Reeds asymmetrical vamp

eb424

Well-Known Member
Messages
4,216
Location
london
Morning, does the uniformity of the vamp on a sax reed make a difference to how it plays..I don't mean the section that makes a reed filed but the v section that is cut into all reeds.. should this be symmetrical...
 
Last edited:
should this be symmetrical...
It probably should be by design of course - ie manufacturers wouldn't make it asymmetrical on purpose

However just because a reed isn't symmetrical doesn't mean the reed is a bad one. I've found unsymmetrical reeds that play well, and symmetrical reeds that don't.

They are not consistent so playing is the only way to truly tell.
 
Well, of course, there can be asymmetrically cut reeds that work OK, but the intention of shaping a reed is to have the left and right sides identical. If it's not that way, it's an error in the cutting process. I would immediately be suspicious of such a reed. I would expect that it would need more side-to-side balancing than usual and that it might not be possible to get it playing well.

This is one of my QC evaluations of reeds; brands with a high percentage of off-center cuts don't get bought again.
 
Well, of course, there can be asymmetrically cut reeds that work OK, but the intention of shaping a reed is to have the left and right sides identical. If it's not that way, it's an error in the cutting process. I would immediately be suspicious of such a reed. I would expect that it would need more side-to-side balancing than usual and that it might not be possible to get it playing well.

This is one of my QC evaluations of reeds; brands with a high percentage of off-center cuts don't get bought again.
Just had to return a legere the same didnt play well..I asked as i spend time with the geek levelling up..didn't know if it was a waste of time..
 
I would immediately be suspicious of such a reed.
Me too, it usually be left until Id used all the more asymmetrical ones. But have at times been surprised when an asymmetrical reed plays OK hence my response above.

If it is a synthetic then that's a different matter...
 
Eddie, if your Legere is crooked, it’s defective. You should just exchange it. Unless you’re extremely skilled or extremely lucky, working on it will probably ruin it.
 
If this is a cane reed, then usually asymmetry extends to the heel. If one side is thinner, then you will get an off center looking reed at the base of the vamp. Sometimes these play fine, sometimes not. Phil is right, the part where the bark shows on the side doesn’t vibrate very much, if at all. It’s because cane, being organic, isn’t completely perfectly round. The only way to know how a reed plays is to play it.

If this is a Legere reed then return it immediately. Machines should make perfectly symmetrical reeds, to within a specified tolerance (which would be invisible to the naked eye).
 
should this be symmetrical...
Yes, that's the thought with a saxophone reed. Cane is good because you make a a cane reed playable.

Machines should make perfectly symmetrical reeds, to within a specified tolerance (which would be invisible to the naked eye).
I have a "Black Bamboo" plastic reed and it's not so easy for figure out if it's symmetrical. But the biggest problem is that the stock/bark is too thick so the ligature can't hold it. Bought in Germany and sent to me (1 black Bamboo" and a box of five LaVoz reeds) in huge package that I had to re-cycle. The LaVoz reeds are great because they are playable.
 
I don't get this reply in the context of the opening post, what is limiting?, and what do you mean about your mouthpiece sounding one way?, it's the player that's in control.
Is the reed you have posted about cane or synthetic?
I was playing the legeres but feel i can get a better variety of tones back on cane..The mpce sounds different with a 3 green and different again with a 2m dsj..
 
I was playing the legeres but feel i can get a better variety of tones back on cane..The mpce sounds different with a 3 green and different again with a 2m dsj..
So if it was a Legere that is asymmetrical, did you get a refund? They would have to refund for such a manufacturing defect. As I am a Legere endorser I will contact them and I should be able to help you if you are having a problem getting refunded.
 
Last edited:

Similar threads... or are they? Maybe not but they could be worth reading anyway 😀

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,072
Messages
578,571
Members
8,133
Latest member
walthang
Back
Top Bottom