Miscellaneous About Learning to Play an Instrument as an "Oldster"

6441

Well-Known Member
Messages
5,846
So many seem to be joining as new students or players of the saxophone, I thought this might be of interest. It's by the author of This is Your Brain on Music, Daniel Levitan. He's a musician, neurologist and professor who maintains that you not only can but should learn a musical instrument late in life. I've linked to the question about music, but his whole concept is interesting, although if you read, you're better off getting the book "Successful Aging" or listening to a more focused interview like the one on The Next Big Idea, where it's edited to include only the most important ideas (IMO). Oldster is a term he uses to counter the implication of the word "elderly". Youngster... oldster.

View: https://youtu.be/RqbSg2HFAV8?t=2669
 
Oldster is a term he uses to counter the implication of the word "elderly". Youngster... oldster.
Which really isn't needed.
Elderly is an adjective.
Youngster is a noun.
The correct word to 'counter the implication' is elder.
An older, respected and more experienced member of a group who gives advice and makes decisions.

As parents should teach their children 'Show respect for your elders'.
 
Last edited:
I personally 'ste(e)r' clear from that notion. It's ambiguous, highly relative and often demonstrate how unequal we are... At work, 4 of us are from the same 'vintage' and are the oldest of the team. We keep joking about it but they will soon have to consider recruiting because we're a small team and when we all retire around the same time, they will feel it!

Regarding memory, it's quite an interesting subject. I have a great memory for some stuff, but a terrible one for others. And that's not related to age, yet! I've tried to study the German language for over a year and although I'm starting to get some of it's forms, I can't memorize the vocabulary.

Anyways, I'm still relatively young being under 60, but I have many objectives ahead of me and I'll continue to pursue those for as long as I have energy. Provided I can get rid of my kids quickly enough, I may still and some energy left when they are gone to focus on my things! :w00t:
 
We have an interesting issue coming up that affects many companies. Once upon a time, companies like mine ran regular intake courses to train their own programmers etc. They would set off on a career in IT within the company progressing through the various disciplines. The end result of which was that after 20/25 years you would have a cadre of very experienced and very knowledgeable people.

The answer to the question of "Why do we need network engineers/programmers/analysts with 30 years' experience, when we can have 2 or 3 young guys for that amount of money?" is that when your extremely complex system has a problem, those guys know what to do, know the right way to do it, and how to do it without creating a major incident of some description. But for the last 20+ years the senior management types have had their way and the experience has been lost. They stopped the recruitment of internal trainees in the mid 90s, not understanding that you cannot buy experience off the shelf. So lots of those people have been made redundant or given early retirement over the years.

The position many companies now find themselves in is this: lots of young trainees with no more than 5 years' experience, a small number with maybe 10 or so years' experience, and a huge gap from about 12+ years to 30 years with almost no-one in that space. There is then a small group in the 30+ range who are in their 50s.

So, I regularly have conversations that go something like this: "Oh yes, xyz does that because when it was designed (by me) in 1993 we had to..." and they say, "I wasn't born then..." often followed by "You're older than my dad..."
 
Most people who play an instrument have learned how in the first 20 years of their lives. Some learn and do not keep up with it, forget, let it go, etc. The initial post is about learning to play, starting past middle age, as witnessed here in the café by the number of times people ring the doorbell stating they're over 70 (which I am). I think it's a good sign that so many mentally healthy people are fit enough to take on learning the saxophone! Having a fun reason to get out of bed in the morning is a good way to live a longer and happier old age.
 
I started learning to play saxophone as a teenager (I'm 50 now). For various life reasons there were periods when I didn't play for some years. I think I had more or less given up on the idea of it, but I got back into seriously practicing it only a couple of years ago, partly because of what I saw on this forum.

I've always enjoyed learning new instruments, even if I only get to a fairly basic level, I find it's worth it. I also play (at a basic level) drums, guitar, a year ago I added electric bass. This year I started learning electric upright bass and flugelhorn. I mean, why not? My lifestyle lets me spend 10 to 20 minutes a couple of times every day picking up different instruments to practice. That's time that used to be wasted watching news that I had already seen 10 times while scrolling through social media feeds. I don't really care if I never get very good on these instruments, but I feel like I'm not wasting my time having fun playing them. When I'm EVEN OLDER and looking at retirement, I guess I'll be browsing the Thomann website looking for something else to learn...
 
To be honest @randulo I don't think music is much different to other hobbies and interests. During my lifetime, there has been one big change and we see it with saxes as well and I will illustrate it with astronomy.

When I was a young teen and joined my local amateur astronomical society, the membership was split roughly 1/3 youngsters i.e. U21, 1/3 'working age', and the remaining third 'retired'.

There have been two big changes in the 45 years or so since I got involved. One is that there are almost no youngsters involved any more. I am no longer a member of that society, but although the membership has more than doubled since then to over 200, there is now only a handful of youngsters. The other change is very few people in the 25 - 55 bracket.

Some of it is that there are other things to occupy time: computers, computer games etc. This certainly affects the youngsters. Work-life pattens have changed. When I started work, your workplace would be in the same town/city as the one that you lived, office hours would be regular 9 - 5. Having a hobby that used up mid-week evenings was not difficult. We have mostly lost that. People have significant commutes to get to/from work, working hours are extended/variable.

The end result is that people are not engaging with hobbies the way they used to. People like me (I was 60 in February) who have had a long career with a company with (fairly) consistent working hours etc are becoming a rarity - I'm more-or-less at the end of the line of that way of working.

Very few adults feel able to 'indulge' in hobby type activities until much later in life. This is having an impact on society in many ways. It's not just astronomical societies, choirs, orchestras, bands etc which have been hollowed out with almost no working age members, but groups such as cubs and scouts for example struggle to get enough adult leaders to make them function.

So, it is no surprise to me that here in the Café we see a lot of "am I too late to start?" type posts from people in their mid-50s onwards. To some extent I'm a 'sort-of' example. I have kept doing stuff despite working, but that's probably because I'm single and live alone. I dropped out of astronomy in my 30s, but music and singing in choirs took over. In my 50s playing instruments was added. Now in my 60s I am re-joining the astronomy fold. For most people, it's not until the kids have grown up and left that people start looking to do other things..

One possible 'boon' from the lockdown is people showing an increased interest in and awareness of needing / wanting to take up a hobby. Let's hope so: it's good for people's mental health and in my opinion also leads to a better society, but that's another story.

(EDIT - sorry another essay!)
 
Last edited:
I've always enjoyed learning new instruments, even if I only get to a fairly basic level, I find it's worth it. I also play (at a basic level) drums, guitar, a year ago I added electric bass. This year I started learning electric upright bass and flugelhorn.
I feel that way too. It's really fun to learn and develop skills on another instrument. I practice my alto diligently with the aim to continue improving for the rest of my life, but at the start of April, I started learning the flute and the cornet. It's kind of fun to be a beginner again. Neither of those instruments will ever replace the saxophone in my heart, but I am really enjoying both of them.
 
If you think about it, piano would be a logical instrument to start on, because there are so many out there, even in train stations now days, and many in homes. Sax, on the other hand, even if someone owns one, they may not allow you to play it, you have to buy or rent. But the main premise is, keeping curious and having the discipline to keep at it.
 
Some of it is that there are other things to occupy time: computers, computer games etc. This certainly affects the youngsters. Work-life pattens have changed. When I started work, your workplace would be in the same town/city as the one that you lived, office hours would be regular 9 - 5. Having a hobby that used up mid-week evenings was not difficult. We have mostly lost that. People have significant commutes to get to/from work, working hours are extended/variable.
Yes. We have enslaved ourselves and call it progress.
 
I started learning to play saxophone as a teenager (I'm 50 now). For various life reasons there were periods when I didn't play for some years. I think I had more or less given up on the idea of it, but I got back into seriously practicing it only a couple of years ago, partly because of what I saw on this forum.

I've always enjoyed learning new instruments, even if I only get to a fairly basic level, I find it's worth it. I also play (at a basic level) drums, guitar, a year ago I added electric bass. This year I started learning electric upright bass and flugelhorn. I mean, why not? My lifestyle lets me spend 10 to 20 minutes a couple of times every day picking up different instruments to practice. That's time that used to be wasted watching news that I had already seen 10 times while scrolling through social media feeds. I don't really care if I never get very good on these instruments, but I feel like I'm not wasting my time having fun playing them. When I'm EVEN OLDER and looking at retirement, I guess I'll be browsing the Thomann website looking for something else to learn...
Brilliant
 

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,074
Messages
578,647
Members
8,134
Latest member
banjo
Back
Top Bottom