Playing the saxophone Bright, dark, focussed, core, open - what do these terms mean to you?

For me "focussed" and "centered" is almost the same. A Martin Comm II with a Dukoff S chamber and
a plasticover reed is a very "focussed/centered" combo.
When you say almost the same, that means they aren't exactly the same. So I wonder what the difference is then, between focused and centered?
 
When you say almost the same, that means they aren't exactly the same. So I wonder what the difference is then, between focused and centered?
When I play I have a "centered" feeling and when I hear it's more a "focussed" feeling. When I played I had one feeling and when I listen I have another feeling. Didn't I email you the study "Perceptual dimensions of saxophone sounds" for some years ago.
 
Do real people use these and some of the other terms or only manufacturers and retailers attempting to convince the buyers of the special quality of their products?
For 25 years ago a company had plans making saxes with different characterstics, Same same but different. If we could speak the same language the connections between manufacturers, designers and customers I would be easier.
 
I don’t know what any of these mean in the big world, I was once told that I had a centred sound, I think I have a spread sound. People say dark when I often think they mean muddy. However you choose to describe sound it will end being filtered by the other persons interpretation.
 
I would be interested to see someone come up with a tone scale, analogous to the MOHs hardness scale for minerals, listing some well-known players on a brightness-darkness spectrum. Then I might have an idea what you guys are talking about.
 
I would be interested to see someone come up with a tone scale, analogous to the MOHs hardness scale for minerals, listing some well-known players on a brightness-darkness spectrum. Then I might have an idea what you guys are talking about.
If it were only that simple.....
When it comes to tone, when people start using those terms, it's all a bit mixed together. It's not just about tone most of the time....
Well that's my impression anyway
 

​

Perceptual and Acoustical Dimensions of Saxophone Sound​


Abstract and Figures​

Specifications of product sound qualities may contain both perceptual and acoustical descriptions. The perceptual descriptions are most helpful when they contain adequate detail and utilises understandable wording. To facilitate the product design process the descriptions should also be interpretable as acoustical quantities. The objectives of the study reported upon here were to investigate how musicians use verbal descriptions of sound and to interpret these descriptions in terms of commonly used acoustical quantities. Musicians' use of verbal descriptions of saxophone sound was investigated through interviews. The most frequently used words were evaluated through listening tests. The subjects were asked to judge how well the words described the timbre of test sounds. To find the most significant perceptual dimensions for the test sounds Principal Component Analysis was used. Four significant dimensions were found and described by 9 words. To interpret the perceptual dimensions in terms of physically measurable indices, models for how acoustical quantities relate to the perceptual dimensions were developed. Dimension 1 was described by full-toned/warm/soft. The psycho-acoustical quantity sharpness correlated negatively with this dimension. Dimension 2 was described by the term (o)-like. Sharpness and specific roughness (9-11 Bark) correlated negatively with this dimension. Dimension 3 was described by sharp/keen/rough. Sharpness and roughness correlated with this dimension. Dimension 4 was described by the term (e)-like. No model for prediction of this dimension was found. To validate the models the effect of a changed design of the tone holes of a saxophone was predicted with the model and validated with new listening tests.
 
OK - let’s make it simpler - Paul Desmond’s solo on Take Five - is it bright? Or dark?
It's sweet, light and airy >:)
Dry Martini anyone?

I'm struggling where to start with my thoughts in this thread except to say that sound descriptions will be linked to the emotion a particular sound conjures from someone and we all know that we don't all like the same thing, so that emotion will be different. Hence description will vary. Thats similar to music genres in a way.
John Coltrane on soprano? Thin from what I've heard.
Grover Washington on Soprano? Sweet and airy again.
 
Last edited:
Bright - reedy tonality, the upper midrange and highs are boosted. Very cutting, because the frequencies which are being emphasized are higher. "More treble, more high-midrange" if you imagined tone controls on a stereo or a mixing board.

Dark - the low mids and lows are boosted, the upper mids and highs are more subdued. This often results in a tonality which people describe as 'smooth' or 'smoky', 'old-school', 'vintage', etc..whether you happen to agree with the use of those terms or not.

Spread/Focused - not certain why folks consider this a useless description (?) If you have tried many horns it's sort of an obvious and very real quality which exists, IMHO. Spread - lots of harmonics, resulting a a very 'wide' sounding, big and rich tonality. Yes you hear the note you are playing, but it has rich harmonics surrounding that pitch. Focused - narrower harmonics, the harmonics surrounding teh pitch are narrower- note this doesn't mean 'thin sounding'.

Things get murky when you assign/confuse 'dark' to/with 'spread' and 'bright' to/with 'focused'. Those aren't synonymous/interchangeable terms, IMHO.
You could have a brighter-toned horn which is spread. You could have a dark-toned horn which is focused.
Some folks, myself included, will describe a nice Yani as having some 'vintage tone' qualities to them, in the richness and spread of harmonics.
But they aren't dark-toned, like a Conn or Keilwerth....nor would most describe a Yani as 'dark'.

Likewise Beaugnier horns, France, are dark IMHO, but they are also focused, while a Conn 10M or Martin Committee are both dark and spread.

Some folks describe VI's as dark and focused. (I actually don't categorize VI's as 'Dark', in respect to say a Conn Artist...although they are certainly darker than most contemporary models. I call 'em 'balanced' in the Dark vs. Bright dept.)

Classic Buescher Aristocrats are dark, as are their THC 400 cousins. But one is definitely more spread than the other, while the other has a more focused sound.
Playtesting side by side, or hearing a good objective recording in a controlled comparison (IOW the only variable being the sax model itself, everything else held as constant as possible), will illustrate this quite clearly.
This makes sense to me!
 
I don't think you will ever get consensus regarding sound and how we perceive it, because we all have different ears.

A few months ago me and the wife went to see another player play at a gig, for me I could identify a lot in this players sound that was similar to mine, but my wife said that this player sounded a lot brighter than me and wasn't near to my sound so maybe we hear a lot different depending on whether we are playing or just listening.
 
in this thread except to say that sound descriptions will be linked to the emotion a particular sound conjures from someone and we all know that we don't all like the same thing
This fits in with my idea that in regard to saxophone we should use the word sound as a different meaning to tone.

 
Paul Desmond’s solo on Take Five - is it bright? Or dark?
Bright .... other words that are used when we think and say bright is "airy", "fluffy" .... I would also describe Desmond's solo as "brilliance". Desmond's tone is "dark" and "mellow". "Rich of overtones" and "richly colored". Not "plastic" .....
 
maybe we hear a lot different depending on whether we are playing or just listening.
True. Most players thinks a curved soprano sounds different compared to a straight soprano. The bell on the curved is more aimed to your ears and the straight is more headed from you. You adjust your playing with your ears unless you are not connected to a PA system.
 
Edgy is another word that I would not use, but when I hear it I think about "sharp edges" or spikes in the sound spectrum. Technically I think about things like standing waves that give sharp spikes in the spectrum. These would be annoying to me.

Most people can agree on the difference between dark and bright. When you try to make a more precise description it is necessary to check if the words used mean the same to all people. Especially when the sound is 'wanted' in one genre and not wanted'' in another. This introduces emotional bias which can blur the meaning of the terms. For example: the sound of Clarence Clemons can be described as a bright edgy sound or as a bright sound with a metallic edge. I think that compared to edgy metallic edge is a more universal understood descriptor.
 

Similar threads... or are they? Maybe not but they could be worth reading anyway 😀

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,072
Messages
578,576
Members
8,133
Latest member
walthang
Back
Top Bottom