Saxophones Alto for warm tone

And you can achieve it by switching to a different reed.
You can massage it by m'piece/reed setup changes yes....So yeah you could make a naturally focused horn sound fatter, or naturally spread horn sound focused....to a degree....

Now and then people will ask me, for example, if a Yama 4c or a Selmer S80 woukd be a good match for the (usually) vintage horn I sold them. I will point out that in both instances, if the horn is dark and spread in tone, those choices will 'rob' the sax of some of its harmonics and width...

Now that MIGHT BE, as you suggest, what the player actually wants to do in a particular instance...but oftentimes not, too...
 
well we all know ones set-up (mouthpiece reed combo) is the easiest & quickest way to manipulate ones tonal character.

I agree the Buescher TTs are wonderful, I have a 1926 golden era alto plus a 156 Aristocrat which is awesome.
I myself often gravitate towards German horns
So true about set-ups, the late great Arthur Blythe played a True Tone alto for most of his life and I wouldn't call Arthur mellow- although he did use a metal Berg Larsen 95/1 mouthpiece...! 😱

Reminds of Mr. Sanborn playing his Level Air on those wonderful 1970s Gil Evans albums...:thumb:

Greg S.
 
You can massage it by m'piece/reed setup changes yes....So yeah you could make a naturally focused horn sound fatter, or naturally spread horn sound focused....to a degree....
I found this comparing my YAS-25 (MiJ 1998 model) and my newly acquired YAS-32 (MiJ 1978 PL model).

The 25 has overall a 'brighter' 'focused' tone and although different reeds/strengths had an effect in reducing it, nothing made it sound like the 32. This has a fuller, richer, fatter tone with less of a bright edge, more like a sparkle over a lush tone, and is definitely 'warmer' to my ears.

MrsCappers said the 32 sounds more complex, 'deeper' 'smoother' and less 'metallic'. Ditto my YTS-25 v YTS-32 (both made in 1993).

Re mpcs, I tried the YAS-32 with the standard 4C, all good but maybe a tad restrained. Then switched to my PPT5 and it was like a different beast, much more going on tonally and far more flexible and responsive.

I've only been learning/playing for two years now so not as attuned to these nuances than many here. I know that ultimately the player is responsible for most of the tonal quality, the reed/mpc choice next followed by the horn itself, but in my limited experience, the horn can be a significant factor. Another example is my teacher's TJ RAW alto, a much fuller, fatter, warmer sound than the Yammas, although the 32 has much of that going on.
 
I found this comparing my YAS-25 (MiJ 1998 model) and my newly acquired YAS-32 (MiJ 1978 PL model).

The 25 has overall a 'brighter' 'focused' tone and although different reeds/strengths had an effect in reducing it, nothing made it sound like the 32. This has a fuller, richer, fatter tone with less of a bright edge, more like a sparkle over a lush tone, and is definitely 'warmer' to my ears.

MrsCappers said the 32 sounds more complex, 'deeper' 'smoother' and less 'metallic'. Ditto my YTS-25 v YTS-32 (both made in 1993).

Re mpcs, I tried the YAS-32 with the standard 4C, all good but maybe a tad restrained. Then switched to my PPT5 and it was like a different beast, much more going on tonally and far more flexible and responsive.

I've only been learning/playing for two years now so not as attuned to these nuances than many here. I know that ultimately the player is responsible for most of the tonal quality, the reed/mpc choice next followed by the horn itself, but in my limited experience, the horn can be a significant factor. Another example is my teacher's TJ RAW alto, a much fuller, fatter, warmer sound than the Yammas, although the 32 has much of that going on.
Did you do a back to back comparison with same reed and mouthpiece? I ask because my journey is similar to yours (only playing for 2 years, trying different horns, etc).

My wife heard a similar thing between the CommIII, regular Handcraft, and the 14m. To her ears, immediately, the CommIII was much like you describe the 32...much more complex and and a lot "fuller". Overall, significantly better. I had tried multiple mouthpieces and reeds, and she did it as a blind test, so she had no idea which I was trying each time. The CommIII took the cake every time.

I do believe the horn makes a difference, all other factors being equal. Vintage horns do have different qualities to them than modern horns. One isn't better than the other, mostly comes down to preference and what you like. I came to love the vintage horn qualities, so I stick with those.
 
I found this comparing my YAS-25 (MiJ 1998 model) and my newly acquired YAS-32 (MiJ 1978 PL model).

The 25 has overall a 'brighter' 'focused' tone and although different reeds/strengths had an effect in reducing it, nothing made it sound like the 32. This has a fuller, richer, fatter tone with less of a bright edge, more like a sparkle over a lush tone, and is definitely 'warmer' to my ears.

MrsCappers said the 32 sounds more complex, 'deeper' 'smoother' and less 'metallic'. Ditto my YTS-25 v YTS-32 (both made in 1993).

Re mpcs, I tried the YAS-32 with the standard 4C, all good but maybe a tad restrained. Then switched to my PPT5 and it was like a different beast, much more going on tonally and far more flexible and responsive.

I've only been learning/playing for two years now so not as attuned to these nuances than many here. I know that ultimately the player is responsible for most of the tonal quality, the reed/mpc choice next followed by the horn itself, but in my limited experience, the horn can be a significant factor. Another example is my teacher's TJ RAW alto, a much fuller, fatter, warmer sound than the Yammas, although the 32 has much of that going on.
Out of curiosity, not to digress the thread too much....did you try swapping the necks to see if that changed your impressions ?
 
Did you do a back to back comparison with same reed and mouthpiece? I ask because my journey is similar to yours (only playing for 2 years, trying different horns, etc).
Yes. PPT-5 mpc, Alexander DC #2 reed. 'Tuned' the mpc on each neck to F#/concert A and blew. They have the same intrinsic sound but the 32 is more complex, as if there are extra layers of sound. 'Warmer' 'deeper' or less 'edgy', just more going on, so hard to express.

I was after a YAS-32 because I have a YTS-32 which is much 'warmer' than my YTS-25 and hoped the altos would be similar. @Stephen Howard says the difference in altos might be less than on the tenors but in this case, it is quite noticeable.
Out of curiosity, not to digress the thread too much....did you try swapping the necks to see if that changed your impressions ?
No. I'll try and let you know .
 
After a week untouched on the stand, my 25 was sounding "bright" yesterday. An hour with a leak light and a screwdriver and it mellowed and darkened. Whispering Bell notes reappeared. It needs a refit but I'm loathe to take it out of service till it won't play.
The 25 had a full strip down, clean, oil, and adjusted with 7 new pads three months ago, and I check it with a leak light regularly, so I doubt its out of whack.

The 25 can be mellow and dark and the bell notes easy (easier at the moment than on the 32 which has leaks - booked in for a service),but the 32 has just 'more' going on and is definitely warmer/darker/mellower/smoother....take your pick!

Considering the early 32s are early 62s without the bling I would expect it to sound 'better' than the 25 (even thought the 25s are great horns).
 
Mostly it's up to the player.

I have a 1930 Buescher Truetone alto. I would describe it is a warm toned sax. But it's really capable of anything. A kid wanted to learn the bits to "Young Americans" the other day. I was surprised how easy it was to get a similar sound with my 96 year old horn and off the shelf Meyer 4 piece. It's all in the attitude.
 
Considering the early 32s are early 62s without the bling I would expect it to sound 'better' than the 25 (even thought the 25s are great horns).
I believe the 32's are what on the US market were 52's (which are virtually identical to a 475). 62's and 52's are not the same model, though. So I don't think a 32 is just a series-1 62 with different furniture. Necks are different, for one thing, if I recall...

IF the 32 is a 52, as I have been told, indeed it is a model above their base 23/25...and I agree, having refurbed many 52's and far more 23's than I'd rather think about...the 52is a 'better' horn in both tone and key response...
 
Mostly it's up to the player.
No disagreement with that.
As I said....
ultimately the player is responsible for most of the tonal quality, the reed/mpc choice next followed by the horn itself...
Your 'warm' toned Buescher can make a brighter and 'modern' sound by mpc & reeed selection and by voicing, yet it is a fundamentally 'warm' toned horn.
Yamahas are known for being 'bright' or at least 'neutral' but can be manipulated to be warm and mellow. For me, the 32s steer me in that direction more than the 25s.
 
No disagreement with that.
As I said....

Your 'warm' toned Buescher can make a brighter and 'modern' sound by mpc & reeed selection and by voicing, yet it is a fundamentally 'warm' toned horn.
Yamahas are known for being 'bright' or at least 'neutral' but can be manipulated to be warm and mellow. For me, the 32s steer me in that direction more than the 25s.
I agree, I've yet to hear a Yamaha not sounding "bright" and that doesn't just apply to saxs. My son plays piano and all the Yamaha he's played have always been obviously bright 🤔🤷
 
After a week untouched on the stand, my 25 was sounding "bright" yesterday. An hour with a leak light and a screwdriver and it mellowed and darkened. Whispering Bell notes reappeared. It needs a refit but I'm loathe to take it out of service till it won't play.
But now you lost all the second and third harmonics that were so easy - give some, lose some.
 
I agree, I've yet to hear a Yamaha not sounding "bright"
Yes, particularly the 2x/2xx models. Yet @Stephen Howard says in his review of the YTS-23:

"The thing I most liked about the 23 was that there's no 'in-house' tone.........It seems to be almost completely neutral. This is why some people describe the tone as thin, or weedy, or without character and depth........ there's a price to pay for that neutrality (aside from having to work at building your own tone) and that's the 23's tendency to 'run bright' if you let it.

Yamaha YTS23 tenor sax review
Yamaha YAS275 alto saxophone review
 
I am so intrigued by this comment!
I would love to see how you've managed to mellow and darken the tone with a leak light and screwdriver and get those bell notes whispering 🙏🙏
Pretty please 🙏🙏
When you're playing through leaks, your tonal spread is limited to what you can get. It won't push or pull this way or that way. With a tight seal, a compliant reed, a mouthpiece in perfect condition and a buskers embouchure, the sound opens up and goes where you take it. The horn has little choice and must comply.
 
I agree, I've yet to hear a Yamaha not sounding "bright" and that doesn't just apply to saxs. My son plays piano and all the Yamaha he's played have always been obviously bright 🤔🤷
It's the tonal paradigm they went for, you could actually argue they created that paradigm. Cannot speak to pianos, but their trumpets, trombones, other brass also have that reputation in their respective players' worlds...
 

Similar threads... or are they? Maybe not but they could be worth reading anyway 😀

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,079
Messages
578,704
Members
8,136
Latest member
peterdehelegrote
Back
Top Bottom