Tech/maintenance can we talk about the low C key

JulesMartin

Member
Messages
117
Location
Essex, UK
Hi Guys, whilst cleaning my sax this evening I noticed something I need some advice about. With the instrument laying down on the table, when pressing the low C key the flap closes fine but is quite slow to reopen and does not reach its felt pad when releasing the key. With the sax upright in its playing position the flap opens fine resting quickly up against its felt pad. I'm wondering why there should be a difference depending on the sax being horizontal or vertical. Is there something I can do to improve this or is it something not to worry about. Any help as always much appreciated.
 
Don't worry, it's completely normal. It's all about spring strength, which you don't want to be so strong that closing the key is really hard. I'd only worry about it if you're likely to be playing the sax sideways.
 
As above. It's the spring tension - the metal work is quite heavy comparatively speaking on the larger pads. In the horizontal position you are adding the weight of the keywork that wouldn't normally be working against the spring in the vertical position.

One point to note -be careful laying a sax down on its side on a hard surface as you can bend bits (palm keys etc) use a towel or the case.

I use a tall stand when cleaning my saxophones - you could also put a normal stand on a table to make it easy.
 
Perfectly normal. Increasing the spring tension will just make your pinky miserable. You will find the same environment on most bell keys too. This is also why it’s important to keep things oiled. Sluggish return could be dry parts. But I don’t see that in this instance.
 
Thanks for all your replies and reassurance. I might try a drop of oil just to see if anything changes but if it's all normal I'm happy with that. Oh! and Veggie Dave, is there any other way other than horizontal :thumb:
One more thing if i may on a related point. Is the open gap between the tone hole and the cap important in regard to Tone/Volume/Tuning? All the caps that are by default open, all rest nicely against their pads but I see that there is adjustment for the pads on the lower ones. Just wondering being a newbie if this is yet another piece of the puzzle that is the saxophone?:confused:
:confused:
 
One more thing if i may on a related point. Is the open gap between the tone hole and the cap important in regard to Tone/Volume/Tuning? All the caps that are by default open, all rest nicely against their pads but I see that there is adjustment for the pads on the lower ones. Just wondering being a newbie if this is yet another piece of the puzzle that is the saxophone?:confused:
:confused:

Yes, that gap is important. If the bell keys are set too low you may encounter problems with tuning and a stuff tone. Less so when set too high - but that can make the action feel cumbersome. As a general rule you shouldn't need to adjust the height of these keys unless there's a specific issue you want to deal with. Also, adjusting the opening height of the low B and Bb keys will have an effect on the bell key table (the bits you press) regulation and its link to the G# key.
 
Yes, that gap is important. If the bell keys are set too low you may encounter problems with tuning and a stuff tone. Less so when set too high - but that can make the action feel cumbersome. As a general rule you shouldn't need to adjust the height of these keys unless there's a specific issue you want to deal with. Also, adjusting the opening height of the low B and Bb keys will have an effect on the bell key table (the bits you press) regulation and its link to the G# key.
Thanks I'll leave best alone. The felts are brand new throughout along with the pads so in my lack of knowledge I'll assume all is ok. I sort of guessed there would be a point to there being adjusters there, after all you can adjust the hell out of everything else on it so why not. As and when it needs a service I assume the person doing the work will know the optimum clearance for the pads. I'll just go back to concentrating on getting notes out of it! thanks again people
 
Thanks I'll leave best alone
Great idea. They look like they are there for user adjusting but I think it’s best to consider them as something best left for techs.

It’s often the case that as you adjust one key, another one goes out of whack. Adjust that and yet another one goes out of whack. And so on…
 
Great idea. They look like they are there for user adjusting but I think it’s best to consider them as something best left for techs.

It’s often the case that as you adjust one key, another one goes out of whack. Adjust that and yet another one goes out of whack. And so on…
With so many other issues of my own to get sorted bit by bit I think the old adage of "if it ain't broke..." is well applied.
 
I have a little different take on adjusting the low C spring. I like to adjust it so it just barely opens the key with the sax lying on its side. That is quite a large key that the spring needs to open and adjusting it like that gives it that "snappy" feeling that I like. Plus the spring closed low Eb needs a stronger spring tension for a positive seal, and making the low C a bit stiffer helps to make them as equal as possible.

As far as the opening of the low C is concerned, the timbre of low D and middle D is the most important factor. I like to open it enough to make the D's as clear as possible without making D2 too sharp. Based on something Curt Altarac said about setting up the new Wilmington saxes that come into his shop, I have been experimenting with opening the bell keys more than I used to and it seems to "open up" the sound of all the notes. As @Pete Thomas said, doing so requires some careful adjustments of the LH table and should be done by an experienced tech.
 

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,072
Messages
578,584
Members
8,133
Latest member
walthang
Back
Top Bottom