Theory & Impro Does D7+9 have augmented 5th?

Your voicing with the #5 and natural 9 is something I'd call a 9#11b13.

That's reasonable in many cases, but a ♭13 can also have a perfect 5th as well. Also, although enharmonic, the function is different melodically and harmonically between a 5th being augmented and a 13th being flattened

which is why those are notated #9 rather than +9, the former meaning #9, natural 5 and the later meaning #5, altered 9 (b and or #).
I've never heard of that differentiation, does it come form an authoritative source? (as opposed to Wikipedia which does nonetheless disagree with that assumption).

This debate could go on forever as I would suggest there is no one definitive authoritative source apart from the original meaning of augmented applying only to 4ths and 5ths. But I am happy to concede many people are happy in their own niche with different nomenclatures HOWEVER for me the important thing is that the symbols should be unambiguous in a general sense outside of certain niches.
 
Last edited:
That would seem unambiguous (unlike D7+ 9)

But let’s look at this the other way round. Suppose we agree that D7+9 means that the 9th is sharpened, there is no reason to assume that the 5th is augmented.

In fact with a #9 (or ♭10 ) it is very common for the 5th to be perfect 5th and not augmented.
I think the confusion arises from the mistaken assumption that + is the same as #. It isn't the same. + means #5 and altered extensions. # just means raise one specific chord tone a half step.

To me, + is unambiguous. It means #5 with altered extensions.
 
In thinking about how to write chords, it’s often useful to think about how they work in the tune. In this case, a minor key ii-V-i , the chord Aebersold writes about is what I would call a D7 b9 b13.

Thirteenth chords date back to the Romantic period of classical music, where the 13th often replaces the 5th of the chord. Note that the 13rh of the dominant chord is the third og the key - so in G major, it’s B, and in G minor, it’s Bb. Using the 13th allows one to emphasize the third of the key in the melody, which is how this chord arose in the first place.

I agree that the chord-scale approach is misleading, and often leads to discussions like this one. Unfortunately, it’s kind of a standard approach in jazz education now. To me, it’s WAY more useful to think of these upper extensions in terms of how they function in the key - so playing a b13 over the V chord is really just playing the third of the key, and playing the #9 and b9 lead you down naturally to the fifth of the key. Those notes are from the natural minor scale of the root key.

I think calling this an augmented chord is misleading - but saying it’s a dominant 7th with a flat 9 and flat 13 is saying we’re playing in a minor ky, so use the notes from that key.
 
Thirteenth chords date back to the Romantic period of classical music, where the 13th often replaces the 5th of the chord.
I was taught that the 13th (and other upper extensions) is basically a suspension. These days we often just think of the 4th as a suspension (sus4), but all of the (unaltered) upper extensions started life in classical music as suspensions. So a 9th is a suspended root, 11th suspended 3rd and 13th a suspended 5th. In those days I think the suspension usually has to be "prepared", ie it was a chord note of the previous chord which carried over into the next chord.

So back then a 13th would not have existed at the same time as the 5th whereas these days these suspensions can still have the note they "suspend onto" at the same time.

+ means #5 and altered extensions.
To me that is confusing, it would seem very open to interpretation which is OK for an improvising soloist context but (again from the POV of composer/arranger) not for notating something to be specifically played or voiced.
 
It can have a perfect 5th or a sharpened 5th, no need to get complicated, perfect 5th is in the diminished scale , the sharpened 5th or if you prefer the Flat 13th is in the diminished whole tone scale
 
The explanation can be found in Aebersold's comments at the bottom of the Scale Syllabus page.



Remember Aebersold writes that this is his system of notation. There are others, notably Pete Thomas, who disagree.
Well, that's just nutty.,

Just write C dim.

To me, as a performing musician, if I see C7 and then some other stuff, I'm going to expect C E G Bb and then some other stuff.
 

Similar threads... or are they? Maybe not but they could be worth reading anyway 😀

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,072
Messages
578,588
Members
8,133
Latest member
walthang
Back
Top Bottom