Ligatures Enlightened Ligature Theo Wanne Where to purchase?

I've used traditional two screw ligs, Lawtons, Rovners, BGs, string, sellotape and jubilee clips. Never heard any difference.

What's needed is something from my line of work. A blinded randomised controlled trial with a large number of subjects to dilute the effects of chance. However, manufacturers of 'exotic' ligs are just like the people who rave about homoeopathy and other crank therapies - they'll never agree to a truly scientific test.
 
The enlightened ligature doesnt move around for me. The only time the presure plate wouldnt sit at the same angle as I wanted was when I changed plates and did the screw up too tightly meaning that the plate didnt move as seperately to the tightening bolt as easily. This was fixed by getting the supplied screw driver, and twisting the screw holding the pressure plate in half a turn back
 
The feild of ligs altering sound has been coming up here a bit. From my experience- they don't, but- here's my ten pence worth- they can alter 'response'. I've found that with Francois Louis ligs high and low notes seem to kick in a bit easier, the overall consistency of the horn's response in the extremes feels easier... the whole even-ness of the sax from top to bottom improves.. still sounds the same though!
 
The feild of ligs altering sound has been coming up here a bit. From my experience- they don't, but- here's my ten pence worth- they can alter 'response'. I've found that with Francois Louis ligs high and low notes seem to kick in a bit easier, the overall consistency of the horn's response in the extremes feels easier... the whole even-ness of the sax from top to bottom improves.. still sounds the same though!


True that! I think that the response of a ligature may make people perceive that the tone colour changes as well. That may be why there are so many debates about ligatures. I find that they do only change the response, however as some are not as response enhancing, top, mid or bottom notes will be dampened, thinned or overly punchy. Those characteristics may be mistaken for brightness, darkness tambour etc

Also, matching a ligature that suites a certain style of mouthpiece may assist in bringing out the best in that mouthpiece.

I feel reeds provide more tonal changing qualities than the ligature. The ligature for me helps me unmuffle some notes, and helps me play for longer with better response.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
There are no absolutes about this topic, that's for sure. However, to say that ligs make no difference just isn't borne out by some of my trials. Probably fair to say that most ligs don't bring a great deal to the party, but some do. Francois Louis, Olegatures - and particularly the Borgani Flexitone seem to open the sound up very obviously over Rovners and bog-standard screw ligs. String shouldn't be underestimated either.
 
As Jules said above - the outer edge connection is very flush in my experience - not unlike the Rico H ligature which mainly holds the reed by the extreme points of the H - no contact in the central area of the reed. Quite a few more modern ligatures seem to feature minimal contact with the reed for what it is worth.
 
There are no absolutes about this topic, that's for sure.

But there could be, easily. All you have to do is test properly, using scientifically robust methods and a large number of test subjects (ie, listeners). Randomise between lig A and Lig B without telling the listeners and record their responses. Snake oil peddlars don't like this approach, though, as it removes the 'belief' element and replaces it with reproducable scientific fact.
 
But there could be, easily. All you have to do is test properly, using scientifically robust methods and a large number of test subjects (ie, listeners). Randomise between lig A and Lig B without telling the listeners and record their responses. Snake oil peddlars don't like this approach, though, as it removes the 'belief' element and replaces it with reproducable scientific fact.


Take care Young Jonny, you've just dismissed every human belief in one paragraph.>:)

Typical bloddy amateur astronomer.πŸ™‚
 
But there could be, easily. All you have to do is test properly, using scientifically robust methods and a large number of test subjects (ie, listeners). Randomise between lig A and Lig B without telling the listeners and record their responses. Snake oil peddlars don't like this approach, though, as it removes the 'belief' element and replaces it with reproducable scientific fact.

I've something similar at the Frankfurt musikmesse , I stood at the stand of a famous expensive mouthpiece and ligature manufacturer and swapped lugs around, quite a crowd gathered but nobody could hear a diffence between the fancy lig and my rovner. The manufacturer wasn't well pleased though.
 
I've something similar at the Frankfurt musikmesse , I stood at the stand of a famous expensive mouthpiece and ligature manufacturer and swapped lugs around, quite a crowd gathered but nobody could hear a diffence between the fancy lig and my rovner. The manufacturer wasn't well pleased though.
Was there any difference in 'response'?
 
The enlightened lig's "business end" is actually a francois Louis plate- in practical terms they're a prettier version of the Francois Louis ultimate.....

FWIW the plate looks is more like the old Link plates -- contoured, holds the reed on broader feet at the corners rather than on the outside edge like the FL.

Bottom line, if you like the plate style of lig, this seems a well made one. Attractive, too, IMO.
 

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,076
Messages
578,678
Members
8,134
Latest member
banjo
Back
Top Bottom