- Messages
- 2,526
- Location
- Breakfast room since '06 UK
So this is my new alto.
Why?
I had a look around for a vintage specimen for some months but I didn't fancy many that I saw for what appears to be the current going rates. 2 were north of £3K 1 north of £4K and 1 north of £5K. I tried the later 2 and 1 other only to be disappointed in there description/condition or their sound/playability.
For some background, I have owned a number of vintage horns over time and they were always expensive in comparison to more readily available pre owned horns. But not stupidly so and it was easy to get a ball park figure of what represents reasonable. Perhaps thats a whole other subject but in short I've lost my appetite.
Pro's and cons?
In comparison to what I have tried, the AW010 feels and sounds sweet. It came in at Sub £2.9k plays easy, good intonation and looks fine too. There were a number of options and you tube is full of more professional reviews than I can hope to achieve so I'll just say if considering it "why wouldn't you?"
It is slick and being Yanagisawa it has a top reputation for build quality. Heavier than the AW01 and 02 though.
As I said I did try the AW01, AW02. All different but as this one sat between both of those price wise and bronze doesn't appeal to me and it felt the slickest so it was a quick decision for me. No agonising umm's and ahhh's....
Perhaps the un-lacquered versions may have presented more thought but there weren't any to try and the AW020 is quite a hefty lift in price over the AW010. I know it will depreciate but I bought it to keep.
Final thoughts?
So about that price, £2895 still not cheap I guess but compared to a new series II Selmer or Selmer supreme it's an incredible saving without sacrifice to my ears.
I didn't think the other Yanigisawas mentioned were particularly inferior in any respect. But the underslung neck and a slightly slicker action and my love traditional brass and lacquer meant there was only one winner. If you like bronze and don't care for the underslung octave mechanism the AW02 would be just fine. No better no worse in my mind.
But it's been an eye opener to free myself from the shackles of 'Vintage'.
Disclaimer, I still love them too but currently they are disproportionately priced in my mind. I'm sure it will change in future or maybe I just haven't kept up with the times.
So on a final note, the mouthpiece was also a nice surprise. I have owned yanagisawa mouthpieces before (soprano and tenor) but they left me empty. So this '7' stayed in the box until I had a spare moment to fill and I coupled it and the nice ligature to one of the handful of reeds thrown in and it was an instant hit.
Why?
I had a look around for a vintage specimen for some months but I didn't fancy many that I saw for what appears to be the current going rates. 2 were north of £3K 1 north of £4K and 1 north of £5K. I tried the later 2 and 1 other only to be disappointed in there description/condition or their sound/playability.
For some background, I have owned a number of vintage horns over time and they were always expensive in comparison to more readily available pre owned horns. But not stupidly so and it was easy to get a ball park figure of what represents reasonable. Perhaps thats a whole other subject but in short I've lost my appetite.
Pro's and cons?
In comparison to what I have tried, the AW010 feels and sounds sweet. It came in at Sub £2.9k plays easy, good intonation and looks fine too. There were a number of options and you tube is full of more professional reviews than I can hope to achieve so I'll just say if considering it "why wouldn't you?"
It is slick and being Yanagisawa it has a top reputation for build quality. Heavier than the AW01 and 02 though.
As I said I did try the AW01, AW02. All different but as this one sat between both of those price wise and bronze doesn't appeal to me and it felt the slickest so it was a quick decision for me. No agonising umm's and ahhh's....
Perhaps the un-lacquered versions may have presented more thought but there weren't any to try and the AW020 is quite a hefty lift in price over the AW010. I know it will depreciate but I bought it to keep.
Final thoughts?
So about that price, £2895 still not cheap I guess but compared to a new series II Selmer or Selmer supreme it's an incredible saving without sacrifice to my ears.
I didn't think the other Yanigisawas mentioned were particularly inferior in any respect. But the underslung neck and a slightly slicker action and my love traditional brass and lacquer meant there was only one winner. If you like bronze and don't care for the underslung octave mechanism the AW02 would be just fine. No better no worse in my mind.
But it's been an eye opener to free myself from the shackles of 'Vintage'.
Disclaimer, I still love them too but currently they are disproportionately priced in my mind. I'm sure it will change in future or maybe I just haven't kept up with the times.
So on a final note, the mouthpiece was also a nice surprise. I have owned yanagisawa mouthpieces before (soprano and tenor) but they left me empty. So this '7' stayed in the box until I had a spare moment to fill and I coupled it and the nice ligature to one of the handful of reeds thrown in and it was an instant hit.
