Saxophones Definition of a Stencil saxophone

Pete Thomas

Admin
Cafe Moderator
Messages
23,638
Location
London
Level
Retired professional
(From another thread)

It's not "fake", it's not a "stencil".
Yes definitely not fake but I think [people seem to have different interpretations of the word stencil.

IMO it means one brand manufacturing something in their own factory for another brand, and putting that second brand's logo on it.

But people also use it (rightly or wrongly) to mean any factory (that is not tied to a specific brand ) making something for a brand and putting that brand logo on it.

I tend to favour the first definition because it was probably the original, at least in regard to instruments. I tend to think of big retail outlets wanting their own brand, but without actually being saxophone makers, so they'd do a deal with Martin or whoever to make the horns for them
 
Last edited:
In other parts of the industrial world, the first is called OEM - Original equipment manufacturer. Vitos (and, I suppose, now G4m,Thomann etc.) are OEM instruments.

If 'stencile' mens "design pattern", then someone - eg with access to a no-name factory - could licences the designs from, e.g. Yamaha if they thought it worthwhile and then make an instrument that looks about the same. That's what I thought stencils where.

Often it's worth even well known brands doing either of those to access markets their normal processes cost them out of.

If those designs are reverse engineered, it's a counterfeit.

2¢
 
To me, "Stencil" means "Fred's Music Shoppe" orders 50 horns with "El Freddo Di Saxophone" engraved on them. An actual music instrument company like LeBlanc contracting with a non-LeBlanc factory to produce Vitos is SLIGHTLY different, but not really that different in reality.
 
In other parts of the industrial world, the first is called OEM - Original equipment manufacturer. Vitos (and, I suppose, now G4m,Thomann etc.) are OEM instruments.

If 'stencile' mens "design pattern", then someone - eg with access to a no-name factory - could licences the designs from, e.g. Yamaha if they thought it worthwhile and then make an instrument that looks about the same. That's what I thought stencils where.

Often it's worth even well known brands doing either of those to access markets their normal processes cost them out of.

If those designs are reverse engineered, it's a counterfeit.

2¢
I would NOT call a product that's been reverse engineered a counterfeit. A Counterfeit is a Selmer that's not made by Selmer or purchased by Selmer from a contract factory, it's a Selmer made by someone with zero involvement from Selmer and then LABELED as a Selmer. You can make as identical a copy of a Selmer sax as you wish (as long as you're not infringing any patent, which you won't be given the extreme age of the intellectual property - and it's TOTALLY OK but ONLY if you label it as "Smith Sax Co." or equivalent. What you must not do is to engrave "Selmer" on your copy.
 
I would NOT call a product that's been reverse engineered a counterfeit.
No but it can still be less than legal if it infringes a patent

To be counterfeit it has to be tied in to a branding trademark infringement (ie passing of as ) that is not the same as copying a design or a patent.

There are three main types of IP theft

  • The brand mark, ie trademark = name and/or logo. This must be registered and is based on territory and a time period.
  • The mechanical invention, ie patent. It can apply to many things from a saxophone ligature to a a medicine. This must be registered and is based on territory and a time period.
  • The artistic creation (poetry, music composition, artwork etc...). This does not need to be registered as the original publication is the evidence.
 
No but it can still be less than legal if it infringes a patent

To be counterfeit it has to be tied in to a branding trademark infringement (ie passing of as ) that is not the same as copying a design or a patent.

There are three main types of IP theft

  • The brand mark (trademark = name and/or logo. This must be registered and is based on territory and a time period.
  • The mechanical invention, ie patent. It can apply to many things from a saxophone ligature to a a medicine. This must be registered and is based on territory and a time period.
  • The artistic creation (poetry, music composition, artwork etc...). This does not need to be registered as the original publication is the evidence
I agree. I have a curved soprano which is lovely, but it has a trademark (which begins with Y) which does not belong, it also says 'Made in Japan' on it ( it was made in China) and it even has a fake serial number. It is worthless to anybody but me. I can never sell it, and have no intentions of doing so.
 
A stencil saxophone is a sax that it's made for X by Y. The stencils saxes were often an old model. Anyone seen a King Super 20 stencil built by H.N.White for .... .? The engraving and the stamped serial number was done at the factory by the manufacture. All costs for patents and design was included in the price. I think USA had a standard for stencils. Europe had another due to the iron curtain. It's not illegal to buy blanks. But it's not ok to buy blanks that is using patents that the manufacture don't have the rights to use. Hard to know?? It's legal to buy a container of blanks and engrave your own brand/name on it. But the country where the sax was made should be stamped on the sax.
 
We used to get it on pianos where you could get stencil names to put on where the manufacturers name should be, (as they were sometimes left blank - or the stencil name might come off if it was refinished.)
On saxophones a stencil is one where the name isn't the manufacturers name or brand. Leblanc owned the Vito name so to me a Vito made by Leblanc isn't a stencil, but a Vito made by Beagnier or someone else could be considered a stencil.
There used to be a bit more of a clear line where companies like Martin would use their latest keywork design for their own brand and use older designs, usually the old Handcraft, for stencils with many different names appearing on Martin-made instruments.
Today a lot of Chinese instruments are produced and I'm not sure if any have the manufacturer's name on them. And they oftne don't have country of origin on them either. I'm not sure if these are counted as stencils as they don't come from a recognised maker and could be put together from different manufacturers. They tend to copy Yanagisawa or Yamaha designs but not exactly enough to be copies. Most of the fakes don't copy the design properly, which is one way of spotting them - so I'm not sure what you call those?
 
Having looked into trademarks recently there are also different categories of goods. If I wanted to make Selmer pies, so long as nobody has already registered Selmer as a pie trademark, I could.

And even within the "food" category there are further sections, so you might have Pukka Pies and Pukka Tea.

You can't copy a registered logo though, even if in a different category. So a stylised "Selmer" or "Yanagisawa" IF registered in its stylised version as well as registering it as the brand name cannot be used by others under any circumstances.
 
Last edited:
I agree. I have a curved soprano which is lovely, but it has a trademark (which begins with Y) which does not belong, it also says 'Made in Japan' on it ( it was made in China) and it even has a fake serial number. It is worthless to anybody but me. I can never sell it, and have no intentions of doing so.
We've had this argument elsewhere, but to me your post reads similar to this: I bought some cocaine, just for me, but have no intention of selling it.

Straying into the Fakes thread again?
 
If I wanted to make Selmer pies, so long as nobody has already registered Selmer as a pie trademark, I could.
Just wait for the Fray bentos saxophone.
You can't copy a registered logo though, even if in a different category.
A trademark can be both text and artwork.

If the logo includes artwork, (as many do) there could probably be an infringement of the artist's copyright.

So if I brought out a McDonalds brand saxophone I imagine their trademark doesn't cover musical instruments (but I haven't checked).

But I could not (legally) use the "iconic" M logo.

Likewise your Selmer Pie could not (legally) use the Selmer logo or abbreviated S. having said that it' could be moot if McDonalds or Selmer didn't care and so don't sue. But they could do.
 
Hmmm, we're strying off the path a bit here. McDonald's have a history of sueing people that have nothign to do with their products, but use the name. They sued a food chop in Scotland that existed before McDonald's did in the US. But these people use the law here whereas most of the counterfeit products seem to originate in China and they don't seem to care about protecting 'our' brands and court cases can go in favour of the Chinese company because they are the local interest.

I have customers that use a Yamaha or Yanagisawa with a Selmer neck bearing their S logo. That could potentially be a problem but I doubt anyone is going to get sued there. There have been previous examples of The Selmer S being copied on MkVI copies with some name like Selman on them. For the most part its not worth Selmer's time going to court over some cheap copy.
The recent level of counterfeiting by China is a real concern though and I think our government should put more pressure on China to reduce counterfeiting. Basically anything made in China gets copied and they'll copy anything else that sells now. Nothing is sacred. It's not really feasable to take legal action there.
 
There used to be a bit more of a clear line where companies like Martin would use their latest keywork design for their own brand and use older designs, usually the old Handcraft, for stencils with many different names appearing on Martin-made instruments.
Not only the keyword design. Just one brand that used the Committee Body/tonholes and that was Reynolds. It was RMC that made Martin and Reynolds saxes. Before RMC it was Martin Band Instruments Company.
 
Hmmm, we're strying off the path a bit here. McDonald's have a history of sueing people that have nothign to do with their products, but use the name. They sued a food chop in Scotland that existed before McDonald's did in the US. But these people use the law here whereas most of the counterfeit products seem to originate in China and they don't seem to care about protecting 'our' brands and court cases can go in favour of the Chinese company because they are the local interest.

I have customers that use a Yamaha or Yanagisawa with a Selmer neck bearing their S logo. That could potentially be a problem but I doubt anyone is going to get sued there. There have been previous examples of The Selmer S being copied on MkVI copies with some name like Selman on them. For the most part its not worth Selmer's time going to court over some cheap copy.
Didn't Rolls Royce sue someone for putting a flying lady mascot on their non-RR bonnet?
Interesting point about the S neck, but which of Selmer or Yanagisawa would sue the sax owner. Maybe both?
 
I have customers that use a Yamaha or Yanagisawa with a Selmer neck bearing their S logo. That could potentially be a problem
No, that won't be an issue. The horn says "Yamaha", and it was made by Yamaha. The neck says "Selmer" and it was made by them. Everyone's been paid the proper going rate for their product. No one's going to claim a Yamaha saxophone with "Yamaha" prominently engraved on the bell is a Selmer based on it having a Selmer neck.
 
Not only the keyword design. Just one brand that used the Committee Body/tonholes and that was Reynolds. It was RMC that made Martin and Reynolds saxes. Before RMC it was Martin Band Instruments Company.
A second-line horn (Reynolds, Indiana, Cleveland, Pan American) isn't what I'd consider a "stencil".
 
A second-line horn (Reynolds, Indiana, Cleveland, Pan American) isn't what I'd consider a "stencil".
Martin, Reynolds and Blessing were all saxes that RMC made. Reynolds Contempora can be a stencil but I don't think so. Just another version of a "The Martin". Differnt keytouches, keyguards .... but it have the Committee toneholes. Good pictures that I found on internet.
contempora-visser.jpg
 
Once saxophone makers would have their own brands. 1st and 2nd tier saxes that would be readily recognised as pro or beginner. These same manufacturers would also sell to businesses engaged in supplying large volumes to schools or the military and because of cost would sell past inventory or low cost (no engraving, cheaper pads, generic mpc….etc) to them. They in turn would then put their own logo on the bell and sometimes have some engraving done. Ergo Stencil.
Today it’s more difficult to say because there are many saxophone manufacturers in Asia who do not market a particular brand. Just bought the old tooling from Yamaha or Conn and started making saxes. The moulds are then copied and recopied and sold to other manufacturers. With every copy the sax quality gets worse. Anyone can order a few 100 and put their own name on it. Stencil? If one can find out which known sax’s tooling was used to make it but most likely it will be a hybrid.
 

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,076
Messages
578,677
Members
8,134
Latest member
banjo
Back
Top Bottom