Blimey I've actually transcribed something!

sharon

Member
Messages
426
And it wasn't as hard as I thought 🙂 . I thought I'd do something fairly easy and I've a copy of "Yesterday" which plays in a higher key than I like so I chose that. I boned up on key signatures and a bit of theory and sat down and did it.... and it played. Turns out the original was in d major (I think) and now its in g major (I'm pretty sure)

What a really useful thing to do for a couple of reasons. Obviously I've got a tune that sounds nicer (to me) but also by doing it I was able to see the relationship between all the bits in the songs like where parts repeated - sort of the nuts and bolts. The other thing was that where I went a bit wrong I was able to straighten it out by ear so it was good ear excercise as well.

An all round result really which I'll definately have another go at. A really good practical excercise for those who are just learning music I think.

Sharon
 
Well done Sharon! It definitely helps to be able to transcribe, sometimes if you are in a band situation you might be called upon to play what to you is a familiar tune, but in an unfamiliar key and it's very useful if you can do that on the hoof so to speak.
 
Do you mean "transposing" (i.e. take a written piece of music and keep all the intervals the same but put it in a different key) ?

"Transcribing" usually means hearing a tune and producing the written music by using your ears to hear the pitch intervals and the rhythms.

See Wikipedia: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Transcription_(music)
and http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Transposition_(music)

Well done, whichever it is !

Rhys
 
Yes of course - transposing not transcribing. Transcribing is definately beyond me for the moment. 😉 But I definately feel I've learned a few different things.

Sharon
 
Good on you, girl!

See, I told you it'd help you get you head around it all. Exercises like this begin to open your mind to how keys fit together, and some of the structure of it all. You can begin to understand why the keys are the way they are, rather than just blindly learning them without appreciating the logic behind it.

Read a bit of theory, then have a go, then re-read it - it'll make more sense. You're on your way. 🙂

regards, Phil
 
Thanks Phil, you've hit the nail on the head. That's exactly what happened - it was like a light going on 🙂 It's also made me more interested in theory which is probably a good thing although I can feel the stupid questions starting to build up 😉

Sharon
 
Well done Sharon.
If you look at the amazing machine on the left, it is an automatic D Maj to G Maj or t'other way round transposer and does the same for the related minors. Melodeonists do it the easy way. :w00t:
 
It definitely is a very useful tool to be able to transpose, and efficiently too.

I played with a local reggae band for the first time on Saturday (had a great time, in the band! Gig on the 25th). I really needed my transposing skills then because they're all in concert pitch and can't afford to waste the rehearsal time transposing things for me.

So I had to watch the bass player, work out what he was playing and then transpose to Bb (tenor) all on sight. I can tell you that was a work out, but by the end of the 6 hours I was really efficient at it.
 
old git wrote:
If you look at the amazing machine on the left, it is an automatic D Maj to G Maj or t'other way round transposer and does the same for the related minors. Melodeonists do it the easy way. :w00t:

I've wondered is that machine the same sort or thing as a concertina/accordian and is it hard to play?

Lee - how is it possible to transpose by watching someone play on a different instrument 😱 . Hat's off to you that is definately beyond me. 😉

I have to say, I wouldn't even have attempted it without the stiff talk you gave me in the other post about my "gadget" so thanks for that.

Sharon
 
sharon wrote:
Lee - how is it possible to transpose by watching someone play on a different instrument 😱 . Hat's off to you that is definately beyond me. 😉

Sharon

Sharon, you should add "...at the moment".

regards, Phil
 
Sharon,
Very simple bisonoric button accordion. This is a converted Hohner 'Club' from 1936/7 so it could be older than me, just. As you look at it, the uppermost row is in D, the middle row in G and the half or helper row is stuffed with flattened thirds, fifths and sevenths, custom stuff. Mainly for Morris, folk and blues.
Very easy to play, well I can knock a tune out but that is nothing to go on. They are really bellows blown 'gob irons' but it is hard to bend notes, in other words, I can't.
I have the same love/hate relationship with all my instruments, including the tenor.
 
Hi Sharon. Glad you did do some transposing and found it to be a good experience. Keep doing it.

As regards to sight transposing, the more you practise transposing the quicker you become at it and eventually it happens just like reading music. The only difference is you don't have printed notation, just a live performer.
Also knowing theory helps, stuff to do with chords progressions, scales, and intervals. half the time you know what's coming before it's even been played.
 

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,069
Messages
578,505
Members
8,131
Latest member
Jef B
Back
Top Bottom