Playing the saxophone 21st Century Jazz point of view

Even in rock/pop music the audiences got tired of lead guitar ego solos, no matter how good the player was. Audiences just don't want to be heavied by ego tripping musos, they want to hear music that touches them and takes them along for the ride.
That's very true. And too many jazz players are doing just what you say. But I think that sort of thing can happen in any style of music. Even classical players, who are restricted to a score, can play insensitively and treat a performance as nothing but an oppportunity to show off their technique. I like to listen to someone who's saying "listen to this, it's beautiful" rather than "listen to this, I'm brilliant", as I'm sure we all do. If there's more of this going on than there used to be (and I suspect there is), I think it reflects a deeeper shift in the whole culture towards selfishness and competition. I'll try not to stray into politics here (tempting though it is), but turn on the TV (I can only talk about the UK here) and everything we do is being turned into a competition. Cooking, giving a party, antique collecting, music (eg Young Musician of the Year, ugh!), running a hotel, "talent" shows, dating. You name it, and it's been twisted into a game of winners and losers.
 
Just for Big Martin here's a rubbish pop song from the sixties being played by some very different musicians.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=uJMf9gPmSBw

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gTdxAVPkUOk

Thanks for taking the trouble. Yes two very different treatments. (Although on a superficial listening I couldn't hear in what way the first was based on the original apart from using the lyrics.) Neither did anything for me, though, any more than the original. I accept that it's a question of taste, but this stuff doesn't taste of anything to me.
 
Since I am well entitled to be hard on this:
http://www.myspace.com/aldevistibaldi/music/songs/ontosauro-18967424

This is REAL 21st century rubbish! The use of samples to be up to date. The alluring reverbs on the horns. The ELECTRIC GUITAR!

Now; this stuff is an attempt to sound modern and to access a wider audience. It simply doesn't work. I find Stravinsky (or Palestrina) much more contemporary than this, since most of us haven't heard everything they composed.

The point of being contemporary is probably more in WHAT you say rather in HOW you say it.
Standards, electronic music or total improvisation are languages that can be more or less suitable to express a musical concept.

If everything I want to say is that I am an amazing saxophone player, I will be boring whatever I play.
 
Not original in what sense? You can't have heard it before because it was improvised on the spot. So was it the style, the chords, the instrumentation? What would you expect to hear that would make it 21st century?

Obviously it was original in the sense that the notes were in a different order, but anyone can do that. I suppose I should have elaborated by using words such as style and concept just to help with understanding the term.
I would not expect to hear anything that makes it '21st century', the phrase was introduced by Wade which is why I placed it within punctuation marks; perhaps you could ask him to explain in simple terms what he means by it.
 
Since I am well entitled to be hard on this:
http://www.myspace.com/aldevistibaldi/music/songs/ontosauro-18967424

This is REAL 21st century rubbish! The use of samples to be up to date. The alluring reverbs on the horns. The ELECTRIC GUITAR!


I actually really like your stuff on the link.

For me the essence of the 21st century has to reflect the technological advances of our times. Most of the musical Instrumentation of the 20th century had roots going back to primevel times.

The Electronic and Synthetic Musical equipment/Gear which was prohibitively expensive for the average person in the latter years of the 20th century has only just become available to the masses as a result of extremely inexpensive computer power which I could only dream and drool about as recently as the late 90`s, The importance of the ability to access the internet in order to not only gain access to this mainly free power but also to self-publish also cannot be understated.

I suppose as musicians we will have to chose our weapons even more carefully and as stated already, use them in a manner that nourish and appeal to our more primevel instincts. Even a soft synth can be played and tweaked on the fly and used to sculpt waveform improvisation in realtime>:) I`m sure the early jazz inovators would have used any stuff they could lay their mitts on in the cutting sessions.


On an optimistic note isn`t it nice just to think about all these kids who can access all this stuff "modern and old" and use it to create.
 
Thanks for posting the clip Wade. I loved it, although I don't fully understand your argument. This is one direction to take music, standards or song based improvisation is another, but not totally removed from the former. Keith Jarrett, Herbie Hancock and the like have been ploughing these furrows alternately for years.

You say that there is no future in playing standards but you'd be turning your back on some marvellous music that has moved people for decades.I'm not here to further the course of music but to have a blast and if that is playing Round Midnight or noodling to what ever is on the radio then so be it.

I think that if you enjoy what you' re playing others will as well.
Just play what gives you a buzz, and don't care where the starting line is.
 
Interesting point being made, Wade but does that mean that tenorviol should burn his instrument and rip out his larynx as he mainly performs and sings early music?

Wasn't this known in the past as Free Form Jazz? Damn! That's condemned it out of hand.

Still playing standards at 74, do please accept my profuse apologies.



Last night started rehearsals for Bach St. John Passion, first performed in 1724 - see this for more info - so that would be 288 years old, at the recent end of my musical repertoire....😱
 
That's very true. And too many jazz players are doing just what you say. But I think that sort of thing can happen in any style of music. Even classical players, who are restricted to a score, can play insensitively and treat a performance as nothing but an oppportunity to show off their technique. I like to listen to someone who's saying "listen to this, it's beautiful" rather than "listen to this, I'm brilliant", as I'm sure we all do. If there's more of this going on than there used to be (and I suspect there is), I think it reflects a deeeper shift in the whole culture towards selfishness and competition. I'll try not to stray into politics here (tempting though it is), but turn on the TV (I can only talk about the UK here) and everything we do is being turned into a competition. Cooking, giving a party, antique collecting, music (eg Young Musician of the Year, ugh!), running a hotel, "talent" shows, dating. You name it, and it's been twisted into a game of winners and losers.

In the 'classical' domain, one of the worst aspects of modern performance is the tendency to think that technical virtuosity and pyrotechnical displays in performance are the same as a 'musical' performance. There are performers who understand, but there are an awful lot of (mostly younger) players who think blistering technique is everything.

Modern 'classical' music mostly failed to take off after about 1925. Why? Complex question, but in part the musicians got obsessed with their own cleverness and became detached from their audiences.

Does that mean that serialism and atonal music has no place? No. Is it going to be an enduring art form and join the mainstream cannon? No, or at least unlikely.

It turned out to be a blind alley which took about 50 years to get out of. It consumed the music 'establishment' including the BBC and anyone writing 'tunes' was an outcast (George Lloyd anyone?).

Fashions ebb and flow; ideas come, evolve, and go. Tastes change. Mahler's music was virtually unplayed until the 1960s: many orchestras programme his music most seasons now. Music of the Spanish Renaissance has lain mostly unknown for 400 years and has only recently started to re-appear (Morales, Esquivel etc). Music written by Jesuit missionaries and their Latin American native protégés in the jungles of Bolivia in the C16th/C17th/C18th have only re-appeared in the last 10 years.

Why does the music of the past endure? It is good music and there is always a new generation to discover it. Doesn't mean that music does not continue to move in new directions.

Talking to my 15 year old nephew at the weekend (he plays trumpet, cornet and guitar). I thought he was just a 'heavy metal' freak (sorry afficianado). Turns out he likes Frank Sinatra. that's a surprising improvement: when I was 15 (70s) I couldn't imagine the guys in my class who were into say Frank Zappa admitting to liking Sinatra!
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Adding to what Tv said, I think a fundamental issue is that composers forget their audiences. Music has to do something - entertain, and that means reaching and entangling people's emotions. And atonal/serial entertains/reaches very few. Tastes differ, there's room in music for many different styles and many different tastes but if there's no audience, then the musicians are playing alone.
 
Thanks to Nick for posting the World Saxophone Quartet interpreting "And The Wind Cried Mary". It is obviously carefully rehearsed as shown by the raised sax dropped and three join in with the same patterns. All this time, one of the others is badly cribbing from Mozart's string parts for the Trio from Cosi.

The start could be from the soundtrack to "Scott of the Antarctic" or "The Ancient Mariner." Is 'pretentious' the word I'm seeking?
 

Similar threads... or are they? Maybe not but they could be worth reading anyway 😀

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,076
Messages
578,677
Members
8,134
Latest member
banjo
Back
Top Bottom