Your voicing with the #5 and natural 9 is something I'd call a 9#11b13.
That's reasonable in many cases, but a ♭13 can also have a perfect 5th as well. Also, although enharmonic, the function is different melodically and harmonically between a 5th being augmented and a 13th being flattened
I've never heard of that differentiation, does it come form an authoritative source? (as opposed to Wikipedia which does nonetheless disagree with that assumption).which is why those are notated #9 rather than +9, the former meaning #9, natural 5 and the later meaning #5, altered 9 (b and or #).
This debate could go on forever as I would suggest there is no one definitive authoritative source apart from the original meaning of augmented applying only to 4ths and 5ths. But I am happy to concede many people are happy in their own niche with different nomenclatures HOWEVER for me the important thing is that the symbols should be unambiguous in a general sense outside of certain niches.
Last edited:
