Mouthpieces Burnin mouthpiece alternatives/additions?

rytrom

New Member
Messages
2
Location
Atlanta
Hello saxers sisters and brothers!

I'm a 50 year old returning player and a year ago bought a BetterSax Alto with the Burnin mouthpiece. Getting there slowly but fully enjoying every moment! Today made a gift to myself and upgrader to an Eastman 52nd Street (what a difference!)

Although I don't think that the mouthpiece upgrade is justified by my skills level I still want to indulge myself and buy something new to play with so like a pro I'll have more than one mouthpiece🙂 Seriously, the point is to try something rather different to expand my experience. What are your thoughts? $200-300 budget.
 
You should definitely consider Ed Pillinger's mouthpieces. His NYA in either the 5*M (or the 6M depending upon which Burnin' piece you have) facing would be a very good place to start. Or indeed the PPT alto piece in either a 5 or a 6 facing which is made by Ed to the specifications of @Pete Thomas. Either of these will last a lifetime of playing and you can rest assured that Ed's craftsmanship is beyond reproach and that his mouthpieces are the most reed-friendly I have ever used.

Beyond that, for your budget there is nothing that in my experience compares to Ed's pieces. But....

Vandorens are a reasonable and cheaper alternative. I'm thinking of the V16 ebonite A5, or A5S+if you want some extra bite.
If you wanted to explore the classical side of saxophone playing the Vandoren Optimum AL3 or AL4 (along with classical cut reeds) can be excellent for the money.

D'Addario are also a reasonable purchase, but frankly they can be a bit bland and you probably won't get much of a real alternative to the Burnin'.

Yanagisawa ebonite mouthpieces are surprisingly OK for the money, but again, probably not much of an alternative to the Burnin'.

Otherwise, you are getting into either more expensive territory, or run the risk of buying a poorly made piece (I'm thinking of modern Meyers, Otto Links, Rousseaus etc. which can be very variable still and thus a luck of the draw purchase). Looking at the Sax.co.uk page of alto pieces under £300, there is not a huge amount that is going to give you a really good alternative except for those I have mentioned.
 
I think it makes sense to do some listening to some of your favorite players and deciding on what color palate you are looking for. Of course you will still sound different on the same type of piece but you can at least narrow the field. Your question will go either unanswered or you will get a long list of everyones favorite piece. Is great to have new gear and the chance to try something different but you need a direction to find a desireable "different".
 
What do you want that's different than what your current piece is giving you?

Don't be too quick to assume that something that appears to be a "cheap student mouthpiece" can't be used for professional results. There's a guy named Mark Fleming who's posted a series of mouthpiece articles - among which is his investigation in which he finds that the "Goldentone" mouthpiece typically supplied with Bundy saxes, and which sells for about $10 used these days, is basically the same thing (molded from the same material, in the same factory, with identical interior dimensions) as the Brilhart Ebolin and Tonalin which have become "collector pieces" in recent years. There's a lot of debunking yet to be done in the mouthpiece industry.

Me, I continue to hold that a mouthpiece of moderate design (small rollover baffle, moderate chamber size) is the most likely to be a long term general purpose mouthpiece. The fully equipped saxophonist who has to cover all genres can probably get by on alto with a Meyer or copy and a classical piece; on tenor with a classical piece, a Link hard rubber or copy, and a high baffle piece for rock and roll.

My point is that the "El Cheapo" stamped on your mouthpiece doesn't mean inherently that you need to "upgrade" from it, not necessarily. In the last 10 years or so I've really been digging getting professional results from inexpensive equipment that carries a negative snob factor.
 
…Seriously, the point is to try something rather different to expand my experience. What are your thoughts? $200-300 budget.

I don’t think getting a new rollover baffle mouthpiece will give you anything much different than the Burnin’. These mouthpieces are made by JodyJazz, who make high quality mouthpieces. For expanding your experience I’d suggest something completely different such as a Vandoren AP3 for classical or a Vandoren Jumbo Java A45 for rock.

…

Otherwise, you are getting into either more expensive territory, or run the risk of buying a poorly made piece (I'm thinking of modern Meyers, Otto Links, Rousseaus etc. which can be very variable still and thus a luck of the draw purchase). Looking at the Sax.co.uk page of alto pieces under £300, there is not a huge amount that is going to give you a really good alternative except for those I have mentioned.
Rousseau are now hand finished by JodyJazz so if you can find a current one it should be more consistent. I have an NC5 tenor model on back order with Gear4Music. I’ll add a review to this site if it ever arrives.
 
Folks, thanks for your input. The goal is really to try something different. I hear you about the classic option but not sure it excites me yet. What about a metal mouthpiece? I see quite a few alternative in the ~$300 range at Sweetwater.com
 
A saxophone is a saxophone is a saxophone.
The difference is the player.
We all go through the stage of wondering if better gear will be the solution to all our problems. It turns out that it isn't. It can add that little sparkle that a very experienced player can create but becoming a very experienced player is needed first.
A hand finished piece will have any little inconsistencies removed and make playing easier and not be so reed fussy but you still need to put in the hours.
You may find the difference you're looking for by experimenting with reeds. Different cuts, brands etc.
And then there's reed adjustment, which is a whole new world for exploration.
 
Folks, thanks for your input. The goal is really to try something different. I hear you about the classic option but not sure it excites me yet. What about a metal mouthpiece? I see quite a few alternative in the ~$300 range at Sweetwater.com
Avoid Berg Larsen, they are very inconsistent in quality. Otto Link aren’t much better, and don’t have the step baffle that will give you the different sound you’re looking for. Anything with a step baffle will give you the edgier sound regardless of material. It might be a bit much for alto though ~ this saxophone size is naturally brighter than a tenor. But if you want to scratch that itch, I’m going to say Vandoren Jumbo Java again.
 
Honestly I think that your best plan would be to travel to a shop where they have a wide selection of mouthpiece of various types and spend an afternoon just messin' around. It says here you're in Atlanta, so there's got to be somewhere either in the city or nearby. If you try to do this by mail ordering and returning and repeating ad infinitum, you're going to spend all your time back and forth to the PO and a bunch of money on shipping and restocking, and still with no system to what you're doing.

Some savvy retailer ought to offer a "returnable sample pack" with MPs of several diffferent basic types and a non-punitive return policy for the ones you don't want.

I'd characterize the basic alto mouthpiece types:

Classical old style, large chamber (bigger than the bore), no baffle

Classical French school, smaller chamber either horseshoe (Selmer Soloist), square (Selmer S-90/80), round (Selmer Larry Teal), very tiny rollover bafffle

Meyer type, rounded interior walls in window, chamber about same diameter as bore, modest rollover baffle (this is what you have) - Links are similar with a bit large chamber and several different minor variations in detail design of baffle through the years. Meyers and Links blow more differently than you'd think given the similarity in basic design.

Woodwind Co, and others, made mouthpieces that are the same basic design of chamber as Meyer, but the chamber is considerable smaller than the bore. I'm sure there are many copies in circulation as well.

Brilhart type, flat/vertical or nearly so walls in window, chamber about same diameter as bore, modest rollover baffle

Dukoff Super Power type, long high baffle that drops off into a second plane at an angle to the bore, chamber same diameter as bore. There are numerous copies of this type.

Berg type, long high baffle that drops off into bore in a couple different ways depending on model, smaller chamber than bore. There are many like this too. Berg themselves offer up to 5 different baffle heights which seems to be the angle of the baffle to the centerline, from 0 which is the highest to 4 (rare) which is the lowest. So different Berg baffles are going to act like different designs.

Jumbo Java type, instead of the little rollover baffle that occupies maybe 3-5 mm in from the tip rail, the baffle is huge and arched and probably 10-15 mm long.

Brilhart Level Air type, kind of like the Dukoff Power Chamber but instead of the baffle going down to the bore with a plane that's at an angle to the centerline, the baffle just drops straight off to the bore. (This is the old "real" Level Air. Later ones made with the same name are from pictures I've seen a lot closer to the Dukoff SPC type.)

I know that there are many variants and subvariants of these basic designs and I've probably left some out. But you can see how many different design concepts have been applied to this thing. Then you add in material - no, the material of itself doesn't affect tone, but metal mouthpieces are a lot smaller on the OD so they feel different to play, and metal mouthpieces tend to be made in the brighter, more cutting types of designs. I think if you want to explore different concepts in mouthpieces, you have to consider the design concept of each one, not the brand name. Spending a day trying out 15 different makers' versions of the Meyer alto mouthpiece will just tell you who makes the Meyer copy you like best. If you've already decided (as I have, for instance) that the Meyer concept is what works for you on alto, that's useful. If you don't even know whether you'd like to play a Meyer style, or a Berg 1 chamber (see Arthur Blythe) or a Dukoff Super Power Chamber (see David Sanborn) or, or, or... then you need to try some different stuff. Again I recommend a trip to a real store where you can try these things out, direct A to B right there, not mail order.
 
so like a pro I'll have more than one mouthpiece
I wouldn’t mind betting that the concept of more than one mouthpiece may be more prevalent among amateurs than pros.
It could be more useful to think "so like a pro I will develop a sound through tone exercises and ear training."
Although I don't think that the mouthpiece upgrade is justified by my skills level I still want to indulge myself

I always shudder a bit when I hear the word "upgrade." The word should mean "better," but too often it is used merely to mean "more expensive." Often different does seem better at first. I've often tried something and gone "ooooh" but then the next day I'm back to what I was using before. This is the flip side to trying mouthpieces in a store or at a trade fair.

Yes it’s fun to mess around with gear, but I would only advise switching mouthpiece once you are able to articulate what is wrong with your current one. Trying different mouthpieces to expand your experience is OK if you can afford it, and it's exactly what I did as a beginner but luckily a teacher caught some bad habits before they set in too deeply.

Another way to think about this is to imagine for one really crazy moment that instead of buying stuff, it is more important to develop your embouchure and breathing in order to improve your sound. And the initial part of this is best done on a basic but good mouthpiece such as a Yamaha or some of the others that have been mentioned such as Selmer, Vandoren, Yanagisawa.

Or indeed the PPT alto piece in either a 5 or a 6 facing which is made by Ed to the specifications of @Pete Thomas.
Thanks David, and if you follow that link you'll hear a really nice example of alto tone by David. Yes I was lucky enough to be able to work with Ed to design my ideal mouthpiece.
 
I learned to play on an Eastern European made clunker of a horn, I played it for years and used the mouthpiece that came with it until one day I bought a Link that was hard to blow, I didn't know any better and it served me well in the end. Nevertheless I progressed.

In retrospect I wonder if it did me harm or was a benefit, I think it did me no harm. I would have been delighted and amazed to have a starter horn and mouthpiece like those available today but I was learning with what I had and really I'm not envious of people starting out and the sales stuff that they are bombarded with. Too much choice can be worse than too little.

As Pete suggested play what you have until you can identify where the problems are then look for a solution.
 
Ive had lots of mouthpieces and finally settled on one..its so nice being able to pick up the sax and just play. Ive done it the hard way buying on line its grief but fun buying and selling and i would reccommend the shop route..You have a good mouthpiece so if you try others id suggest going in the oppossite direction..i.e. if you have rubber large chamber, low baffle piece try metal with step baffle..in the end the mouthpiece and just as importantly reeds will not change what you can do or your tone on that piece but CAN ease the way you do it..
 
Tho is a recurring topic. Most of us feel the need to experiment other mouthpieces. I did after starting on a classical one recommended by my teacher from the conservatoire. She is a good player but very much classical focused and with no interest for experiment and a clearly narrow tolerance for sound. I once came with a very different mouthpiece to see her reaction. It was a Meyer G if I recall and she jumped as she was clearly horrified.

I enjoyed trying different mouthpieces and I have quite a collection. But s I do not practice enough, I'm not yet settled on one. I have a few that I come back to. But I can't decide on one. More work ahead obviously.

Having many different mouthpieces I organized mouthpiece tasting sessions for a couple of friends who were schooled by the same teacher and never tried anything else. It has the advantage of keeping you in your comfort zone if the mouthpiece you have is a good one.

I felt that comfort when I came back to my original one after experimenting on wider tips but now I moved on.

I guess we're all different. The trouble here is that when experimenting wider tips, you usually need softer reeds and that requires getting used to as well.

It's a process of trial and error. At least for me it was. Still is.

What's clear is that a properly tweaked mouthpiece makes a difference. I used the services of @Phil A couple of times and was delighted by the results.
 
I agree with @lydian says.

I've had niggles with my sound, gone to my lesson and within a minute of playing my teachers spotted the problem, and it's resolved.

During my first lesson he had me make changes to my embouchure, with immediate results in sound.

I did buy a new mouthpiece with my sax, and it played OK, months later I wasn't happy and felt I was biting, again ran it past my teacher and out came a box of mouthpieces to try, a smaller tip, but better sound.

I'm not happy with my Tenor at the minute, I know the horns good, but it feels restricted and doesn't really get going. It's more about the feel I get when playing that the sound out the horn.

When I pick my Alto up from the repair shop next week I'll be taking my Tenor to see how different pieces feel, might try some Alto's too for the hell of it.
 

Similar threads... or are they? Maybe not but they could be worth reading anyway 😀

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,072
Messages
578,574
Members
8,133
Latest member
walthang
Back
Top Bottom