Saxophones ...about that Silver Yamaha 62 I got for a song on eBay...

Hi all - I am answering a recent post here: cafesaxophone.com/threads/was-it.33192/

but thought I would start a new post with a descriptive title for anyone interested...

I have been playing for a LONG time but this is my first Yamaha

Been curious about the 62's for a while, but I really am sorted for horns so I bought it to flip,
thinking "Oh yea, great price, I can try it for a while then flip it"

BUT, for the reasons stated below, I will now be keeping it...

It's a MkII with the G1 neck - by the way it was listed as needing a service but its FINE apart from
fluffy bell keys (they warm up) but its already in the shop for a preventative COA anyway...

Like a lot of modern horns, and annoyingly for me as I am mainly vintage, the G1 neck has the
WIDER neck-pipe diameter (takes a 16mm shank diameter, as opposed to my vintage 15.7mm shanks)

This meant only three of my MANY mouthpieces would fit - 1950's Soloist, metal Early Babbit, & Guardala

With the Soloist on G1 neck it was UNBELIEVABLY LOUD - I mean, as soon as I put it on I could hear my neighbours
two blocks away having a heart attack!

I soon found out the G1 neck also has INFINITE power - even though it was already very loud I kept pushing
and it just KEPT on giving, but STILL with a rock-solid core - absolutely NO degradation of tone whatsoever!

Phenomenal - never known anything like it...

With the Guardala on G1 neck it was a BIT quieter, with a nice "dirty" buzz running underneath the core (it’s a hand-made Studio model)

The metal Early Babbit on G1 neck tamed its OUTRAGEOUS volume, so my ears stopped ringing (!!), and had GREAT tone

BUT there was an Achilles heel with ALL these pieces, to varying degrees, on the G1 neck -

it had a tendency to BLAT - I mean THUNK! note note note THUNK! note note CRASH! note note note THUD! etc...

After 20 minutes playing it I became aware of this and had to remain conscious of it for the next 40 minutes

And you know what its like - anything you have to remain conscious of or guard against can SERIOUSLY get in the way of your playing, so after an hour I was thinking "interesting, but Nah, I'm gonna flip it"

BUT THEN I remembered I've also got a Yanagisawa Solid Silver neck here - AH!, I thought...

Two minutes later the world was a different place - the EB plays WONDERFUL on it! - the Blatting has all gone, and the Yanagisawa neck adds colour to and thickens the core tone, and it SUBSTANTIALLY improves articulation, expression, dynamics, fluidity, consistency... I mean you name it – it’s an improvement of SEVERAL MAGNITUDES in every aspect...

The horn has already gone in for a COA now so I didn't have time to try anything else, but I don't care!

The other thing is, the Yani Silver neck is the OLDER A-series version, so has the STANDARD neck-pipe diameter, which means ALL my pieces will now fit! - I'm MORE THAN HAPPY with the EB on it, but CAN'T WAIT to get it back from its COA so I can try a few of my other pieces!

OK, nearly over but two more things to say...

Firstly, if you think I am a freak for playing a Yamaha body with a Yanagisawa neck then I DON'T CARE - stuff it, they are just two bits of metal, what matters is they MATCH, so I don't care what names are on each part

Secondly, this is not the first time I have done this - I also have a WONDERFUL Chinese-made Bronze Walstein Alto here, that I also play with a Bronze Yanagisawa 020 neck - all due respect to Walstein (hi Martin!) but for very similar reasons, as the original Walstein neck also has the wider diameter - also to be honest (and with all due respect to the Walstein founders) the Yani neck DEFINITELY improves the intonation compared to the original

Funny thing is, I am NOT really a fan of the actual Yanagisawa HORNS - I'll be polite and just say "too neutral" (a friend of mine says "boring") - but as you can see I absolutely LOVE their necks! - I've got three actually, as I've also got a gold-plated brass one - they can do WONDERS on a horn they fit, and are available in all sorts of different materials and finishes etc, which is all good fun!

Anyway - long post so I will end soon, but I am sure you get the gist

I've also ordered the new Yamaha "Retro" neck in Silver-plate to match the horn - these are advertised as an after-market update on the Purple Logo necks - the scuttlebutt on the forums is there is some doubt they are genuine Yamaha items, as Yamaha do NOT show them on their official website, but at the same time ALL the posts on the forums simply say "don't worry about it, just get one" - or words to that effect - people say it improves intonation, or makes it sound like a Purple Logo, or simply improves EVERYTHING - so hell Yea, why not!!

...and Yes I KNOW I don't NEED one as I've lucked out with the Yanagisawa neck, but that's not really the point….

By the way don't bother with any negative comments - I don't give a HOOT and won't take any notice...

Keep blowing and have fun!!

Signed: the Terminal Cynic
That IS a novel!
Sorry... I meant that IS novel!
Well done! :thumb:
I keep meaning to try my T4 neck on my 62.
 
Last edited:
it had a tendency to BLAT - I mean THUNK! note note note THUNK! note note CRASH! note note note THUD! etc...

After 20 minutes playing it I became aware of this and had to remain conscious of it for the next 40 minutes

And you know what its like - anything you have to remain conscious of or guard against can SERIOUSLY get in the way of your playing, so after an hour I was thinking "interesting, but Nah, I'm gonna flip it"

BUT THEN I remembered I've also got a Yanagisawa Solid Silver neck here - AH!, I thought...

Two minutes later the world was a different place - the EB plays WONDERFUL on it! - the Blatting has all gone,
What's 'blatting'?
 
in a nutshell blatting = excessively plosive - unintentional and NOT in a good way
Nope, still none the wiser. In phonetics, plosive is a sound made by closing off the airway with the palate or lips entirely. Surely a plosive sound can only be made by the player, not the neck?
 
that's not my understanding of the MECHANICS of plosive in the sax world, as you do not cut off the airflow completely, just TEMPORARILY interrupt it - but has PARALLEL musical effect as the meaning in phonetics

I'm not saying its the same, but a SIMILAR mechanism to very strong attack, i.e. aggressive -

I am (usually) a very aggressive player, but when I want a plosive I use the flat of my tongue, not the tip

Regarding "Surely a plosive sound can only be made by the player, not the neck" as mentioned in my original post and also to Trigger, my experience is the G1 neck has a (original post) "tendency" and (to Trigger) "propensity" to Blat -

to refine my earlier definition I would say "unintentionally excessively plosive"

This can be read more than one way - I do NOT mean the intention was to be plosive and it simply came out as excessively plosive - what I mean is there was no intention to be plosive AT ALL

All due respect but I know it's not me (the player) - all my experience is telling me that neck on that horn has a tendency (or propensity, if you like) to Blat

Proof is it does NOT do so with the Yani neck, even played with EXCATLY the same setup

The G1 neck has a noticeably wide bore AND taper - therefore I am convinced it has something to do with
the PHYSICAL PROPERTIES of its actual construction (when matched with that body) - but that is acoustic science, which is beyond me

However that is also what gives it its AMAZING and INFINITE power, by the way, so it is CERTAINLY good for that when you want it -

...but you would just have to be aware of and keep control of its propensity to Blat, is all...

By the way "One Way Love" is my favourite - absolutely BLISTERING track

"Idiot Box" is a really good track as well - that album was very under-rated

Did you ever get into Crass???

just FANTASTIC -

I'm STILL waiting for them to be properly recognised...

For example from "Banned from the Roxy"

"Do they think guitars and microphones are just f***ing toys?"

TOO RIGHT mate, TOO RIGHT...

Roll on the re-birth (or re-interpretation, or whatever you want to call it) - LONG overdue...

But that is not for us - "the youf" must speak - it is their turn now....
 
Surely a plosive sound can only be made by the player, not the neck?
I took ot to mean too much resistance, hence not very responsive (but could be in certain mouthpiece/reed) combinations.

No! - all due respect Pete, but No! - NOTHING to do with that...

There are quite a few plosive sounds in PHONETICS, but in the SAX world we are only concerned with three of them - P, B and T - but T ONLY at the END of a phrase (or word in phonetics)

and note they are in CAPITAL letters -

so NOT pa-pa-pa, ba-ba-ba

but a HARD , 'low' (meaning using minimal articulation, NOT pitch), FLAT-sounding P or B etc

Like this: P(uh)-P(uh)-P(uh), B(uh)-B(uh)-B(uh)

Think of a baby going B(uh)-B(uh)-B(uh) and you will get it

The hard T is only a valid plosive at the END of a phrase, as if at the start it is not really technically a plosive, as there would still be an airstream emitting from between your upper teeth

Think of the hard T sound you make when you relish telling somebody they are a **** - like this: "You're a twa-T" - see what I mean?

Like the P and B examples above, you pronounce it with the FLAT of your tongue, whereas any other time a T is pronounced (articulated) with the TIP of your tongue through your upper teeth

Now try speaking (or singing) a hard P, B or T into your sax as in the examples above and you will get it

Anyway -

I'm off now as I really do have MUCH more interesting things to do - like actually PLAYING the damn thing, or writing a new song, or taking my dog out, or a million and one other MUCH more interesting and important things...

See ya!
 
I may be confused but I fail to grasp how the "plosives" P or B can be used while playing the saxophone, because to make those sounds the lips have to start closed and then open. How can the lips close with a mouthpiece in between them? 🙂
 
that's not my understanding of the MECHANICS of plosive in the sax world, as you do not cut off the airflow completely, just TEMPORARILY interrupt it - but has PARALLEL musical effect as the meaning in phonetics

I'm not saying its the same, but a SIMILAR mechanism to very strong attack, i.e. aggressive -

I am (usually) a very aggressive player, but when I want a plosive I use the flat of my tongue, not the tip

Regarding "Surely a plosive sound can only be made by the player, not the neck" as mentioned in my original post and also to Trigger, my experience is the G1 neck has a (original post) "tendency" and (to Trigger) "propensity" to Blat -

to refine my earlier definition I would say "unintentionally excessively plosive"

This can be read more than one way - I do NOT mean the intention was to be plosive and it simply came out as excessively plosive - what I mean is there was no intention to be plosive AT ALL

All due respect but I know it's not me (the player) - all my experience is telling me that neck on that horn has a tendency (or propensity, if you like) to Blat

Proof is it does NOT do so with the Yani neck, even played with EXCATLY the same setup

The G1 neck has a noticeably wide bore AND taper - therefore I am convinced it has something to do with
the PHYSICAL PROPERTIES of its actual construction (when matched with that body) - but that is acoustic science, which is beyond me

However that is also what gives it its AMAZING and INFINITE power, by the way, so it is CERTAINLY good for that when you want it -

...but you would just have to be aware of and keep control of its propensity to Blat, is all...

By the way "One Way Love" is my favourite - absolutely BLISTERING track

"Idiot Box" is a really good track as well - that album was very under-rated

Did you ever get into Crass???

just FANTASTIC -

I'm STILL waiting for them to be properly recognised...

For example from "Banned from the Roxy"

"Do they think guitars and microphones are just f***ing toys?"

TOO RIGHT mate, TOO RIGHT...

Roll on the re-birth (or re-interpretation, or whatever you want to call it) - LONG overdue...

But that is not for us - "the youf" must speak - it is their turn now....
Hi which "one way love"...do you play it on the sax..downloaded it but think it was to much for me as a newish player. Any chance of a sound clip would love to hear it....
 
The Damned - One Way Love

best recording I found of it is here:

www.youtube.com/watch?v=nb5FLk6GkCA

and NO I wouldn't try to play this on sax -

NOT because of the notes, or the speed or anything, but because I really do not think you can replicate the FEELING of that song on a saxophone - know what I mean? - a MACHINE-GUN, maybe, but NOT a saxophone!

Apologies I did not make it clear what song/version I was talking about, but the person that comment was aimed at (jonf) would have known, as the lyrics in his signature are from another Damned song (Love Song)
 
The Damned - One Way Love

best recording I found of it is here:

www.youtube.com/watch?v=nb5FLk6GkCA

and NO I wouldn't try to play this on sax -

NOT because of the notes, or the speed or anything, but because I really do not think you can replicate the FEELING of that song on a saxophone - know what I mean? - a MACHINE-GUN, maybe, but NOT a saxophone!

Apologies I did not make it clear what song/version I was talking about, but the person that comment was aimed at (jonf) would have known, as the lyrics in his signature are from another Damned song (Love Song)
ohh sorry I'll change my tag to buttinsky...LOL...thought it might have been this one thought it may sound good on tenor.....bit partial to the damned just my era...

View: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=nLpDPH_uxs4
 

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,078
Messages
578,696
Members
8,136
Latest member
peterdehelegrote
Back
Top Bottom