An 'enlightening' experience ...

RiceBag

Member
Messages
54
Hi dear friends,

I had a nice experience yesterday on my learning as I play activity.

I play with two keyboards sometimes (specially because of the B4 software that emulates a B3 organ), and I use Yamaha styles to provide backing.

Anyway, recently I'd kind of figured out a song that I like and that was not that easy for me to resolve.

In my learning effort, I often play a song for days, as I correct myself and stumble upon new things.

Anyway, to play that song I'd use maybe a little more than two octaves on the right hand.

I have some old gear, including several MIDI keyboards. One of those keyboards is a 2-Octave regulation-size-keys keyboard.

So I hooked that for right-hand playing.

Then It boiled to me that the keyboard was too small, and that it was ok for many things, but not enough for some songs.

Then I said, why not really TRY to play that song (the melody) in that 2-Octave keyboard?

So I tried, and, of course, this forced me to go into chord inversions, which I often do not consider.

And, lo and behold, I came to one HUGE realization for me: It was completely possible to play it IN ONE SINGLE OCTAVE range!

Not only that, it sounded prety good, and even 'more elegant'.

Morale: I am definitely going to investigate that aproach to playing melody much more.

Questions: Does this relate to some sort of technique that is advisable to keyboard players? Does it have a name? Comments?

It seems to me a very important finding, and highly recommend it to myself, of course, and suggest it to any who has not forced him/herself to play a tune in only one octave, as a learning practice.

In my case, though, I do play melody with the right hand from chord positions as a base, so this may only apply to that sort of playing, and, although I don't think chords by name, I do enable them as such.

Again, I don't know if playing melody (with the right hand) from chord positions is a specific technique, or has a name, for, as said before, all my learning is so far self-inflicted.:w00t:

This does not mean that I actually push the chord notes, just that the fingers are there ready. I just push the notes for melody, and maybe a few extra ones, which being chord-related, generally seem to be ok.

I would appreciate comments on this, whether they be of approval, and better if they are of correction or steering.

(I am here for I have no one nearby to discuss this things with).

Also, although I don't play Sax, I do enable as a must, a Growling Sax synth voice, with which I often play melody, but yet again, I do push some occasional Sax chords with this type of melody playing, although I don't seem to mind them.:erm:

So, I am also interested in all that goes on here about Saxophone playing and related issues.

Thanks for reading/replying, and may every thing be the best with everyone.
 
I tend to find that the more limits you place upon something, the more creative you have to be. Although it's not necessarily good for music, it is wonderful for your creativity.

Restricting your range, using only 1 tom on a drum kit, not 8 things like that. Very good practise tools.
 
Hi Linky,

And thanks for your good observation on limitations and creativity. I'm certainly finding my lacks there.

As to 'name' for this sort of thing, I did find out that it is part of some high (for me) level of composition with terms like "Counterpoint", and "adding texture".

Probably what in my case is "sounding boring". :cry:

So, yes, this has been a good practice tool for me, and I can now put a little of that in my play as I learn situation.
 
Although I've got an upright piano and a couple of large but ancient Casio MIDI keyboards the one I use for working out things on is a Casio SA-1 ... runs on batteries, 2.5 octaves, 99 sound tone bank, 2-note polyphonic (!) It cost me 3 Euros second hand at a local flea market. 2-note polyphony restricts me to 1 note at a time for the 'chords' plus one note for the melody but for me it's very satisfying (and probably quite instructive) doing things that way. If I hear a tune or riff I like I can establish the key and pick the framework notes out very quickly. Linky's right ... less is sometimes more! The things so self-contained and portable too. The restrictions of it force you to hold stuff in your head that go with the overall tune!
 
I think this may have been part of the idea behind the 'pianoless' bands e.g. the Chet Baker/Gerry Mulligan quartet - it allows the players a bit more freedom, and also allows the listener to 'imply' some of the harmony. Of course, the fact that the original Baker/Mulligan quartet was going to be a quintet but for the fact the stage was too small for a piano may also have been a factor.

I've used one of those cheapo Casio-type diddy keyboards on occasion, but it had four-note polyphony - probably one more note than I could reasonably use at any given moment, but loads of fun and had some nice organ-ish tones for providing a background wash on some of my primitive home recordings.

Didn't the bass-player in Morphine only ever have two strings on his bass...?
 
Hey ... two strings is a lot!! I can remember the fun I had playing a tea-chest bass back in the early sixties in a pub somewhere on the Norfolk coast. A flamenco caj?n is another really simple instrument (basically a snared box the player sits on) that in the right hands can pretty much replace a drummer.
 
Cant agree more Mike, I go to a jam on a regular basis now, A gut brings a Cajon with him and sounds great. It brings a whole new level to the event
 

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,069
Messages
578,505
Members
8,131
Latest member
Jef B
Back
Top Bottom