Playing the saxophone Bari sax - natural hanging position

Thanks Mandy, I'll give your advice a try today. I have a generic Chinese bari. A luthier friend who specialize in saxophones checked it out and was pleasantly surprised by the quality. He did tell me to toss the crap mouthpiece. (it was awful) I purchased a Yamaha 5C and a BG L15 lig, paired with Rico Royal 2.5 reeds and playing became 100% easier, especially upper register.
The attachment ring seems to be absurdly low. The sax hangs way, way forward.

Thanks again Mandy, I'll practice and try to get the new C# fingerings into muscle memory.
Hey Mandy H,
I gave your alt finger solution a try. No difference of tone whilst pressing the right hand keys. BUT.....after hundreds of scale relations my fingers of stone and tiny brain didn't want to change the routine that were beaten into them. Very possible to convert to alt fingerings, but I bailed out and ended up with a draw string to reel in my bari. A few minor tweaks and it will be all good. Not very pretty, but I can play C# without sounding like small animals being tortured.
 
In the long run to move ring on the saxophone or solder on a new is the best way to go to get a better balance.

I use a good bari harness (with metal hook) on both baritone and tenor. I think the harness should fit me, not the sax, whether I'm playing bari or tenor. I don't adjust the harness.

The length of the mouthpiece is also something you should consider. The mouthpice I use on my old Martin tenors are nearly 25 mm longer than the original mpc that the sax is designed for.

I have made some "cords" with new hooks. On the tenor I just need an extra hook. Not iron/steel. So the "cord" is the right length for for the sax and mpc. I use hooks that are softer than the sax-rings. The small hook have a "breaking point" at 15 kg and the bigger is around 25 kg. The black cord breaking point is 800 kg. A shoemaker help me with the "cords". I stand up when I play.

And you can add some color as well.
hooks.webp
 
I like these hooks. I found similar ones but they don't say "Not for climbing".

Now who would climb with a saxophone around his/her neck?
No sax hanging in a strap that is hanging around my neck. To climb with sax a harness is better. But I would stay out of that as well. 😉
 
I like these hooks. I found similar ones but they don't say "Not for climbing".

Now who would climb with a saxophone around his/her neck?
Thanks thomsax. I located a three ring piece online and that will be my permanent fix. Until then I will play sitting or use my string setup to correct things.

Not rocket science to fix, but I'm amazed that a manufacturer would overlook something as simple as the location of a strap ring.
 
I wonder if the 'issue' is specific or aggravated by the low A tube extension.

That adds weight up the horn, so unless the ring has been relocated vs low Bb, that would make sense.
I didn't think about that! It's a cheap, generic sax, but it has no leaks and plays in tune (as close as any sax does) Except for the expected crap mpc, the ring location is the only fault. For the price, I can't complain.
 
My Startone is Chinese. The sling ring is situated just above the G# tone hole.

It hangs with the mouthpiece about a foot away from my face. I position the crook and sling, so that by pushing with the right thumb the mouthpiece comes to my mouth in a natural playing posture.
With the crook angled correctly I have no problem blowing a fingerless C# using Rh thumb and teeth only to control the instrument.
Perhaps pictures would help identify the balance problem. You with your horn, the horn ring position and the crook position you're using.
 
Do you play baritone?

Anyone playing bari knows it leads to mountain climbing equipment. :rolleyes:
LOL

Yes, while it's not my main instrument these days, I've played it on and off since the 70s. I was even all-state on bari as a kid. I still can't climb mountains. I used a neckstrap as a kid, harness as an adult, but no ropes or carabiners.

If you think wrangling a bari is tough, try my bass sax sometime. I use a peg for the weight and neckstrap for stability. I also use a neckstrap on soprano, so maybe I'm just weird.
 
Last edited:
This is pretty normal.View attachment 22730
Not for me. When I played (on a low level) baritone in a 3-horn section, the space for the section was limited. On the floor at a café, small stage wagon ... . So the "natural hanging" was not possible. But I didn't play at big productions.

I try to hold my bari in the same position , or close to, as I do when I'm playing. My bari is a "The Martin Baritone" with the bell keys on the left side of the bell.

For me it's natural to use a harness. I use safety belts, helmet w face protection when I played hockey...... . Today I know more as when I started to play the saxophone. Harness is better for my body. I think it's insane to have young players using neck straps.

My system with different hooks and straps is just a way to use the same harness on bari and tenor.

We are all different. My guys believe in treating their reeds with vodka and some guys believe in harnesses.
 
My Startone is Chinese. The sling ring is situated just above the G# tone hole.

It hangs with the mouthpiece about a foot away from my face. I position the crook and sling, so that by pushing with the right thumb the mouthpiece comes to my mouth in a natural playing posture.
With the crook angled correctly I have no problem blowing a fingerless C# using Rh thumb and teeth only to control the instrument.
Perhaps pictures would help identify the balance problem. You with your horn, the horn ring position and the crook position you're using.
Thanks Colin. I had a bit of a think, then ended up putting on my harness and doing a major strap adjustment. It's not 100% perfect, but I can play open C# with a minimum of right thumb pressure. (ditched the ugly drawstring)
It seems that the extra length of a baritone magnifies any angle discrepancy. I'm new to the saxophone world, but IMHO an adjustable or multiple position ring would be a nice addition. Anyway......thank you for all your heip. Now that open C# is solved, I can continue learning the twelve major scales. This will make fussing around with the harness ring a forgotten memory.
 

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,072
Messages
578,597
Members
8,133
Latest member
walthang
Back
Top Bottom