A stray F# that sounds right

Bobby G

Well-Known Member
Messages
4,636
Location
Wonderful Welwyn Garden City, Herts
I've noticed several phrases that end on the 6th of the major scale on the tonic chord. All well and good, an A in the key of C major is fine, it's one of the notes in the major scale.

I've also noticed a similar thing in the minor key - in A minor, an F# seems perfectly acceptable (I'm thinking here of Miles' playing on Autumn Leaves on the Somethin' Else album by Cannonball) at the end of a phrase, much more so than an F natural.

Why should this be? F# doesn't occur in the major scale related to A minor, namely C, it's the b5, and yet it sounds right.

Remember I am self-taught but with a residual knowledge (and continuing interest) of theory from childhood paino lessons, filtered through many years of guitar-picking and bass-playing.

Am I making the mistake of equating a minor key to its relative major? Does this F# come from another scale or (ducks to avoid flak) mode? Am I trying to run before I can walk with the theory? Should I just accept the F# for now?

Cheers, Bob
 
Minor harmony is a strange fish.

It can be based on the relative major (ie ABCDEFGA) this is often called the natural minor and is an Aeolilan mode.

However we can also base minor harmony on a dorian mode (which has the F#).

Over an Aminor chord, the simple reason an F# (the 6th) sounds better is that there is a tone between it and the 5th of the chord note a semitone which while OK in some cases is often more discordant. (sopmetimes you want discordance, but usually this is over a dominat chord rather than a tonic)

To complicate it further either of these could have a leading note, ie the 7th is raised a semitone to give a nice "lead" up into the tonic.

So from the Aeolian or natural minor you get the hramonic minor scale (A B C D E F G# A) and from the dorina you get the melodic minor (A B C D E F# G# A)

I go into some more detail in the jazz theory section of my site, but I'd read and digest the jazz theory for beginners first.

Good luck!
 
Thanks Pete. That makes sense, and I've started investigating the beginners theory.

I'm quite pleased with how much of it I've remembered from 35-odd years ago, I bet I hit the wall soon though >.<

It's an interesting subject and I like the way it's presented here.

Thanks, Bob
 

Similar threads... or are they? Maybe not but they could be worth reading anyway 😀

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,059
Messages
578,308
Members
8,127
Latest member
PJ2116
Back
Top Bottom