
Message him on Facebook and save £125? I guess you have to go get it either way. That's the best idea anyhow.

Let us know how you get on. I'm sensing you have GAS bad! 😉
 
Last edited:
Vote:
Upvote 0
No, don't do that!! Wait, I'll explain...

If you message him eBay may be alerted if a sale doesn't proceed via them and he may get a slap.
Let me get his number and I'll PM you with it.

I was only going to ask if he’d take an offer, I know about the AI on eBay (used to be a software dev). But thanks for the reaction, it a good citizen thing to do.

Actually my Mrs uses FB, I’ll get her to ping him on FB messenger

Tony
 
Vote:
Upvote 0

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,073
Messages
578,610
Members
8,133
Latest member
walthang
Back
Top Bottom