This! Just start slowly at first and gradually increase the speed. Practicing a D arpeggio for 2 octaves up and down can reinforce getting comfortable with this finger change.You don't need alternate keys you just need to practice to get your fingers coordinated.
Oh my! I just tried that. It’s harder than imaginedAnywhere anytime do this finger exercise:
- Lay your hand flat on a table
- Lift your fingers one by one.
- Then lift them in pairs: 1 & 3, 2 & 4, 1 & 2, 3 & 4, 2 & 3, 1 & 4
- Lift them in threes: 123, 234, 134, 124 (really tricky)
I do that a lot exercising RH 2. 😎You can practice whilst driving in traffic.
As a biker doing a Barry Sheene impression?Rh 1&2 over here.
Thanks Pete the most difficult for me is 2+4. I tried thinking of pressing the not lifted fingers instead. In fact all of them are tough if required voluntary movements, but will do more, hope that my wife will not mistaken I am having severe seizure when I am practicing, haha.Anywhere anytime do this finger exercise:
- Lay your hand flat on a table
- Lift your fingers one by one.
- Then lift them in pairs: 1 & 3, 2 & 4, 1 & 2, 3 & 4, 2 & 3, 1 & 4
- Lift them in threes: 123, 234, 134, 124 (really tricky)
Thanks for your comprehensive response which deserves scrutinizing in practice. ThanksYep, you need to buckle down and master this basic skill. You're going to run into exactly the same thing with your LH when you play G-C. You'll also need to master some finger flipping, another coordination challenge, when playing B-C and F-F#. Another one is coordinating the left thumb on the octave key with the left ring finger. These also need to be in sync for proper operation of the octave key. All these will fall into place with practice. Using alternate fingerings to avoid learning these skills will come back to bite you eventually.
We've all been there, and we've all eventually gotten it down. One of my biggest challenges was learning to play over the break on clarinet. Talk about coordination, 9 of 10 fingers have to be in perfect sync to make that smooth. It's still a challenge when I'm out of practice.
Here's a helpful tip. Lift your pinky along with your ring finger. There is a shared tendon between the middle and ring finger that can make it more difficult to lift the ring finger while the middle finger is held down. Using the pinky as a helper will make it a little easier. But this is mostly just a matter of getting RH1 and 3 synchronized, which just takes focused practice.
Pete's excellent exercises above are a great way to start and to practice without your instrument.
Not a great idea IMO, and not the standard approach. The sequence B C D, for example, requires some gymnastics when coming from side C. Better to reserve side C for chromatic passages and trills. Descending sequences are fine, i.e., C B A. But if you already have smooth flip flop skills, just stick with the standard fingerings.I try to avoid "flip flopping" when playing from B to C and F to F#. Of course there are some note combinations where that is the only choice. I would prefer my students to practice the "fork F#" and the side C fingerings that are useful in the chromatic scale.
Ain't gonna happen to go from D to F#.I try to avoid "flip flopping" when playing from B to C and F to F#. Of course there are some note combinations where that is the only choice. I would prefer my students to practice the "fork F#" and the side C fingerings that are useful in the chromatic scale. "Crossing the break" on clarinet can be made easier by putting the right hand down on A or Bb and even LH3 in some instances so only a few fingers are involved in the change.
