Miscellaneous A bit of a dilemma

Moz

Member
Messages
802
Location
North of Liskeard, Cornwall,UK
I write songs. I play instruments and I write the music to those songs. They're not brilliant and I'll make no money out of them but I enjoy doing it. Now here's the problem...

My son also plays instruments but he cannot write his own songs and mostly does cover versions of commercial songs when he does the occasional open mic night at his local pubs (COVID permitting). He likes some of my songs and performs them at said OM nights and he has my blessing to do that but...he didn't like one of the verses that I wrote as a couple of the lines were repeated and he thought a few of his lyrics might sound better and that's the way he plays the song. I only found this out this weekend when he visited and he has now gone home (we live 250 miles away from each other) and I didn't say anything at the time but now I'm thinking about it and it bothers me that words I wrote for one of my own songs have been changed and it is being performed in public and I'm afraid it is starting to prey on my mind that my song has been adulterated without my consent. It's never going to become a world class song, it is never going to be recorded and it is just a bit of fun but I'm still annoyed.

In all other ways my son and I get on like a house on fire and we talk music, motorbikes, politics and go away on holiday on the bikes every year and have done that since 2006...

...but it still grates that he has changed the lyrics to one of my songs.

Should I just let it go, it's only a few words in one song anyway and he hasn't altered any of my other songs, or should I say something and if so, what? I know it's a tiny thing but I wrote that song in that way because that's the way I like it and if anyone wants to change the lyrics then they should write their own song instead. Is this unreasonable?
 
This is your son. He lives 250 miles away. A guy who loves your songs enough that he plays them whenever he can. How much more pride can a father have as far as musics concerned?
If this was a neighbour or some random person off the internet then it’s completely different.
If it bothers you ‘that’ much perhaps you should talk to him about it in a civil adult to adult manner and discuss it.

My personal opinion, let it go. Yes it’s petty. There’s a deadly virus going around, riots and looting throughout the world, you could possibly lose your son to or you to him. Be grateful he loves you and your work enough to want to play it. I only play music I really love and I’m quite fussy. I’d take it as the biggest compliment you’ll ever receive and BE GRATEFUL!
 
This is your son. He lives 250 miles away. A guy who loves your songs enough that he plays them whenever he can. How much more pride can a father have as far as musics concerned?
If this was a neighbour or some random person off the internet then it’s completely different.
If it bothers you ‘that’ much perhaps you should talk to him about it in a civil adult to adult manner and discuss it.

My personal opinion, let it go. Yes it’s petty. There’s a deadly virus going around, riots and looting throughout the world, you could possibly lose your son to or you to him. Be grateful he loves you and your work enough to want to play it. I only play music I really love and I’m quite fussy. I’d take it as the biggest compliment you’ll ever receive and BE GRATEFUL!

You are, of course, quite right, I suppose I knew that even as I was making the post. I shall say nothing but will still try to encourage him to write his own songs as he is a damn sight better musician than I. Thank you for your honest reply.
 
This is your son. He lives 250 miles away. A guy who loves your songs enough that he plays them whenever he can. How much more pride can a father have as far as musics concerned?
+1
You are very fortunate Moz to have a son with common interests.

As a way of encouraging your son, I wonder if you might offer to collaborate. Your son seems to have confidence to write lyrics but not music. Next time he visits, would he be interested in helping you write music and lyrics of a new collaborated song? Offer to help him understand your process and tell him you think he could write music well. What do you think?
 
+1
You are very fortunate Moz to have a son with common interests.

As a way of encouraging your son, I wonder if you might offer to collaborate. Your son seems to have confidence to write lyrics but not music. Next time he visits, would he be interested in helping you write music and lyrics of a new collaborated song? Offer to help him understand your process and tell him you think he could write music well. What do you think?
Fabulous idea Clive.
 
I agree with Nikki. Unless the changed lyrics are obscene or offensive I would not even jokingly criticise. He clearly thinks highly of you and your songs. If you are harbouring so much angst about a non-offensive small change I would be worried that any sign of disapproval from his revered dad may be even more damaging (even a joking "I prefer my version"). Maybe this subtle tweak of words is a toe in the water to his own individual creativity. Why not "turn the other cheek" and see if he has any lyrics for you to put music to or why not jam and write one together? Has he got some chords you could develop? So long as you don't find you have musical differences and end up not speaking. Whatever you do his respect in playing them outweighs annoying creativity of putting his spin on it (the writer of Autumn leaves would be wanting to kill thousands of people from miles Davis to Diana Krall on the same principle.
 
I've never written a song but can imagine it is a very personal experience and I understand your feelings but I agree with the others, it is a compliment your son plays them and certainly not worth falling out over the fact he changes the lyrics a little.

Hope you can see this differently now and forgive him 🙂

Jx
 
Someone else is actually performing your music! How many songwriters can say that?

You have to let go of the song once it is out of your hands - the performer should be allowed to sing it their way. All the greats have changed melodies and lyrics. Just listen to what Ella Fitzgerald does to the songs she sings.
 
Thank you for all your replies all along the same lines as SaxyNikki and of course you are all absolutely right and I will dwell no more on it.

Further to the collaboration theme...we are getting there. He plays piano very well but his gigging device is the ukelele, however I have slowly drawn him into the delights of guitar and even now (well, tomorrow actually) he is going to see an experienced guitarist who lives near him for advice on what to buy as while he loves his uke there is no doubt that the guitar is a sea-change in expression. If I can teach him certain guitar moves he and I can play live as I can dust off the old sax and get improvving around his chords. Since I took up guitar the sax has taken a back seat because you can't sing and sax at the same time.

Just as an example of why I need two people to do a song live, here is something I put together but can't do it live because I can't get to the sax quickly enough for the solo:

Sun Is Shining
 
There may have been a logical reason for changing a few words that had to do with singing the lyrics. Some vowels and consonants are much easier to sing especially in the breaking part of the voice from the chest to head voice. You admit he’s a better musician than you so perhaps he just figured you wouldn’t mind.
 
Bah, I change the words of every song I've ever sung. Mind you, that might be more down to my terrible ability to remember lyrics..

I'd just remind yourself that your Son is performing your song! A lot of Sons can't even bear to be associated with their Father. Count yourself lucky 🙂
 
Id love it if one of my boys (or girls) would have enough respect for me to sing one of the songs ive written over the years......
Id love it even more if they would sit down with me and play it or sing it with me some time too!!!

Perhaps as someone who sings in public he tried the original lyrics and they didnt roll off the tongue correctly or sounded out of time or something so instead made a minor adjustment? Maybe get him to sit with you and do a Father son recording and slip it into conversation with a very open mind? It might surprise you!
 

Similar threads... or are they? Maybe not but they could be worth reading anyway 😀

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,074
Messages
578,647
Members
8,134
Latest member
banjo
Back
Top Bottom