Playing the saxophone Daily practice.

@Wade Cornell that's kind of what my teacher said, learn my scales playing around the circle of 5ths, hear what each scale is like, not play from written scales.

Which does work, but then I'm useless when asked how many sharps in F# major, what key signature is this in, or told the pentatonic scale is just the 1st, 2nd, 3rd, 5th & 6th degrees.

Of course you could argue my teacher should be teaching me this, but he's been right with everything so far, I need to pull my finger out.
 
@Wade Cornell that's kind of what my teacher said, learn my scales playing around the circle of 5ths, hear what each scale is like, not play from written scales.

Which does work, but then I'm useless when asked how many sharps in F# major, what key signature is this in, or told the pentatonic scale is just the 1st, 2nd, 3rd, 5th & 6th degrees.

Of course you could argue my teacher should be teaching me this, but he's been right with everything so far, I need to pull my finger out.
2 little acronyms..
 
I struggle remembering those :doh:

Takes me ages to remember people's names too, even now I call people I play with the wrong name, then know it's wrong but can't remember the right name... Not even hit 40 yet either 😱
Me too, mske up your own ive only sussed the # side nearly ( thanks @lydian ) Cool Gorillas Do Aerobics Bare ( for) Fun CGDAEBF all the key sigs other one Fat Cats Go Down Alleys Eating Birds all the sharps..Order of FCGDAEB..sounds complecated but theres no sharps in C major, 1 sharp in G 2 in D etc. So if you wanted the notes in the scale of E m..Cool Gorrillas Do Aerobics Evenings, 5 moves round the circle equals 4 sharps ( just minus one for Cm) 4th letter of Fat Cats Go Down so sharps are FCGD scale equals E root F # G# A B C# D# E. It's probably easier than Ive made it sound..You can make up your own accronyms whatever works for you..
 
How can you best achieve this?
Pre-requisite A: Learn every note on your instrument and be able to play it instantly without thinking. In other words, if you read a D, you're not consulting a fingering chart. Your fingers automatically go to D and you have a good idea what's going to come out of your horn (not low D or high D if you're trying to play middle D).

Pre-requisite B: Learn your major scales. This gets ordered sequences of notes under your fingers and in your ears. If you know the C scale, try to play the G scale by ear without reading it or thinking about the key signature, just using interval recognition. Now try the D scale and so on. Extra credit, play some arpeggios by ear.

Phase 1: Sing a random note then play it on your horn. At first you'll hunt and peck a lot. But eventually you'll make the connection and get up to a very high success rate. You'll also just be able to imagine a note and play it without singing it first. Do this a lot, every day.

Phase 2: Learn what different intervals sound like - semi-tone, whole-tone, minor third, major third, etc. Find them in familiar tunes - Twinkle Twinkle Little Star - perfect 5th, Here Comes the Bride - perfect 4th, etc. Also do this every day with every song you hear.

Put these together and you'll eventually be able to play any tune by ear.
 
Pre-requisite A: Learn every note on your instrument and be able to play it instantly without thinking. In other words, if you read a D, you're not consulting a fingering chart. Your fingers automatically go to D and you have a good idea what's going to come out of your horn (not low D or high D if you're trying to play middle D).

Pre-requisite B: Learn your major scales. This gets ordered sequences of notes under your fingers and in your ears. If you know the C scale, try to play the G scale by ear without reading it or thinking about the key signature, just using interval recognition. Now try the D scale and so on. Extra credit, play some arpeggios by ear.

Phase 1: Sing a random note then play it on your horn. At first you'll hunt and peck a lot. But eventually you'll make the connection and get up to a very high success rate. You'll also just be able to imagine a note and play it without singing it first. Do this a lot, every day.

Phase 2: Learn what different intervals sound like - semi-tone, whole-tone, minor third, major third, etc. Find them in familiar tunes - Twinkle Twinkle Little Star - perfect 5th, Here Comes the Bride - perfect 4th, etc. Also do this every day with every song you hear.

Put these together and you'll eventually be able to play any

Pre-requisite A: Learn every note on your instrument and be able to play it instantly without thinking. In other words, if you read a D, you're not consulting a fingering chart. Your fingers automatically go to D and you have a good idea what's going to come out of your horn (not low D or high D if you're trying to play middle D).

Pre-requisite B: Learn your major scales. This gets ordered sequences of notes under your fingers and in your ears. If you know the C scale, try to play the G scale by ear without reading it or thinking about the key signature, just using interval recognition. Now try the D scale and so on. Extra credit, play some arpeggios by ear.

Phase 1: Sing a random note then play it on your horn. At first you'll hunt and peck a lot. But eventually you'll make the connection and get up to a very high success rate. You'll also just be able to imagine a note and play it without singing it first. Do this a lot, every day.

Phase 2: Learn what different intervals sound like - semi-tone, whole-tone, minor third, major third, etc. Find them in familiar tunes - Twinkle Twinkle Little Star - perfect 5th, Here Comes the Bride - perfect 4th, etc. Also do this every day with every song you hear.

Put these together and you'll eventually be able to play any tune by ear.
Shoot..take the advice..
 
View: https://youtu.be/Kk8r5U0weksIt's
a completely different set of skills that all great players mastered. You hum a tune and they can play it. If you can't, then what is your connection to your instrument?
Can you give me some ideas how I practice this? I use sing instead of humming. It's that bad?

We had a workshop with a player that covers some styles that are used in Rock. All scales were in concert A so we could compare. We played improvised solos over the chord tones.We dicovred that some scales we better than others The teacher also demonstrate what we should beware of and how to borrow from other scales to make the solos more interesting. Do you think that is bad?

I have never done any deeper scale study. The teacher demonstrate how to practice with scales. I think that is harmless?

View: https://youtu.be/Kk8r5U0weks
 
Last edited:
Learn every note on your instrument and be able to play it instantly without thinking
Same reason I was told not confuse enharmonics, Bb is not the same A#, despite the same fingerings. It sounds daft, but another little thing that works well for me.

You'll also just be able to imagine a note
My first lesson involved lots of imagining, and 'now play it better', the wife must have thought what on earth is this guy smoking, some of the random things I've been told to imagine whilst playing (being locked inside a postbox my favourite) but it's worked.

I've been told to learn to play simple tunes like happy birthday, then play in a different keys, I imagine for similar reasoning regards intervals.
 
… I was told not confuse enharmonics, Bb is not the same A#, despite the same fingerings.
That’s what music theory is all about, to bring us to a higher level of understanding. If distinct enharmonics does that for you, that’s great. But that would be too much mental gymnastics for me when an extra millisecond of thought means missing a note. So they’re equivalent to me. Bring on the C flats and F flats. I ain’t afraid of you.
 
Lots of good replies, especially from lydian. I'd only add that when playing by ear it's not necessary or desirable to be trying to think of the key, mode or anything else. If you're continually doing this it's like having to translate in order to speak.

Knowledge of music and theory allows us to talk to each other and analyze specific aspects of music. However that's not necessarily a great way to play as "reverse engineering". Similarly we can take classes in English, spell perfectly and know every rule of grammar, however that doesn't make you a good writer, only a good editor. Creativity works best when it's direct: you hear what you want to play (as you would sing it), and use your instrument to sing for you.

When improvising I'm never aware of the key, mode, or anything else, although I could stop analyze it, and then tell you. Creativity is about flow, and being in the moment. It's ears to hands without analysis and never starting by visualizing or conceiving of what should be played according to theory or what someone else would have played.

Learning to play by ear seems to work most of the time for very young children (3 to 5 year olds) using the Suzuki method of teaching. They learn to play music by ear without reference to written music or theory. Later they learn the rest (reading, theory, etc.). The idea behind this is that learning to play by ear, like singing, is the same as learning your native language. Similarly it's more difficult for many of us to learn to speak a different language as we age. There will be enormous differences between individuals in how difficult this may be. Learning to play by ear will take varying amounts of effort for different individuals.

Academic teaching of music completely avoids this and instead promotes that anyone can learn music by reading (developing an eye to hand mental pathway). That works in the same way that painting by numbers results in a picture, but does it make you an artist? Similarly improvisation is taught as "theory" (not the same as the general study of music theory) that doesn't require creativity, only recognizing chord movement and playing "cut and paste "riffs and arpeggios" that are practiced in order to achieve speed/dexterity. Some players eventually grow beyond this and become truly creative, but for many/most it's another dead end.

OK, that's a lot to digest and it's mainly aimed at those who are very serious about becoming creative players. It's also OK to just play music for fun and not have those ambitions. Reading a piece of music and enjoying the result can be satisfying and for many all that they wish. Likewise improvising by just playing the written changes and challenging yourself to plug in those riffs and arpeggios ever faster can be a hard won achievement. However one shouldn't mistake these for being the same as developing yourself as a creative musician.
 
@Wade Cornell that's kind of what my teacher said, learn my scales playing around the circle of 5ths, hear what each scale is like, not play from written scales.

Which does work, but then I'm useless when asked how many sharps in F# major, what key signature is this in, or told the pentatonic scale is just the 1st, 2nd, 3rd, 5th & 6th degrees.

Of course you could argue my teacher should be teaching me this, but he's been right with everything so far, I need to pull my finger out.
Don't spend money on having a teacher to show you basic theory. I played in concert A, E, B early without knowing what key and scale I played in. I was , still is, playing what I heard and wanted to play on my sax. By ear. I tried to play major and major pentatonic in F# (F#, G#, A#, B, C#, D#, F and F#,G#,A#, C#,D#) and I also played F# blues scale (F#, A, B, C, C#, E) without knowing what key, key signature or the tones in different keys .... . Of course, I used the basic fingerings as well. You can find out this on your own.

Later I met player and teachers that like and played the same music as I did. They explained about the different scales and what to stay out from, how to use different fingerings to get a better flow, how to dispose a given solo (length) ...... . The teachers and experienced players experiences was valuable. I was ready to spend my money on their knowledge.

I practicing to play with others and for a small audience. That is why I'm playing, even if I spend most of the time playing alone in the woodshed.

Music is not easy. We know a lot, but why are we not playing better
 
Don't spend money on having a teacher to show you basic theory.
I won't, he puts the responsibility to learn that myself.

It is getting to a point where it is starting to hold me back.

Can you explain that? I can understand someone thinking basic theory isn't something they can be bothered with, but I don't see how it holds someone back.
 
I won't, he puts the responsibility to learn that myself. It is getting to a point where it is starting to hold me back.
For me more knowledge (theory and the "practical sax playing") is to find a common language. Maybe more a social thing? But also a way to reduce some "try and failure". I can't see anything bad with reading a Rock & Roll Saxophone article with the headline:

"Learning To love The Key Of E Concert" and with intermediate headlines like;

  • Scale selections in E concert
  • Alternating alternative fingerings
  • Favorite overtone fingering
  • Also go with major scales and major pentatonics
  • Reading and playing horn section parts
  • Background lines in E concert
  • Double sharps
  • A mention about transcribing and tunes you should know
Nothing wrong with improvising in it's purest form, visualization, give tones licks to different stimuli ..... for me this it's just tools to became a better player. I'm practicing this quite often.
 
Can you explain that? I can understand someone thinking basic theory isn't something they can be bothered with, but I don't see how it holds someone back

@thomsax probably puts it better it's the common language, and communication.

I think I've said before, when someone said to me "it's only the B pentatonic scale" that's great, provided you know the B major scale, and how to transform that (or any other scale) into a pentatonic, or have memorised the B pentatonic.

Same with the blues scales, relative minors. It's to Google it, or be told it's just X scale with with XYZ changed, but trying to get that to stick in my head :doh:

As soon as people start talking scales, keys, my eyes glaze over and a more gormless expression descends across my face.

Granted it doesn't interfere with the physical playing, reading music, but I don't want to be tied to playing from sheet music.
 
@thomsax probably puts it better it's the common language, and communication.

I think I've said before, when someone said to me "it's only the B pentatonic scale" that's great, provided you know the B major scale, and how to transform that (or any other scale) into a pentatonic, or have memorised the B pentatonic.

Same with the blues scales, relative minors. It's to Google it, or be told it's just X scale with with XYZ changed, but trying to get that to stick in my head :doh:

As soon as people start talking scales, keys, my eyes glaze over and a more gormless expression descends across my face.

Granted it doesn't interfere with the physical playing, reading music, but I don't want to be tied to playing from sheet music.
Bare....4 #s.. Fat Cats Go Down.. worth learning the basics..ive got a terrrible memory but think the basics are worth retaining..at least when you transpose you can check your right..To be fair and taking it onto improv I aways write the notes from the scale on top of my 1st sheet .it's a ref point for infills and learning what riffs work..at least if you can write the scale out and have a reference to what a pentatonic is you have all that to work with..
 
I think I've said before, when someone said to me "it's only the B pentatonic scale" that's great, provided you know the B major scale, and how to transform that (or any other scale) into a pentatonic, or have memorised the B pentatonic.

Yes I understand that, but don't understand how taking steps to learn it would hold you back.

but I don't want to be tied to playing from sheet music.
And if that's the case, all the more reason to learn scales that can help you not be tied to playing from sheet music
 
but trying to get that to stick in my head
I have an appalling declarative memory (names, dates, stand alone facts), always have (Not just age)
One thing I've found helps (As I posted earlier) is to practice (maj, min) scales, arpeggios etc. in the key of the piece I'm leaning/practicing, as warmup. Add in pentatonics etc. and diatonics and you practice a huge chunk of fingerings in the piece; as well as getting the ear tuned in to the tones of the pieces.
Obviously the more unusual keys need to be done on purpose.

For added value; try playing the exercises using a rhythmic shape from the piece.
 

Similar threads... or are they? Maybe not but they could be worth reading anyway 😀

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,072
Messages
578,571
Members
8,133
Latest member
walthang
Back
Top Bottom