Beginner Saxes buying my first alto sax

It takes time to get used to having a lump of plastic, with a reed strapped to it, in your mouth.
If the Thomann is comfortable use that one.
The mouthpiece that came with my Thomann was ok. Good enough to get a newbie going.
There's enough to learn and get used to when starting out without fussing over gear.
Depending on how much practice is undertaken it could be a year or two before a beginner's embouchure is developed enough to perceive any difference. At the start comfort is all that matters. imo.
Having said that the Thomann mouthpiece is very similar to a Yamaha mouthpiece.
 
DSCN0541.JPG


these are the 2 mouthpices.As you can see the stock mouthpiece on the right is longer and slimmer than the Yamaha.
 
Any particular reason?

What I mean, what is unsuitable about the one you have?
like i said the stock mouthpiece works for me but i really would like to know how to define this mouthpiece,i may want to buy something similar in different material or with some other differences but same shape.I asked Thomann but all the info i got is that the opening is 1.6 and the chamber is round.
 
View attachment 21802

these are the 2 mouthpices.As you can see the stock mouthpiece on the right is longer and slimmer than the Yamaha.
You're right, there is a slight difference, but it is pretty small. My guess would be that going to the Yamaha after the Thomann, it may feel more bulky in the mouth. However, I'd be pretty certain that if you played the Yamaha for half an hour a day for a week, you'd get used to it. But hey, if the Thomann feels OK for you, just use that.
 
folks ,the question is how do you define this mouthpiece?i;m kinda surprised at the very little info i found in the web about this.I know from experience that trumpet mouthpieces are very specificaly defined.When you want to buy one you know what to get.But it seems strangely in the sax world this is not the case.The difference between the 2 above mouthpieces is HUGE by scientific standards.They may look similar but in scientific terms where 1mm is a significant amount the difference is very large.
 
folks ,the question is how do you define this mouthpiece
the thing is, with the exception of mettle vs. HR or plastic; I've very rarely seen the thickness / slimmness of a MP discussed like this. I'm guessing folks are a bit puzzled.

Just out of curisity, how far along the MP would you say your teath/lips sit?
Foks do all sorts for various reasons; but a begginer rule of thumb is that the lips sit just where the reed and MP part company along the rails (the plastic on either side of the long opening in the MP). Are you, maybe, taking quite a lot of MP into your mouth?
 
Have a look at the Theo Wanne website and click on the resources tab to learn about saxophone mouthpieces.
i have already read this.The sax mouthpiece as described in this glossary has at least 2 dozenparameters.I havent counted them but there are alot.When you are buying amouthpiece which of these are given?from what i have seen just 3.The opening ,the shapeof the chamber and the size of the facing.THis not very helpful.
 
the thing is, with the exception of mettle vs. HR or plastic; I've very rarely seen the thickness / slimmness of a MP discussed like this. I'm guessing folks are a bit puzzled.

Just out of curisity, how far along the MP would you say your teath/lips sit?
Foks do all sorts for various reasons; but a begginer rule of thumb is that the lips sit just where the reed and MP part company along the rails (the plastic on either side of the long opening in the MP). Are you, maybe, taking quite a lot of MP into your mouth?
i have used these mouthpieces with my sax teacher.So i put my mouth correctly.I told him the Yamaha bothers me and he said it happens but couldnt helpme anymore.The point is i think one should be able to buy exactly the specific mouthpiece if he wants to,which seems not possible from what i see.
 
i have already read this.The sax mouthpiece as described in this glossary has at least 2 dozenparameters.I havent counted them but there are alot.When you are buying amouthpiece which of these are given?from what i have seen just 3.The opening ,the shapeof the chamber and the size of the facing.THis not very helpful.

Very generally speaking but NOT an absolute rule:

The external shape and size of a saxophone mouthpiece is traditionally determined by the material it is made from:
hard rubber and (plastic) pieces designed to emulate hard rubber tend to be externally bigger and more conical shaped than metal mouthpieces that tend to be cylindrical and smaller. There really doesn't seem to be any real standards for the external shape and dimensions, with every manufacturer having their own ideas.

You haven't said in exactly what is bothering you -it may be something that you could solve with a mouthpiece patch if it's vibrating on your teeth for example.
 
i have used these mouthpieces with my sax teacher.So i put my mouth correctly.I told him the Yamaha bothers me and he said it happens but couldnt helpme anymore.The point is i think one should be able to buy exactly the specific mouthpiece if he wants to,which seems not possible from what i see.
well. When somethig bothers most users, it is specified (e.g. tip opening, facing length, alto/tenor/sop etc.). The outer diamater of the beak, within the parameters of most manufacturers, seems not to bother many people most the time. So, either you are doing something qutie special (apparently not...) or, as your teacher says, not much to do - other than go to a shop and try out pices.
 
The reality is that the outside dimensions have no effect on the sound, so there has never been any need to document or describe the outside of a mouthpiece. That's why you're not finding any such information. You just have to accept this fact.

As a beginner, you will easily be able to adapt to any shape mouthpiece given a little time. And as a woodwind player, you will have to adapt to many different mouthpiece shapes and sizes from clarinet to bari sax as you progress. If you get hung up on one specific size/shape right now, you'll be unnecessarily limiting your ability to adapt your embouchure.

I would encourage you to not place any significance to the outside shape and make decisions based on sound and response, not shape. Also get the input of an experienced player/teacher as you do not yet have the skills to make an informed judgement.
 
The reality is that the outside dimensions have no effect on the sound, so there has never been any need to document or describe the outside of a mouthpiece. That's why you're not finding any such information. You just have to accept this fact.
i accept this fact but it doesnt mean i must be happy about it.At this point i know i would want to be able to find and try an externaly identical mouthpiece from other brand and i cant.I disagree that i shouldnt complain about it,as you seem to be suggesting.
 
i accept this fact but it doesnt mean i must be happy about it.At this point i know i would want to be able to find and try an externaly identical mouthpiece from other brand and i cant.I disagree that i shouldnt complain about it,as you seem to be suggesting.
I think the point is that manufacturers provide details on the things that affect the sound, and how easy it is to blow the mouthpiece, ie, the internals. The externals do indeed vary, but the significance of this is minor. The reason is that players notice the change in the dimensions of a mouthpiece at first, but very quickly adjust to the different sizes. This is why players can get used to a slimline metal mouthpice adter having played a fatter ebonite one, or, for that matter, go from playing a soprano to a baritone, where the differences in mouthpiece size are huge.

This form of adaptability is a part of the learning process. You'd be surprised at what player can adapt to, and quickly. I coped with losing half my teeth, so for most players, adapting to a mouthpiece that's a mil thicker should be no real issue. Just don't expect any two mouthpieces to feel the same immediately after flipping from one to another.
 
well the good thing is,even though there are no official specs of what i want, as a newbie im not going to spend more than 100 dollars on a mouthpiece so there arent many cheap ones.From these just looking at the photos i can guess somewhat which is closer to what i want.
 
If all MPs had the same external dimensions that could be a problem as they'd perhaps suit only a small number of players. The fact there are all sorts of slightly different shapes may be a (subconscious) minor reason a player may choose a particular MP, although I've never seen external dimensions/shape discussed before in this regard.

It's interesting you've brought it up as I've never given it a second thought. As has been said, I'd always just adapted to whatever I found in a case. I can't consciously recall saying to myself "that one will have to go due to it's fatness/thinness/beak shape etc" but perhaps that's been a tiny part of the decision in my head.

I wonder if @Phil has come across this when refacing... has a customer ever said "while you're at it Phil, could you skim a bit off the outside to make it thinner, and reshape the beak?"
 

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,076
Messages
578,677
Members
8,134
Latest member
banjo
Back
Top Bottom