Tech/maintenance Articulated G# key on saxophone and flute

I think boehm flutes do have an articulated G#. I may be wrong but it could be you mean the tabbed G#/C# mechanism.
 
Last edited:
I'm confused. Saxophones have a left hand "pinky table" where the little finger can press the G#, B, Bb, or C# keys. Pressing the low B or C# key also engages the G# key through the "tabs" on the underside of the G# key. I may be wrong, but this is what I understand to be the "articulated G#".

Flutes have but one LH little finger key, the Ab/G#.
 
Now I see what you mean. To accomplish that modification, the G# key cup would need to open by its own spring and close by the stronger spring on the G# lever. Also there would need to be an "adjustable bridge" between the F# key cup and the G# key cup so one would close the other. That would require an extreme redesign because the G# tonehole is on the underside of the body!
 
I may be wrong, but this is what I understand to be the "articulated G#".
I thought the articulated G# is the mechanism that allows the G# to be fingered while playing RH keys F# etc.



Invented before the tabbed G#
 
Last edited:
Could the G# be opened by a lever system from below instead of on top?
There are different G# thril keys for the right hand on some old saxophones.

Most of them only work when you press the left hand G# key and close when you press the right hand thril key. Once I played an old German alto saxophone on which you could open the G# key without touching the left hand G# key. I think it was a Gebrüder Mönnig, but I am not 100% shure.
 
There are different G# thril keys for the right hand on some old saxophones.

Most of them only work when you press the left hand G# key and close when you press the right hand thril key. Once I played an old German alto saxophone on which you could open the G# key without touching the left hand G# key. I think it was a Gebrüder Mönnig, but I am not 100% shure.
Several of the 20s to early 30s Holton‘s have the feature. The right side/trill G# works independent of the left-hand pinky G#. It opens the key.
A,A,C,T
1673090546466.jpeg

1673089622929.jpeg

1673089779643.png

1673090412704.png
 
"Articulated G#" means that any of the right hand keys closes the G# pad even if the G# key remains depressed.

Almost no flutes have this. Full Boehm clarinets have it, standard Boehm and Alberts don't. 99.9999% of saxophones made after about 1880 or so have it.

Not to be confused with the "linked G#" where C#, B, Bb open G#.

Flutes all have two pads to do the G# job so A is not undervented. That's why the articulated G# isn't needed. The pad on the top opens when you raise your left hand ring finger (the two that are linked together, easiest to see on an offset-G model). The pad on the bottom raises when you push the G# touch.

In the case of the saxophone, it was decided not to complicate matters by adding another pad on the back side (and I think it'd be right about where the neck strap ring is, too)>

I believe the "Dorus" mechanism for flute is a version of articulated G#, but it's been so long since I was completely clear on how that one worked that I wouldn't swear to it. It had a brief popularity around 1900 but disappeared.
 

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,075
Messages
578,651
Members
8,134
Latest member
banjo
Back
Top Bottom