Playing the saxophone Do you play what you hear or do you move your fingers?

I sing if I'm going to play a melody, riff, solo...... as it's recorded or. performed. And if I'm going to play harmonies when the singer is not singing, guitar player is not playing ....... not the melody I use the other tones in the chord or tones that ar not in the chord.! Of, course, being person that like guitar based blues and rock I often play in E, B, F# and C# (transposed keys) and sometimes I must be more careful with fingering.
 
As @rhysonsax and other people posted being able to sing, or "hear" in your head something of you own can be quite different from playing back what you have just heard. It's not your idea, but an idea by someone else, in fact.
However I think they are the 2 sides of the same coin, because you must identify the intervals in both cases.
The more you do it the more you get better.
A good starting point is playing a melody that you can sing, a simple one, starting from a random note.
A basic knowledge of chords and scales is mandatory in my opinion, because you must match what you sing with the right chord/key.
 
Reading can assist with something you can't quite catch.


No. You?

Not first time, but it's a good thing to work at. My old teacher used to get his pupils working at repeating a phrase back and forth, working with a limited set of notes (e.g. a given pentatonic) over a known harmony. Good for hearing rhythms as well as pitches.

Rhys
 
Not sure about the rest of you who can/do play by ear. I don't need to intellectualize knowing the interval I hear in order to play it any more than someone singing. You hear it, you play it. Otherwise it's an intellectual process of hearing, identifying the interval, visualizing and then playing as though it's dots. If you don't need to do this, why would you? The great players who weren't readers certainly never thought in terms of analysis of intervals, they just played.

However to reiterate, we are individuals with various degrees of aptitude/talent. If you wish to advance as a player then you need to do whatever it is that makes that possible, whether it's ear training to recognize intervals which you "translate", practice the same piece over and over, study transcriptions, develop finger memory for changes, or just work at becoming one with your instrument where you can play what you hear (nothing needed as an intermediary).

There is a problem in teaching where the "one size fits all" type of teaching dictates. For those who are able to play what they hear (in their head or otherwise) it's a disservice to tell them they should be "translating". A good/great teacher recognizes that potential in a student and helps them to attain their goals by methods that will be "natural" to them. I don't think this always matches with an academic approach and could actually retard an otherwise talented player.
 
Yes, @Wade Cornell I agree,surely a big part of teaching is understanding the person who you are teaching at.
Some people may need to practice in a different way than the others.
But knowing intervals can, in my humble opinion be useful to be quicker and to be able to play a melody in all keys.
Let's play the melody from "happy birthday" in B for example. It is a simple melody, but it could be difficult to play in that key if you don't know anything about scales and intervals.
However surely there could be somobody out there that can do it, but not an average player.

Of course being able to be flexible in all keys is not mandatory if you don't play in some contextes.
 

Similar threads... or are they? Maybe not but they could be worth reading anyway 😀

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,076
Messages
578,681
Members
8,136
Latest member
peterdehelegrote
Back
Top Bottom