Saxophone beginners Difference between tenor and alto

I am a beginner and started on alto back in March of 22. I eventually got a tenor to try and these are my thoughts. The tenor is a lot heavier and not as easy to hold correctly. your hands are farther apart which was an issue at first. The tenor's MP is a lot bigger and you will need a lot more air. I have a lot more trouble starting low notes on the tenor and trying to not have them warble or growl. I guess as a beginner the size and weight are the biggest issues.

To me though the sounds produced by the tenor are more pleasing to my ear except for middle D which always sounds muffled to me. By contrast the alto sounds buzzy. This may be because I am now holding the horn with the MP in my mouth instead of listening while standing away from the horn or on speakers.
The kind of music that I like to listen to, oldies rock and pop from the 50s - 70s almost always uses a tenor sax so I aim to continue with playing both every day even though the alto is an easier size to play.
 
Hello to you all.
Can anybody tell me the difference between tenor and alto sax not stating the obvious. I play alot by ear on alto and I know it's the same notes on the tenor, but is the difference when it comes to playing the dots etc music or is it just the transposing what matters, thank you charlie
Do you have a tenor, or are you looking to add one?
Keep an eye on the Yardsale section here, a quality tenor may appear at any time...
 

I am a beginner and started on alto back in March of 22. I eventually got a tenor to try and these are my thoughts. The tenor is a lot heavier and not as easy to hold correctly. your hands are farther apart which was an issue at first. The tenor's MP is a lot bigger and you will need a lot more air. I have a lot more trouble starting low notes on the tenor and trying to not have them warble or growl. I guess as a beginner the size and weight are the biggest issues.

To me though the sounds produced by the tenor are more pleasing to my ear except for middle D which always sounds muffled to me. By contrast the alto sounds buzzy. This may be because I am now holding the horn with the MP in my mouth instead of listening while standing away from the horn or on speakers.
The kind of music that I like to listen to, oldies rock and pop from the 50s - 70s almost always uses a tenor sax so I aim to continue with playing both every day even though the alto is an easier size to play.
A tenor sax compared to an alto is heavier. An alto is 2,3 kg - 2,5 kg and a tenor is 3,2 - 3,5 kg. A tenor sax is bigger and you can have some problem with finding a good playing position. I regret I didn't start to use harnesses earlier. It would probably caused me less pain (back, neck, shoulders .... ). I'm also playing older saxes. A sax with bad ergonomics can be experienced as heavy. 3,2 kg is not much ..... but of course I don't know your age or your physical status.

Middle D (d2) can be tricky, especially on older saxes and when you are pushing. This is my personal opinion. Most guys on CS have no problem with D2, Eb2, E2 on thier vintage saxes. I read a column (NYC repairman) and he had done lots of extra toneholes on five digit Selmer MkVI to open up the tone on D2!! You can try diffent reeds, ligatures and mouthpieces. Try to play D2 with your palm D key. Don't use the octave key. This is maybe more an alternative D2 tone but sometimes the alternative fingering sounds better than the ordinairy fingering. (Better= clear and better intonation?)

Generally you can say a small sax needs more pressure and less air. A bigger saxophone less pressure, more air. I started to play alto. And when I began to play tenor as well, I played the tenor in the same way as I played alto. After some years I discovered that a tenor is a very powerful thing. I like to use the power of the tenor. I know some fine players that play soprano, alto, tenor and barytone in differnt concert-, big bands. Nothing wrong with that. They are almost playing all saxes in the same way. They didn't want me in the big band. Too extreme. I was back then playing a King Super 20 tenor with a BergLarsen (0 chamber). That was a very powerful combo. I liked it. But not the big band conductor ..... . So I gave up the social big band and started to honk on my own.

I like smaller metal mouthpieces. Big tip openings and a chamber with some kind of baffle. I like the old school mouthpiece design (outside). The more I have to open my mouth, the fuller gets the tone.
 
Generally you can say a small sax needs more pressure and less air. A bigger saxophone less pressure, more air.
This is a great analogy. I play ATB - I find alto the hardest work for the embouchure, but it's only when I switch to / from Bari that I remember how much more air the Bari needs (with much less tension on the lips / jaw muscles).

Tenor I have found a very easy blow, even on the relatively hard set up I play with. My horn has an almost honey-sweet tone, I just can't figure out what music to play on it. No issues with middle D being stuffy using the OK, might be the horn or (gasp) the player.
 
Greeting chap, are you saying that your D has the same sound as the palm D
Greetings yourself. No - the palm D is brighter, but when I play middle D with the OK it doesn't sound any stuffier than any of the notes either side (say from F down to B). But - and this is quite important I think - I do voice the note in a way that is distinct from all other notes. Hard to describe exactly what I'm doing but in involves some of - intonation (it's a bit sharp, so I voice it to the correct pitch) & pushing a bit more than the notes either side.

Also something for you to note, that whilst you're playing / practising on your own at home and effectively listening out for the stuffiness you'll think it's a much bigger issue than it is. When you perform (with a degree of competence) you'd probably be surprised how noticeable it is (or isn't). As a sax player with a keen ear you can hear the difference when listening to other players, but your average audience member won't notice it at all, nor will it show up particularly on recordings.
 
@Littleboyblue you can also try adding the Low B key when you play a middle D with the octave key, this will bring the sharpness right down, and will change the colour - but this (colour) is easily manageable with a bit of practice.
 

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,076
Messages
578,679
Members
8,134
Latest member
banjo
Back
Top Bottom