Tech/maintenance Anyone here playing a horn padded with Jim Schmidt gold foil pads?

I guess it comes down a bit to semantics. If I increase the presence of the second node I will perceive the tone as brighter whereas you state that it's only the higher nodes that increase brightness. I need to think about it and do some simulations with just a standard equalizer. There are probably more than 50 shades of brightness, what a wonderful paradox, shades of brightness
 
I guess it comes down a bit to semantics. If I increase the presence of the second node I will perceive the tone as brighter whereas you state that it's only the higher nodes that increase brightness. I need to think about it and do some simulations with just a standard equalizer. There are probably more than 50 shades of brightness, what a wonderful paradox, shades of brightness
As you can probably tell this is a topic I find fascinating. This is a link to a thesis by Vanessa Hasbrook that gives a great deal of information about mouthpiece pitch and its effect upon tone quality. Hasbrook Thesis.

If one opens the pdf file and scrolls down to the spectrograms, it becomes apparent that the "upper harmonics" play a major role in determining the "quality" of the sound. The images below show examples comparing a "classical" tone quality with a "jazz" tone quality.
1649608555063.png

1649608682625.png
 
I'm looking for someone who isn't involved in making/selling them? Just want to share experience and compare notes with another user.
I know, but no harm (as Jim is a member here) to see what he has to say. Albeit obviously won't be as objective as a customer.

BTW I did change the thread titile as it will help with people doing searches for the pads. Maybe not right now but definitely in the future.
 
As you can probably tell this is a topic I find fascinating. This is a link to a thesis by Vanessa Hasbrook that gives a great deal of information about mouthpiece pitch and its effect upon tone quality. Hasbrook Thesis.

If one opens the pdf file and scrolls down to the spectrograms, it becomes apparent that the "upper harmonics" play a major role in determining the "quality" of the sound. The images below show examples comparing a "classical" tone quality with a "jazz" tone quality.
View attachment 20067
View attachment 20068
Excellent! And I think we are on the same "wavelength", at least regarding the theory. But you are saying the beyond the second node, any further nodes will not be affected by a minor leak whereas was saying that a minor leak may suppress the first node and therefore the upper nodes will become more prominent, causing a brighter tone.

One of the things I want to clarify is that a minor or micro-leak is not anything that is defined, quantifiable or repeatable, it could be anything from increase in porosity on one pad to build up-induced seal-breaks on several pads.

But thank you, this is a great discussion!
 
Just to be clear I am referring to "modes" as in "modes of vibration". "Nodes" are something different. For example the note low C is the first mode of vibration. The C an octave higher at twice the frequency (the first harmonic) is the second mode of vibration. The G above that at 3 times the frequency (the second harmonic) is the third mode of vibration. The C above that is the fourth mode of vibration and so on.

When the octave vent opens and dampens the first mode of vibration it causes the second mode of vibration to take over and become the pitch we hear. I really can't say if making the fundamental jump the octave has any effect upon the strength or number of the higher overtones. I do know that leaks drain the energy of the soundwaves making the instrument less responsive and the lower notes harder to produce. It is likely that a weakened (not extinguished) fundamental will have overtones that are proportionally weakened as well, but that is just a guess.
 
Sorry, my mistake re: nodes and modes, it should have been modes throughout. And yes, I understand and agree with what you are saying. We don't know how the overtones will be impacted and there is really no good answer in the context of cruddy pads because there won't be any two situation alike. In other words, what you experience with one setup may be completely different with another one.

But it is definitely something that interests me not only in the context of saxophones or other musical instruments but also because I used to design server chassis with a height of 43.7 mm running 6 or 7 40 mm fans at 24k rpm to produce the necessary airflow. And some were louder with an obnoxious high pitch and we were always looking for resistance, pressure drops etc. when a chassis leak might have been the culprit. (I know this is of topic but it just came back to my memory).
 
One of the things I want to clarify is that a minor or micro-leak is not anything that is defined, quantifiable or repeatable, it could be anything from increase in porosity on one pad to build up-induced seal-breaks on several pads.
Great discussion.

It reminds me of some remarks on the difference in sound of rolled and bevelled tone holes on modern Haynes flutes. The bevelled flutes have more volume but lose some brilliance.
As the fish membranes in these pads are still the same as used in the time of the Haynes rolled tone hole patent, the main improvement seems to be in the flatness of the tone holes.

Loss of brilliance was also mentioned in a review of a toptone saxophone by Bertus Borgers. It can be found on his site in the part named "geneuzel". I recognize this when I play my own toptone alto. The simple remedy is to use a sharper mouthpiece.

It is a lot of work but seal breaks can be quantified. I estimate them by the length of the seal without a silver lining.
It is easier to avoid porosity than to measure it. Pads with an impermeable layers became available around 1935.
 

Similar threads... or are they? Maybe not but they could be worth reading anyway 😀

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,078
Messages
578,699
Members
8,136
Latest member
peterdehelegrote
Back
Top Bottom