Miscellaneous BBC Young Musician

All of the players were stunningly good players.

I think the recorder player was a worthy winner. I thought the flautist was very good too. The clarinettist was technically stunning but a bit overtly "showy". The sax player was very good - but split a couple of very high notes unfortunately. The bassoonist was amazing, but looked nervous.
 
Hi all ,

It`s a little sad about the alto player the couple of high notes she glitched put paid to her.

I also find that if you have a whole host of instruments which really sound melodic and then an alto you are going to have an uphill struggle as, and I may be wrong, before you start to appreciate the beauty of the instrument when played well, the ear has to attune to it`s subtleties.

A lot of classicists have stated that it sounds a little discordant. Regds N.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Hi all ,

It`s a little sad about the alto player the couple of high notes she glitched put paid to her.

I also find that if you have a whole host of instruments which really sound melodic and then an alto you are going to have an uphill struggle as, and I may be wrong, before you start to appreciate the beauty of the instrument when played well, the ear has to attune to it`s subtleties.

A lot of classicists have stated that it sounds a little discordant. Regds N.
I think it's a timbre thing - the sax's timbre is quite distinctive. But it is the timbre which makes each instrument distinct. I think part of it is that mainstream musicians don't hear saxes very often so they're not used to the sound.
 
I really enjoyed the woodwind final, I think the result was fair, the recorder player was excellent and had chosen a very good programme. A shame about those couple of high notes breaking up for the sax player but just shows that it happens. I like the range of different instruments you see in the woodwind final, the only one featured this year that I don't or haven't played to some level in the past was the bassoon (though I used to play oboe) which made it a very enjoyable programme for me. My 15 year old son who doesn't play an instrument but is very interested in music (doing BTEC at school) enjoyed it too.
 

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,079
Messages
578,701
Members
8,136
Latest member
peterdehelegrote
Back
Top Bottom