Saxophones Curved Yani Sop wear indicator?

DavidUK

Well-Known Member
Messages
8,133
Location
Near Evesham, Worcestershire
Idly surfing, spotted a Yani 901 sop...

Looks OK here...

Screenshot 2022-11-09 at 15.55.47.webp


...and here...

Screenshot 2022-11-09 at 15.56.22.webp


...but close up of palm key/s and G# shows corrosion/wear. Would this worry anyone...

Screenshot 2022-11-09 at 16.07.07.webp


If it were a normal used price, say £1,000, would you buy it and not worry?
(That's not to say I'll buy it until it drops into bargain price territory!)
 
I do actually like more patinated horns, most of mine are worn and it saves the initial anguish of the first mark on a mint one. But then most of my horns (Selmer, Yani, Yamaha, Buffet, etc) have cost only a few hundred pounds so I can't have cheap and mint anyhow.

I'll chase this one a little more, but I'll probably wait for one to come along at a couple of hundred.
 
Would you consider any curved sop better than a Yani?
It depends. Just sold my SC991. It was superbly built, no question, but tonewise it did not really appeal to me. I was in London this summer and took a chance to test several sopranos at sax.co.uk: SCW010, SCW20, Rampone curved and a Yamaha YSS82ZR. The least to my liking was the SCW010. The SCW020 sounded sliggtly warmer and a tiny bit broader. I found all Yanagisawa curvies I have tested so far rather resistant. Of the curvies the Rampone had the best sound to me with good keywork but the intonation would require more attention. However, the YSS82ZR simply blew them out of the water. It was better in about every way.

Coming back to curvies my first soprano was a curvy Schagerl (Austrian brand, Taiwanese horns). In hindsight I regret having sold it. It was easy to play, great sounding with very easy intonation. Being lured away by the reputation of of other models may not be wise…

Mechanically the Yanagisawas are hard to beat. The rest is up to your decision.

Alphorn
 
The problem for me is I can't get on with a straight or straight with a curved neck soprano, so I have to use the curved sop, its my back problem, holding a straight just gives me massive pain, I would like to try a R&C curvy but they too expensive so I am happy with my 20 years old Yani.
 
That is typical of Yanagisawa lacquer - in fact, it shows less wear than I would expect. I wore the finish off the palm keys and touches in the first years of owning two SC-992 sops (each was relatively new when I bought them).

I haven't played the R&C sops, but much preferred the SC-992 to my Selmer Serie III. Ultimately, I was won over by a Borgani Jubilee sop (fixed bent neck). I would love to play one of their curved sops.
 
They aren’t made anymore but I found the Bauhaus Walstein curved sop at least as good as an old Yani curved I had. I was initially won over by the intonation at the top on the BW. I sold the Yani and didn’t play much for some years. I would have liked to try them head to head again now I have been playing sop a lot again as the BW is very flat on bottom C and B but the more I play the more I accommodate for it. I was going to get rid of the B-W curved for a straight one but found it fitted in my Brompton bike bag in a Berkeley of London case so I whizz around by bike and train with instrument stands and music on the front of the bike. I would love to try the B-W and Yani head to head now that I have some regular playing under my belt but at the time there was little in it with modest bias to B-W. The sticky pads on my B-W curved worse than straight sop are a pain but not pain enough for me to have replaced any yet.
 
From the title, I was thinking of a wear indicator on a horn,
kind of like the bars on your tyres when it's past time to buy a new set.

"Dah, don't buy that Conn, the wear indicators are showing."

In the pics, that looks like the finish is failing (crazing), not wearing.
Needs to be played more.

Says he whose chops are almost non- existent.

t
pointedly not thinking about wear indicators on people, thanks very much, Colin.
 

Similar threads... or are they? Maybe not but they could be worth reading anyway 😀

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,075
Messages
578,674
Members
8,134
Latest member
banjo
Back
Top Bottom