Tech/maintenance Does this soldering look ok?

ferguscullen

Member
Messages
94
Good morning

I'm thinking of buying an alto that is in really nice condition except for some soldering work on the neck/crook.
Apparently it can't be seen from inside the crook so I'm guessing the repair person knew what they were doing.
Does it look like a good job? Would there be any problems later?
alto neck.webp


Any advice appreciated.

Thank you,
F
 
Tricky one.
It doesn't look like the whole tenon sleeve assembly's been resoldered back onto the crook tube. If it had been I'd be wondering why there doesn't appear to be any lacquer damage around the joint, and yet there's solder carelessly splashed all over the tenon sleeve.
This is a bad thing because it can affect the integrity of the crook joint fit and seal - but it also might suggest that something's under that solder...such as a crack in the sleeve.

There's a little bit of solder at the top end of the sleeve, and that suggests that perhaps the joint was leaking there and someone's attempted to fill it. This is rarely good. If there's a problem with the joint you really ought to take the whole lot off, clean it and resolder it.

Worst case scenario is that the sleeve is cracked - and you'll either need to have it repaired (silver soldered) or replaced.
Not a terribly expensive job - and although soft solder doesn't tend to hold cracks together very well, you might get away with it.
If the alto's nice and the price is right I wouldn't necessarily steer clear of it.
 
Tricky one.
It doesn't look like the whole tenon sleeve assembly's been resoldered back onto the crook tube. If it had been I'd be wondering why there doesn't appear to be any lacquer damage around the joint, and yet there's solder carelessly splashed all over the tenon sleeve.
This is a bad thing because it can affect the integrity of the crook joint fit and seal - but it also might suggest that something's under that solder...such as a crack in the sleeve.

There's a little bit of solder at the top end of the sleeve, and that suggests that perhaps the joint was leaking there and someone's attempted to fill it. This is rarely good. If there's a problem with the joint you really ought to take the whole lot off, clean it and resolder it.

Worst case scenario is that the sleeve is cracked - and you'll either need to have it repaired (silver soldered) or replaced.
Not a terribly expensive job - and although soft solder doesn't tend to hold cracks together very well, you might get away with it.
If the alto's nice and the price is right I wouldn't necessarily steer clear of it.
Great advice. Thanks very much Stephen.
 
Probably a cracked tenon. I've had two like that, which I soldered in the simplest way, which looked much like what you're showing, and which lasted for decades. One of them I've since moved on and the other I still have (unfailed) so I don't know the lifetime of those repairs.
 
Probably a cracked tenon. I've had two like that, which I soldered in the simplest way, which looked much like what you're showing, and which lasted for decades. One of them I've since moved on and the other I still have (unfailed) so I don't know the lifetime of those repairs.
That's essentially the problem - there's no knowing how long the repair will last. Might be a week, a few months, a year or...whenever. All depends on how much stress the sleeve is subjected to, and where. And, of course, if you need to have the joint tightened you're a bit stuffed.
That said, I've seen silver soldered splits pop open - and I've seen a split tenon that had been repaired with superglue. Seemed to work, too!
 
Probably a cracked tenon. I've had two like that, which I soldered in the simplest way, which looked much like what you're showing, and which lasted for decades. One of them I've since moved on and the other I still have (unfailed) so I don't know the lifetime of those repairs.
Thanks for your advice
 

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,076
Messages
578,681
Members
8,136
Latest member
peterdehelegrote
Back
Top Bottom