Miscellaneous Copyright or the lack of it

Fraser Jarvis

Senior Member
Messages
1,794
Thought I’d run this past the members here as the subject of copyright has been raised before. Ok so this morning I find yet another competitors website that has ripped off at least one of our photos from linked in, the last one i saw was an American company who were using one of our work pictures (with me on it!) to promote the fact that they carry out the same kind of work, I pointed out that if they do the same work and use the same equipment then surely they have their own pictures to use, I basically got told to get stuffed. So I’m wondering were i stand legally with this?

So this afternoon I’ve found an app called watermark my photos, I’ve had a quick go with it and I can get a neat looking result with the company name in the bottom corner but am guessing that if anyone wants to use the picture they can simply crop the watermark off the bottom of the picture? So now im thinking about using the kind that professional photographers use that runs across the picture in a kind of grey blur but can’t seem to find anything that fits the bill so my question would be does anyone know how to achieve this without resorting to photo shop (which I don’t have).

And lastly, if I watermark my pictures will it automatically transfer to the same picture that has been ripped off? This would be good!

Thanks in advance.
 
As I understand it; copyright arises. In the UK, anyway.
Writing © or such is evidential (reduces the offenders ability to claim ignorance) ... and watermarking really only has the added affect of making the picture harder to use. Which is good because perusing a claim can be expensive.
There's also the issue of the social media small print... Iirc Facebook makes a claim over material posted there (so they can use it for AI and such) (while claiming "safe harbor" protection for themselves, which, IMHO, is outrageous)
 
Watermarking does not confer copyright. It is purely a notification that a copyright exists.

The image is your copyright automatically when it is first published

EDIT I now should back to my original unedited post as Targa has confirmed my initial supposition the copyright exists on creation of the photo.

it should be quite easy to prove this ownership
 
Last edited:
Legally the copyright of a photograph belongs to the person who took it, regardless who is in it.
However they cannot use it to imply that a person it shows prominently endorses a product without their permission.
I think that came about after Cadbury's showed Queen Victoria in an advertisement for cocoa.
Other companies then also used her image for their products.
qv.jpg
 
Last edited:
Legally the copyright of a photograph belongs to the person who took it, regardless who is in it.
That is may be an interesting argument. I’m sure that is correct when the photo is taken in a public place, but a photographer and or publication may still need the consent of a model in order to publish said image.
 
If it’s on a website, send an official take down notice not just to the owner of the site but also to the host and domain registrar.

My wife recently did this, it was a charity website and she also threatened to send it to their trustees.
 
That is may be an interesting argument. I’m sure that is correct when the photo is taken in a public place, but a photographer and or publication may still need the consent of a model in order to publish said image.
Not only a public place, it also applies to such as studio portraits or weddings for example.
I'd expect models to have some sort of contract for professional work which would cover when, where and why it can be used.
If you enter a photographic competition the rules will state something like you agree to the image being used in anything connected with the competition.
 
I remember wanting to publish some dash cam footage on a car forum but as it was taken in a dealership's private workshop I needed those filmed to give permission. It wasn't something they'd have agreed to.

My plumber found another plumber locally whose initials were identical. Both used "A P W Plumbing & Heating" on their vans and the other was getting business on the back of my one's reputation. My one had his solicitor warn off the other as he was last to the party.
 
So really it's the same as music recording. If I write and record a tune, the copyright is mine in the whole thing, both the actual recording and composition. And as soon as it is published (whether on a CD, radio/TV/ or digital audio medium than that first publication is proof of copyright.

But as with models in a photo, I need the consent of any performers (and similar to what Targa said, those rights are often paid for depending on usage - often there is no "buyout" for all useage rights).

It may have changed, but for example a typical union recording session for a movie, would often be just for the movie and if a soundtrack album is released, then a second payment has to be made to the musicians.
 
Both used "A P W Plumbing & Heating" on their vans and the other was getting business on the back of my one's reputation. My one had his solicitor warn off the other as he was last to the party.
That's an interesting case if neither had registered a trademark. It would myabe have been an expensive case to bring to trial, so I imagine may have just been the threat of litigtaion that made the second one back down. Very expensive for both parties that would have been a very simple if a trademark existed for plumber A.
 
Legally the copyright of a photograph belongs to the person who took it, regardless who is in it.
However they cannot use it to imply that a person it shows prominently endorses a product without their permission.

100% correct. In the UK and USA, anyway.

If you use an image for anything other than reportage, then you must have the permission of every recognisable person in that image. The face doesn't even need to be visible to be considered recognisable. If someone who knows the person in the image could recognise that person then you need permission. There was a famous test case in the US where a person was in an advert without permission. They were shot from behind but it was argued that her arse was recognisable to people who knew her. She won the case.

Even with reportage, you can't misrepresent the person in the image without permission.

However, copyright law is very, very expensive to argue. Most people simply don't have the funds to launch a case no matter how 'open and closed' the case may be.
 

Similar threads... or are they? Maybe not but they could be worth reading anyway 😀

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,072
Messages
578,574
Members
8,133
Latest member
walthang
Back
Top Bottom