Saxophone beginners Alto or Tenor, which is easier/faster to make progress on?

I'd say consistent practice and varying what you play will yield the fastest progress - get a decent teacher and go to frequent lessons or play in an ensemble/group: so much easier when there is an external factor to provide feedback, a good teacher will keep you challenged at a point that is achievable.

Essential that your horns are in good order - leaks and bad regulation etc can really hold you back especially if you're not aware of them.

I keep my horns in good order - I try to stick to the same mouthpiece and ligature, play synthetic reeds, and very particular about placement - this gets rid of as many variables as possible meaning if there's something off, it's probably me not the kit.

As an aside I actually find switching between tenor and alto quite beneficial to my playing and my teacher says the same thing for his playing. This is because they are different and the things you can get away with on one you can't necessarily on the other steering you away from bad habits.
 
I must say that this has been a very interesting discussion about altos, tenors, spouses, etc. 😉

Regarding long tones, I enjoy doing this before an audience. I don't circular breathe, but I can hold a note very long, no matter the sax. In the right place during a solo, it can bring up a reaction of applause.

Things like this makes playing sax fun.
 
“Fast progress” is really down to you - your motivation, devotion and determination will control how fast you progress. I like both alto and tenor, and soprano too, so am completely neutral as to which one you choose. I do agree that you should spend a significant amount of time on just one, several months, just to get your sea legs back.
 
There was a big discussion about this on SOTW. Most members felt that I should concentrate on one or the other. I play the tenor most but try to take at least one evening a week to play the alto. I also recently acquired a Roland AE-05 and take some time for that also. IMO, switching between them leads to faster progress. I also think that switching between song and exercises leads to progress instead of trying to master one thing at a time.
 
I agree with @skeller047 , when returning to the sax after a long recess, it is best to stick with one instrument, gets one's chops back into shape. In this case, the OP has two to choose from. Since his primary horn was the tenor, the alto would be easy to tackle, too, just depends on what accessories he has on hand and condition of the instruments at this point in time, along with necessary available accessories.

Also another consideration what practice music he has on hand to start with. Practicing alone, either will work, but if he has some pieces he wants to try that has a backing accompaniment to play with (CD, DVD, VHS video, 33-1/3rd RPM, MP3, etc.), then having the instrument in the right key makes it easier without having to transpose.

Then there's some simple starting logistics, music stand, instrument stand, metronome, etc. (Although I have practiced in a motel or back room with a music book or sheet propped open inside my instrument case.)

There's a saying, "Work is 10% inspiration and 90% perspiration." The main thing is to pursue a direction to start. The rest will fall into place as one is moving forward.
 
Played alto for 6 months then switched to tenor. For me, tenor felt more difficult. It requires a lot of air and low notes can be difficult for this reason. I found it difficult to find a reed that would play well low and high (because soft plays better low and hard, high).

That said, the alto is now a challenge when I go back because it requires a tighter embouchure and doesn't have notes as full naturally.

I would say alto is easier to start on, but not enough to decide for you. If your favourite sax solos are tenor, play tenor

Bear in mind that I've only played for 18 months. Others might have different experiences.
 
FWIW, my experience:
I always wanted to play the tenor. My first teacher said that if I want to play the tenor, I should start on tenor. So I did.
That was about 20 years ago, starting to sound quite decent on tenor by now.....
I never wanted to play alto, so perhaps my answer is not so relevant to the OP?
But about 3.5 years ago I got myself a baritone. Playing the baritone is quite different to playing the tenor. Was not so easy in the first months. These days it is quite easy to switch from tenor to bari.
I still see the tenor as my main instrument and I'll keep taking lessons on tenor for the next 3 - 5 years.
After that I'll start taking lessons on bari ....
 
The alto saxophone is not easy to play. And why is the alto the saxophone that most players starts with?

We don't say an ok/decent alto player. You are very good or ..... alto player.

I have the same mixed feelings when I play (I'm terrible) alto and are going to cook a duck: "Too much for two but not enough for three". No middle of the road. Or nearly good. Ducks and alto saxophones are funny animals.
 
Sometimes, a sax that is not easy to play may be related to its poor intonation throughout its range. Also its keywork may not feel or move that smoothly ergonomically. This is why a low time player when given an intermediate or professional quality instrument will all of a sudden have an easier time to play and sound better.

Although I have a better ear for the range of the bari, I find playing them all equally easy, have no trouble jumping from one to the other. Having the right mouthpiece/reed combination is a key. I have learned to play all instruments in tune throughout its range.

Personally, it seems the newer beginner instruments have better quality control and design, and play better in tune. (Although I would steer away from the cheapest bargain off brand Internet buys, unless one knows what they are doing and has leads on the decent ones.)

My 1965 LeBlanc Vito Bb clarinet is about a quarter sharp in the throat register. To play in tune, I must relax my embouchure there. Yet in the mid 1980's, a new Selmer Bundy plastic clarinet was one of the first clarinets I found that played in tune throughout its range. Its tuning was better than the professional model Buffet Crampon wood clarinets I was issued in the early 1970's.
 

Similar threads... or are they? Maybe not but they could be worth reading anyway 😀

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,072
Messages
578,575
Members
8,133
Latest member
walthang
Back
Top Bottom