Intonation Ear Plugs And Intonation

Veggie Dave

Sax Worker
Messages
3,466
Location
Citizen of Nowhere
Those of you who use normal ear plugs (rather than In Ear Monitors) when playing on stage/at rehearsals, do you find that your sax sounds slightly flat to you when you wear them even though you're playing at pitch?
 
I use a pair of expensive moulded earplugs that are supposed to reduce sound evenly across the frequency range

My intonation is less accurate when I use the plugs, but I put that down to the maelstrom of electric sound, the distractions of playing live and the alteration in embouchure to play as loudly as humanly possible

On the rare occasions I come back clearly in foldback I play in tune
 
I found singing with ear plugs in to be a bit self defeating as I found I struggled with pitching, probably because some of the frequencies that were being cut, were useful for staying in tune. I found I wanted to turn my monitor up! Better to turn things down though, it's not always as easy as that.
 
What a fascinating question. I believe it would be fair to conclude that "ear plugs" lessen the soundwaves going directly into the ear. Perhaps that makes the vibrations going to the inner ear through the eustachean tubes and through the teeth and skull more pronounced. That raises the question of whether the frequencies of the sound waves arriving from those different pathways are somewhat different.

Years ago I found that using my free hand to plug one of my ears while tuning in a large ensemble such as a symphonic band allowed me to better hear my own pitch among the sounds of all of the other instruments (especially the trombones who always sat behind the saxes and played too dang loud even when tuning). 🙂
 
Last night was another small venue with loud PA, so oodles of volume reflected back onto the 'stage' making the foldback less than efficient. There is definitely a difference between plugs and no audible foldback and plugs with audible foldback. It's as though the dominant frequencies that come through when there's no clear foldback don't represent the whole note.
 
I have custom made ear-plug for when I play in loud bands with loud percussion.
I am not aware that they affect what I hear, or my own intonation or pitch. But they might. Since I don’t get to hear what we produced (no one has recorded it and shared it with me) anything is possible.
 
I've thought about custom made plugs but for the same price you can get In Ear Monitors, which I think would be a much better solution for my situation.
I bought these back in 2003. I wasn't aware of In Ear Monitors back then, if they even existed, but In Ear Monitors would have been my first choice as well.
 
Last edited:
I'd love some good in-ear monitors, but they're pricey, so I jury-rigged a cheaper solution. When playing with my loudest band, I sometimes use ambient in-ear headphones with a small personal monitor clipped onto my belt. That way I can hear the band clearly, though safely attenuated, while turning up the volume on my own sound as needed. Haven't noticed any issues with playing flat--at least, not more than usual.
 
I tried using plugs but I just can’t play with them in as I loose the dynamics to the point where I can’t tell how loudly I’m playing. My current solution is Shure SE 215 IEM’s running through a T Bone IEM 75 belt back. The Shures block out about 40 dB (I can’t recal the claimed amount off hand) but with the volume turned down, I can hear the back line (guitar amps, bass guitar and drums) quite clearly. This has really helped my sound no end. It gives me the confidence to know exactly what I’m sounding like (good and bad)
 
I sometimes use ambient in-ear headphones with a small personal monitor clipped onto my belt.

I think quite a few of us would like more details on this set-up. :thumb:

I tried using plugs but I just can’t play with them in as I loose the dynamics to the point where I can’t tell how loudly I’m playing.

I know that feeling! 😀

My current solution is Shure SE 215 IEM’s running through a T Bone IEM 75 belt back.

IEM is the only real solution.

<update>
Regarding my initial issue with ear plugs and intonation, it turns out that the better the intonation of the sax, the fewer problems you have with tuning even when you can't really hear yourself.

I know, it's pretty obvious ... but not all of us has a sax that is as precise as it could be, and without experience of more accurate instruments you don't have the knowledge to know there's a problem. Indeed, until you're in a situation where subtle intonation changes aren't really possible you may not have a problem anyway.
 
I tried using plugs but I just can’t play with them in as I loose the dynamics to the point where I can’t tell how loudly I’m playing. My current solution is Shure SE 215 IEM’s running through a T Bone IEM 75 belt back. The Shures block out about 40 dB (I can’t recal the claimed amount off hand) but with the volume turned down, I can hear the back line (guitar amps, bass guitar and drums) quite clearly. This has really helped my sound no end. It gives me the confidence to know exactly what I’m sounding like (good and bad)

This is how I'm working my IEM's for vocals. I have a tiny bit of keyboards coming through the mix, plus my vocals. The Shure in ears allow enough of the backline to come through, so don't have to worry about a complicated full band mix. The only issue I've had with them is that, when playing the Sax, I find I get a lot of 'Head' sound as well as the mix from my mic. It makes the sax sound really buzzy.
 
I think quite a few of us would like more details on this set-up. :thumb:

Sure thing: I use a Behringer PowerPlay P2 personal amp with some Westone AM Pro 10 ambient earbuds. The P2 has a zero latency minijack out for headphones and both 1/4" and XLR in, so I can feed it a snake from the FOH, and adjust my own volume as needed. Or if I want to be completely self-contained, I can just plug my own mic directly into it. Depending on the mic, that might require an additional portable phantom power supply, which I keep on hand just in case.
 

Similar threads... or are they? Maybe not but they could be worth reading anyway 😀

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,061
Messages
578,384
Members
8,129
Latest member
Bartman
Back
Top Bottom