Reeds Boston Sax Shop Reeds - strength compared to other brands

mrblackbat

Opinionated grumpy northerner
Messages
1,301
Location
United Kingdom
Wondered if anyone here had tried the Boston Sax Shop reeds and confirm the accuracy of their reed stength chart below?

I usually play Gonzalez Jazz Local 627s in a 3 on tenor, which equates nicely to a 3 on a V16 in my experience.... which would be a 4(!) for the BSS reeds..... before splashing out wanted to see if that matches anyone else's experience?

Reed+Chart.png
 
As I mentioned elsewhere, I picked up some Roberto's 2½H which I really got on with. Then the local shop ran out and I ordered some 2½S Rigotti (not shown) - because Rigotti make Roberto's (and BSS?)... And they are, consistently (and I felt both where consistent ), a fraction harder. Nothing a bit of fine sandpaper can't fix, and a sample size of one box of 10 (which I'm still work on!)
 
I find the chart difficult to read and not very helpful but I’ve used BSS 2.5 tenor reeds and found them a fraction harder than Rigotti 2.5 medium which may be easier to compare, they may take a bit more time to blow in. When I first tried them it took me a while although they seem easier now. They are very nice reeds and also very expensive when compared to regular Rigottis and no doubt, Gonzalez.

I haven’t played Gonzalez for a long time and didn’t care for the Jazz Locals which I found a bit thin sounding. If memory serves me you’ll find the BSS a much sturdier experience although V16s are pretty robust so maybe not, the V16 comparison looks like nonsense to me and I would use Rigotti as your guide. You could try dropping down a half size but at the price they are I understand the desire to get it right first time.

The new silver box might be more suited than the original black box, according to BSS they are pretty much the same strength. As with all reeds it’s a bit of a crap shoot.
 
A box of 5 Gonzalez JLs is £19, the BSS are £25 so yeah another quid a reed essentially. But yeah don't want to get a box of 4s to find they're planks and that 3s were right all along at that price!

You never know, and as you say, it's always a bit of a gamble with all reeds. Have to buy a box of each in every strength and then have a day breaking them all in to compare.....

The rigotti chart puts those comparable to vandoren; so perhaps the BSS one is just nonsense:

1690124777700.webp
 
A V16 4 strength is equivalent to both a Rigotti 4 medium and a Gonzalez 4 according to my Reeds Direct chart, a Gonzalez 3 is a fraction harder than a Rigotti 3 light. So, my guess is you would find a BSS 2.5 a bit softer and a 3 a tad harder.
 
Last edited:
Here are Reed Directs reed charts, not sure if this will work. I hope they help.
 

Attachments

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,072
Messages
578,575
Members
8,133
Latest member
walthang
Back
Top Bottom