rudjarl
Senile Member. Scandinavian Ambassadour of CaSLM
- Messages
- 475
- Location
- Løten, Norway
I don't think it's possible to have bad music. Bad taste on the other hand...

John Cage's 4' 33".
Someone theorised that the start of music was a mother humming a baby to sleep. On that basis the fundamental quality of music that does its job must be that it takes you to a different place.
Pete's recent post about 'No music style is banned' got me thinking.
What makes music 'bad'?
Take Sugar Sugar by the Archers for instance.... Or the Macarena or..
But most of the things we'd classify as bad sold well, were really popular at the time. Even Mrs Mills. And the Partridge Family. Or more relevant to this forum Kenny G.
Is it that no music is bad, just not to our taste?
Why aren't Thelonius Monk's drug fuelled compositions labelled bad? What makes Lady Gagga sell?
Must confess I'm at a loss.
Bad Music, Art, Clothing, People, Saxophones, etc All in the eye of the individual observer.
Come to think of it, what is music, anyway?
Whoa- that's nasty! I think we can all agree on that.. hopefully...A lot of this discussion would seem to high light understanding of intent (or perceived intent) as a key element. From that a listener's assessment whether the music succeeds or fails in that aim; house music- does it make you want to dance- yes/no etc..... I find this interesting in the context of the tenor solo I posted a week or so age where even I couldn't really pin down exactly what I was doing and only following a couple of pages of banter have worked out what I'd been going for (blending the melodic-ism/ melancholy of gypsy violin/ uillean pipes and the primal roar or Hendrix' Star Spangled Banner... really couldn't expect anyone to 'get' that but both reference pints are fairly common knowledge so,hopefully, the solo could be related to (that last sentence looks a bit odd!)While good music is a relative concept, bad music can be absolute:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=LCgGLd6hThk
Unfortunately I could not find the original English version that hit the UK charts in 1961.
It is so bad I have it stuck in my brain.
really couldn't expect anyone to 'get' that but both reference pints are fairly common knowledge so,hopefully, the solo could be related to (that last sentence looks a bit odd!)
Ok- devils advocate here- Billy Holliday's Lady in Satin, though her voice is very much degraded by drugs, smoking and general heavy living, stands- to me- as her greatest and most soulful work.....far superior in content to her more in tune earleir works.... to me a lot of the most interesting and engaging music has the feeling its teetering on the edge of falling apartDo we class music as bad if it is outside our perception of 'correct'. If someone sings something we know and sings it totally out of tune we would instantly recognise it as bad... but if someone sings something we don't know which was written to have dischordant harmony would we class that as bad, even though it may be being performed as it was intended to be?
It is so bad I have it stuck in my brain.
