jbtsax
R.I.P. in memoriam 1947 - 2023
- Messages
- 8,985
- Location
- Beautiful Springville, Utah USA
Nederveen in "acoustical aspects of woodwind instruments on p. 87 writes:
"Influence of Wall Vibrations on a Simplified Wind Instrument" by Nief, Gautier, Dalmont, and Gilbert
It is widely known and accepted that the "interior geometry" of a woodwind instrument has a great deal of influence over the sound. Claims that wall material, finishes, adding mass etc. make a difference are still present in saxophone lore, but to date there has been no peer reviewed scientific research to back up any of those claims.
With regard to the wall material having an effect upon the soundwaves inside the tube, this is from a study entitled:In two places alto and tenor saxophones have bends in the bore. The crook in the upper part of the bore shows very low curvature and does not exercise any appreciable difference. The reverse is the case for the sharp bend in the lower part. This bend affects only the lowest notes and does not even come into play for the upper register. . . In section 37 it was shown that such sharp bends correspond to a shortening and widening of the equivalent straight tube, where the differences may be of the order of 5% for the curved parts.
"Influence of Wall Vibrations on a Simplified Wind Instrument" by Nief, Gautier, Dalmont, and Gilbert
I have measured several vintage and new tenor necks in my shop and the wall thickness at the small end averages about 1.8 mm. The wall thickness at the large end before the tenon averages 1.5mm. A thickness of .65mm is quite unusual where American and Japanese made instruments are concerned.. . . in order to obtain measurable effects of wall vibrations, the geometrical parameters of the studied tube have to be
unusual compared to that of real instruments. For a slightly oval-shaped and very thin brass tube [.2 mm], it is shown theoretically and experimentally that a coupling between the inner plane acoustic wave and ovalling mechanical modes occurs and results in disturbances of the input impedance, which can slightly affect the tone color of the sound produced. It is concluded that the reported effects are unlikely to occur in real instruments except for some organ pipes.
It is widely known and accepted that the "interior geometry" of a woodwind instrument has a great deal of influence over the sound. Claims that wall material, finishes, adding mass etc. make a difference are still present in saxophone lore, but to date there has been no peer reviewed scientific research to back up any of those claims.
