Cafe Announcements 📣 Café Survey part 4 - moderation and forum management

Moderation and management of the forum (discuss reasons for your rating in thread below)


  • Total voters
    48
If we except the little scandal of the top black banner advertising for survey #3 when we are clearly at #4, I don't see anything bad to say about the admins and moderators. >:)

Special mention to Jeanette which (at this point 'she' can only be a bot since 'she' is connected 24/7) seem to be everywhere every time, but I am sure the others are there too... little Morlocks working for us by taking away our mistakes (and eventually one of us once in a while)... :rofl:

Smooth good job ! :thumb:
 
Without a degree of moderating being necessary from time to time, life would be somewhat colourless! The visible side of the Forum's moderation is so far as I can recall exemplary in that it is unobtrusive but effective and only exercised when necessary. On the rare occasions when tempers flare up and a good old slanging match seems inevitable it is nipped in the bud firmly but invariably politely. Such spats are usually brought about by a misunderstanding which can easily occur considering the diversity of the membership and languages and cultures involved. This is after all what makes the Forum such a pleasure to be involved in.
The general management of the Forum leaves little to be desired; this is exemplified by the present series of consultations which is surely a rarity in the field of forums (fora?). My own very limited experience would indicate that the inclusion of the membership in guiding the management of the Forum is the exception rather than the rule.
Many thanks to all concerned in the existence of an oasis from the trials and tribulations of life!!
Dave
 
The general management of the Forum leaves little to be desired; this is exemplified by the present series of consultations which is surely a rarity in the field of forums (fora?). My own very limited experience would indicate that the inclusion of the membership in guiding the management of the Forum is the exception rather than the rule.

Thanks, this is our aim. I know we have been criticised in the past, so I'm a bit surprised at the overall very positive reaction so far, I was hoping to find some dissent and either a way to justify certain things or else to change for the better.

Usually issues have been over understanding the Yardsale rules and our attitude to vendors using the posting features for gratuitous marketing. The vendors and business we have here at the moment are very sensitive both the the rules and other members' attitudes (which should basically be aligned IMO)
 
I think the point was made on the thread about forum rules and it also applies to Moderation and Management of the site, in that, if someone has been 'moderated' and doesn't have a particular problem with how it's dealt with, they are most likely to stick around. However if they come under moderation and have a real problem with it, it's more likely the member will move on, rather than stick around a bear a heavy grudge. Possibly that's why those who have responded have done so in a generally positive way.

Also, Forums have been around for a long time and even new members are likely to have had experience with how these kind of social platforms work, rather than stumbling around offending people and needing a prod in the right direction (though I might be wrong on this. It certainly doesn't seem like this on the face of it)

I'll add that for a forum that naturally attracts a lot of the same questions from new joiners and new Players, there is very little, if any, snarky 'Just search the forum' responses to often asked questions, so I think the balance of moderation against the attitude of the general forum population must work quite well. I've certainly been on forums in the past where if there wasn't a good old dust up on a daily basis, with one of the regular trouble makers being banned, then it was an unusual day!
 
I think the management & moderation of this forum work well - I say this only because I haven’t fallen foul to them, so I have no other reason to comment!
So it almost like a duck - serene on the surface, no doubt paddling away furiously under the surface.
I have been on here a number of years, and had to contact the mods once. They handled my concerns very well. I felt they took my concerns seriously and acted appropriately and satisfactorily.
 
Once upon a time in a distant universe, I was the moderator of a forum hosted by a well-known institution (was supposed to be a team but for a while I was the only one). It was music related and due to its nature (I won't say more as too identifiable) it had some very strict rules about what could or could not be posted (there were valid reasons given the context for that). It was unbelievable how much effort supposedly well-educated people would put into subverting the rules.

Generally, we do not get that here (apart from the usual subversive suspects), That in part is due to the fact that the mods are sufficiently active / visible that it keeps things on a more-or-less even keel. There is another forum that I am a member of and the issue there is the complete lack of visibility from the mods, which does lead to serious issues from time to time.

I have encountered issues which I have not been entirely comfortable with.
 

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,075
Messages
578,650
Members
8,134
Latest member
banjo
Back
Top Bottom