Saxophones Choosing a Tenor

anlos

New Member
Messages
1
Location
France
So I've been borrowing an alto for a while but what I really want to play is tenor, I was looking at the Yamaha YTS-280 but then I got to thinking that it might be more worth it to just spend the extra and get either a Yanagisawa T-WO1 or a even a T-WO10.

So I'm just wondering what you all would do and think about it
 
Yamahas are very robust with good intonation, acceptable tone and are mouthpiece friendly.
Yanagisawas are slightly different ergonomically and have a certain sound to them.

You need to try them both to see which fits your hands and appeals to your ear.
 
From a cost aspect, the 3 horns you mention are aimed at different sectors of the market when new. Certainly the YTS 280 to the Yani TW01 anyway.
I always see the Yam 280 advertised as a student model but not the Yani TW01, which is rather more expensive.
The TW010 costs more again for features that make it different but do not claim to be a better playing sax than the TW01 in other ways.
Between the 2 Yanis there will be pro's and con's depending on your requirements. The weight difference is significant.
The Yamaha need not sound any less of a horn or feel like any less of a horn than the Yanis but it will be fairly plain looking in comparison to more expensive horns from both manufacturers.
So whats most important to you?
Plenty of used examples of all 3 out there.

My only warning is this.....chopping and changing makes your final destination sax a more expensive journey/purchase.
It feels like you already have reservations about the Yamaha and could be moving on so in that respect you can short cut this part of the journey and get closer to your destination.

But then if you have the opportunity to try each, that reservation I'm feeling from your post could evaporate as you may well like the Yamaha.
In a nutshell the extra money is always worth it, if its the right horn and stops you needing to spend again and again.
If you aren't sure don't do anything until you've played them all.
 
Last edited:
Yamaha 280 series saxes are great quality and good value. There is some internet chat about how current models made in Indonesia are not as well made as the Japanese-built 275 and earlier series. I think that's rubbish, having had both.

However, I think the Yanagisawa ranges are just a bit better built and have a very adaptable sound. A fair few years ago I got an unexpected tax rebate, and I decided to spend it wisely - on a sax. I made a couple of visits to sax.co.uk and tried all their higher end saxes. This included Yamahas, Selmers, a Keilwerth, Trevor James Signature Custom, a couple of Mauriats and Yanagisawas.

I had expected to come away with a Yamaha YTS62, having played one previously, and loved it, but I ended up buying a Yanagisawa T992 (I also really liked the T901, the predecessor of the TW01). I have never for one minute regretted the purchase, and although it gets played a lot, it has been totally reliable.

I would say that if you have the money, and more to the point, feel you can justify spending that much on a sax, get the Yanagisawa. Of course, your view may differ, all saxes from the level of a YTS280 and up are good, so the best thing to do would be to go to a good shop with your own mouthpiece and plenty of time and blow loads of them. But given a binary choice between YTS280 and Yanagisawa, I'd pick Yanagisawa.
 
As far as build quality and reliability goes, you won't find better than Yanagisawa. They are unmatched when it comes to consistency of their horns, and are very versatile instruments.

Yamahas IMO are a very close 2nd, but for me aren't quite as versatile. Unbeatable for playing in a pop band though.

As always, the best advice is to try as many instruments as possible. What you like more might surprise you!
 
As far as build quality and reliability goes, you won't find better than Yanagisawa. They are unmatched when it comes to consistency of their horns, and are very versatile instruments.
This is true up to a point. I see a lot more Yanagisawas with lacquer blemishes at a relatively early age than I do Yamahas etc.
 
This is true up to a point. I see a lot more Yanagisawas with lacquer blemishes at a relatively early age than I do Yamahas etc.

Do you mean wear on palm, side, and pinkie key touches? That was my experience. I had a new SC-992 at the same time as a new Ref 36, and the lacquer on the Yanagisawa's touch points wore away while the Selmer's stayed intact, even thought the tenor was getting more play time.
 
Do you mean wear on palm, side, and pinkie key touches? That was my experience. I had a new SC-992 at the same time as a new Ref 36, and the lacquer on the Yanagisawa's touch points wore away while the Selmer's stayed intact, even thought the tenor was getting more play time.
No, that's plain old lacquer wear. Blemishes form beneath the lacquer of their own accord - due to acid (flux) bleed around the joints of pillars and fittings.

blemishes.webp
 

Similar threads... or are they? Maybe not but they could be worth reading anyway 😀

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,072
Messages
578,569
Members
8,133
Latest member
walthang
Back
Top Bottom