Young Col
Senior Member
- Messages
- 2,196
- Location
- Coulsdon, London/Surrey
Mrs YC and I were fortunate to get tickets for the excellent Leonardo di Vinci exhibition at the National Gallery in London last week. It finishes this week.
One of the featured paintings is Portait of a Young man ("The Musician"). It's a striking and, for the time, innovative, portrait of a young man holding a piece of music. The music has been folded concertina style and is part opened. While it is difficult to see all of it clearly because of shade, in several of the folds, one of them very clear, the stave has 6 lines, while the others have the five we would expect today. Most of it is a continous line of music across the folds.The lower 6th line has no notes on it so is not a short ledger line as we would understand it now.
Does anyone know - perhaps Tenor Viol? - how music was laid out then? Were there 6 lines if required? It's not clear what pitch clef it is intended to be. The painting was done in the late 1480s. It seems unlikely that it was a naive mistake. Da Vinci was an accomplished lyreist/lutenist and taught others. It had been suggested that the painting was originally done mostly by DaVinci's pupils but it is now recognised that it is primarily his work. Again, surely unlikely that he would let such an error pass if it wasn't all his own work. Intriguingly the hand holding the music and the music itself, at the bottom right of the portrait, were painted over at some time and only rediscovered in 1905 (the painting until then being thought to be of a duke of Milan). I suppose it's possible that restorers added the 6th line, but why not across the whole piece and again, surely such an error would have been spotted?
The exhibtion booklet that we bought has extensive notes about the painting, including the late discovery of the over-painted music, but no explanation of the inconsistent number of lines on the stave.
Any thoughts anyone?
YC
One of the featured paintings is Portait of a Young man ("The Musician"). It's a striking and, for the time, innovative, portrait of a young man holding a piece of music. The music has been folded concertina style and is part opened. While it is difficult to see all of it clearly because of shade, in several of the folds, one of them very clear, the stave has 6 lines, while the others have the five we would expect today. Most of it is a continous line of music across the folds.The lower 6th line has no notes on it so is not a short ledger line as we would understand it now.
Does anyone know - perhaps Tenor Viol? - how music was laid out then? Were there 6 lines if required? It's not clear what pitch clef it is intended to be. The painting was done in the late 1480s. It seems unlikely that it was a naive mistake. Da Vinci was an accomplished lyreist/lutenist and taught others. It had been suggested that the painting was originally done mostly by DaVinci's pupils but it is now recognised that it is primarily his work. Again, surely unlikely that he would let such an error pass if it wasn't all his own work. Intriguingly the hand holding the music and the music itself, at the bottom right of the portrait, were painted over at some time and only rediscovered in 1905 (the painting until then being thought to be of a duke of Milan). I suppose it's possible that restorers added the 6th line, but why not across the whole piece and again, surely such an error would have been spotted?
The exhibtion booklet that we bought has extensive notes about the painting, including the late discovery of the over-painted music, but no explanation of the inconsistent number of lines on the stave.
Any thoughts anyone?
YC
