Miscellaneous Advice on a The Martin Baritone

Thank you everyone for the helpful information. Hopefully these photos will help. Possibly pretty good condition was an understatement. According to the seller, the horn was overhauled in 2019.

The price in total would be approx £1,900-£2000. This is allowing for a courier from SE Asia and approximate import duties on both sax and courier fee.

Apologies for the multiple messages, I could only upload two pictures at a time.
Bari 5.webp
 
The pictures look really good. It has possibly been refurbished.

The big question for me would be is the seller genuine or is it a scam ? Have you got reason to trust this seller or any way of making sure that your money is safe until the baritone arrives in your hands ?

Rhys
 
My first baritone was a "The Martin" from the late 50s and the sound was wonderful. I played it with a Brilhart Level Air metal mouthpiece (older one before the design was changed) that matched superbly. I played it back-to-back with a friend's Conn 12M and would say there was nothing to choose between those two vintage American horns.

The sound was rich and big, the ergonomics were fine but the well-known tuning issues affecting E2 and F2 were annoying. Those notes on The Martin were noticeably sharp, but I mainly sorted that out with crescents in the relevant tone holes.

I sold it after I got a Selmer Serie II baritone, but still regret letting my The Martin go.

In answer to your question I would say that it could/should be worth £2k, provided that:
  • You don't need the low A
  • You can find a mouthpiece that matches it well
  • You are aware of the tuning issues and can overcome them
  • It really is in reasonably good condition (lots of older baritones have had hard lives)

Pete is right about the RH F# trill key being absent, but that didn't worry me.

Rhys
 
Sorry Tania but I'm with Rhys on that one . Asia is pretty notorious for scammers and while we all want you to get a decent bari the last thing we want is for you to get ripped . Your call but be careful...
 
I've never tried/played a Comm I bari. But it looks as the bell is a little bit thinner than Comm III. And Comm I have a side alt F# key!!! Not on Comm III. They didn't make Comm II baris. If it follow the Comm I and II tradition the neck should be a little bit longer on Comm III baris. Harder to find mouthpieces to Comm I and II compared to Comm III.
My experience: If we are talking about Baritones, I found the Comm I and Comm III Baritones to be similarly mouthpiece picky.

If you mean Altos and Tenors, I don't find Comm I's to be particularly picky when it comes to mouthpieces....
 
The pictures look really good. It has possibly been refurbished.

The big question for me would be is the seller genuine or is it a scam ? Have you got reason to trust this seller or any way of making sure that your money is safe until the baritone arrives in your hands ?

Rhys
@Tania noted seller stated it had been overhauled in 2019. So that is good news.

As far as scam goes....a few of observations:

1) the pics appear to be a music shop if you look in background

2) yes the pics could be lifted from somewhere. Very EASY to check this: contact seller, ask for a specific photo or two of a specific section of the horn...say, close up of pinky table...or close up of octave mechanism, or close up of engraving or something. If seller obliges...not a scam

3) Use a payment method with good buyer protection policy, to further protect buyer from scam possibility.

Overhauled in 2019...if seller says it plays well, and confirms it is not a relacquer, 2000 quid invested in what appears to be a III in pretty darn good shape, assuming the case is also in good shape and usable....that is NOT a bad deal, really.

I mean, I have refurbed and sold III bighorns with a lotta lacq wear, not pretty but everything solid in mechanics and body geometry....for between $1700-1900usd (1500quid). For a pretty one, 2000 is maybe ....100 high...but it isn't a 'bad' price, IMHO.
 
My experience: If we are talking about Baritones, I found the Comm I and Comm III Baritones to be similarly mouthpiece picky.

If you mean Altos and Tenors, I don't find Comm I's to be particularly picky when it comes to mouthpieces....
I can't comment the difference between Comm I and Comm III baris. I have just played and owned a Comm III bari. Brilhart HR was good on my Martin Bari. But I wanted metal and a mouthpiece that could handle more volume. And my current mpc "Saxgourmeth Low Rider" is also good. I had problem when I played a Dukoff D9. Hard to play donw low and in upper register as well. Best in mid register. The D9 baffle become more a roll over baffle after a visit at a mouthpiece guru in USA. But it didn't help me.

It's easier for me play a modern designed mouthpice on a Comm III than Comm I or II. A modern mouthpiece is often longer. Here is a pict of a Comm III alto neck (1957) and a Comm II alto neck (1940). "The Martin Alto" neck is longer. And the same goes for "The Martin Tenor compared to a Martin HC (Comm I). I don't know if there is any differnce between a Comm III and Comm I bari neck?
comm necks.JPG
 
I can't comment the difference between Comm I and Comm III baris. I have just played and owned a Comm III bari. Brilhart HR was good on my Martin Bari. But I wanted metal and a mouthpiece that could handle more volume. And my current mpc "Saxgourmeth Low Rider" is also good. I had problem when I played a Dukoff D9. Hard to play donw low and in upper register as well. Best in mid register. The D9 baffle become more a roll over baffle after a visit at a mouthpiece guru in USA. But it didn't help me.

It's easier for me play a modern designed mouthpice on a Comm III than Comm I or II. A modern mouthpiece is often longer. Here is a pict of a Comm III alto neck (1957) and a Comm II alto neck (1940). "The Martin Alto" neck is longer. And the same goes for "The Martin Tenor compared to a Martin HC (Comm I). I don't know if there is any differnce between a Comm III and Comm I bari neck?
View attachment 15912
Yeah definitely the III's were a significant redesign, the necks are very different, very unique...matter of fact, really HARD to match an aftermarket neck to a III.

Good question...I never did compare a Bari I neck to a III....it'd be interesting to see if it is notably different.
 

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,072
Messages
578,577
Members
8,133
Latest member
walthang
Back
Top Bottom