Tech/maintenance Does the loose neck cork have to be replaced?

Messages
367
Location
Malaysia
Level
Beginner
After practicing today, I notice my neck cork is coming loose. It has not totally come off, just that little portion in the picture.

Do I need to replace the entire cork, or can I go with an easier/lazy solution like... say... stuffing some contact glue into the gap?

(Note that the gap is a bit exaggerated because I'm applying pressure to make it easier to notice)

20250417_154452.webp
 
Solution
Contact adhesive will likely not work. There'll be all kinds of mess in that gap and you'll only get once chance at glueing it.
What I do is pop a bit of sellotape over the end ring to protect it, then get some superglue gel (it's less messy) and pop a drop on the end of a small stick. Work it into the gap, then press the cork down firmly hand hold for a minute or so.
Remove the sellotape to clean up.
You do realize that ethyl alcohol is just plain old booze? Vodka, by definition, is ethyl alcohol diluted with water.

Certainly too MUCH ethyl alcohol can yield a nasty byproduct, but it's contained within the consumer of said excess ethyl alcohol.

I really wish that people who write stuff about environmental this and environmental that were required to at least have passed basic high school chemistry and physics.
From what I've read, many shellac refiners in Asia used denatured alcohol* i.e. methylated sprits a.k.a. 'meths' or more strictly methanol, which is highly toxic by ingestion. In India meths is often added to home made hooch or "country wine" as it's cheap and more easily available then ethanol (tax etc) leading to episodes of blindness, liver and kidney failure et al.

Ethyl alcohol a.k.a. ethanol mentioned in the article above, is what one drinks. Yes, it is toxic in high doses and does have some environmental impact during production, but the above IMHO is green scare mongering.

*Denatured alcohol (meths) contains substances such as denatonium, benzene, and pyridine make it unpalatable; they are also toxic.
 
Vote:
Upvote 0
I really wish that people who write stuff about environmental this and environmental that were required to at least have passed basic high school chemistry and physics.
You set a high bar, turf3. I’d be happy to see a “science appreciation”course, similar to music appreciation for people that would otherwise have no exposure to the concepts.
 
Vote:
Upvote 0
I'm not writing that this method is the best. I just want to show what they did in the past when doing simple jobs like re-corking a sax neck. I'm naiv person, I still think learning from history is helping us in the future. My teacher in methodology told me to fill up the empty spaces on a paper with information so the students could try other ways to do things. This was before internet.

So what about the ~75%+ of saxophone necks that have a rolled or soldered ferrule/reinforcing ring on the end?
Most of the saxes I worked on had no "ring". Necks with rings; I had to make the tapered neck tube a little bit wider and also built up with more shellac on the neck.

I know the danger with shellac and I also know the danger with modern adhesives. We have to trust our own judgment. I always wear safety glasses and glowes when I work with modern glues. I don't use such glues on saxes.
 
Vote:
Upvote 0
I like when we can read about diffent ways to do things. Right or wrong? I think internet is great.
Take it from a repair person....cork, or pearls, applied with shellac ? There will be a tech one day in the near future of that lovely bit of work...that will be cursing whoever did that. It;s just not the right adhesive for it, is all 😉
 
Vote:
Upvote 0
Once upon a time, automobiles were painted by hand, with a brush. Once upon a time, flutes were made with the tone holes bored where they were easy to reach with the fingers, and without regard for whether the resulting notes were in tune. Once upon a time, every board in a house was cut with a hand saw and nailed into place with a hammer. Once upon a time, when you got a cavity in a tooth, the dentist pulled it out. And once upon a time, shellac was used as a general all purpose adhesive for corks and felts on a saxophone.

Today, we have this stuff called "contact cement". It works AMAZINGLY well to attach corks and felts.
 
Vote:
Upvote 0

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,061
Messages
578,378
Members
8,129
Latest member
Bartman
Back
Top Bottom