Saxophones YAS280 or Horn 88

all from thesaxshack.co.uk
As far as I can tell, both of the YAS-32's are first generation, so they should be pretty much identical except for the logo and possibly a tilting table. My inclination would be to contact the seller and ask which is in best condition. If they are the same, I would probably go for the cheaper one. There is a mystique about the purple logo, but I don't think there is any real difference except for the difference between any two saxophones.
 
Hi, reviving an old thread. I love your take on things and have read most of your reviews. Thanks for putting those out there. I’ma newbie playing on s borrowed tenor sax but think I’ll want to go alto when I buy my first own one. (My daughter could also play that then).

Right now I’m looking at a YAS-32 for 800 or yas-32 purple label for 900 or a YAS-25 for 550 feom a reputable dealer. (However too far to visit in person). Hansonmusic has a Trevor James SR used but with warranty for 1000. Any thoughts?

Thanks for the input. Will write an introduction post soon when with quiet down a bit.
This is a tricky one. Assuming all the horns are in excellent condition I'd go for the PL 32, followed by the later 32. It's the poor man's 62. But the fly in the old ointment is that older Yamahas are likely to need some pad work - either now or in the very near future.
The SR is a very nice horn, and at a grand with a warranty is likely to be in very good nick.
Any of the horns listed could potentially serve you well for the rest of your playing life - but in terms of tonal dexterity the SR leads the pack. If you were looking to get more into rock and blues rather than jazz then the Yamahas have a slight edge (quite literally).
The 62 at £1500 is tempting, but there's no guarantee you'll get on with the mouthpiece...though you could always sell it on.
 
I recall my tutor bought a new SR tenor but didn't like it at all and replaced it shortly thereafter. The alto may of course be better, and you'll have your own preferences, but looking to future resale a well bought used Yamaha is always easiest to move on whilst losing little if any money. Any TJ, bar the RAW perhaps, will suffer greater depreciation.
 
Thanks for your input so far everyone. This gives me much better bearings.

@stevenhoward : will the 62 most likely have more breathing room before padwork needs to happen? What is the cost of padwork? (AI know it’s hard to say without seeing the horns but as an estimate)

Regarding mouthpiece, I don’t mind a challenge and also don’t mind investing in a yamaha 4c to get me going.

I think I’d really live a 62 but need to find a few more reasons to justify it too myself….

Thanks for everyone’s patience and feedback. Much appreciated.
 
@stevenhoward : will the 62 most likely have more breathing room before padwork needs to happen? What is the cost of padwork? (AI know it’s hard to say without seeing the horns but as an estimate)

Regarding mouthpiece, I don’t mind a challenge and also don’t mind investing in a yamaha 4c to get me going.

I think I’d really live a 62 but need to find a few more reasons to justify it too myself….

Thanks for everyone’s patience and feedback. Much appreciated.
It should do, as it's a newer model - but a great deal depends on how much use it's had.
Yamaha pads are quite good, but I find they don't take too well to being reset. If they look clean and reasonably fresh you'll probably be OK.
An average used Yamaha of more than ten years old will often need about £80-£120's worth of work to bring it back up to spec - and that may not be an issue if the purchase price is low enough.

If you really feel you want a 62 it will help if you're clear about what you feel the horn will give you.
The build quality is generally very good, the action is one of the best on the market, they re-sell well and they tend to be reliable.
From a personal perspective they're fun to play and quite punchy.,
 
thanks steven. That is indeed very helpful. While you are online, what’s your take on the 25 on the other hand of the spectrum? Especially since, sadly, my skill level might not give me the same appreciation of the 62’s benefits as it does for you.
 
thanks steven. That is indeed very helpful. While you are online, what’s your take on the 25 on the other hand of the spectrum? Especially since, sadly, my skill level might not give me the same appreciation of the 62’s benefits as it does for you.
The 25 is a very underrated horn. Its simplicity of design makes it sturdy and reliable, and it has a clarity of tone that's virtually unmatched. I played a 23 tenor for decades on a semi-pro basis. If your budget will only allow you to get a 25, you still won't be disappointed.
 
You (or should I say I) see 62s for sale at £450-1,000 fairly frequently.

A scrappy 62 PL for £450; a mint 62 MkIII for £600; a nice 62 MkI for £1,000, all in the last year.

But you have to be looking, in the right places, most of your (sad) life! 😳

My 23 alto is a "Vito". Identical to a Yamaha 23 bar the engraved brand name. Cost £80 plus five pads (which I fitted) and it's all the sax my paltry skills would ever need.
 
You (or should I say I) see 62s for sale at £450-1,000 fairly frequently.

A scrappy 62 PL for £450; a mint 62 MkIII for £600; a nice 62 MkI for £1,000, all in the last year.

But you have to be looking, in the right places, most of your (sad) life! 😳

My 23 alto is a "Vito". Identical to a Yamaha 23 bar the engraved brand name. Cost £80 plus five pads (which I fitted) and it's all the sax my paltry skills would ever need.
Hi David,

That are prices I’ve never seen. But then I most likely don’t know where to look! Pointers? Or I’ll provide a finders fee if you stumble upon something….?! There is no time pressure at the moment.
 
Buying 2nd hand privately is a minefield. Without experience in both playing and mechanicals you could easily come a cropper (I have) and end up with a large repair bill for something which looks OK at first glance.

I'd stick to a retailer where you have some come back. Those you mention from the sax shack are around what you'd generally see in the private ads anyway.

By the way, I prefer the 25 to the 275 (I've had a few) but the newer 280 is a fine horn albeit more pricey 2nd hand than the others as it's the current model.
 
Buying 2nd hand privately is a minefield. Without experience in both playing and mechanicals you could easily come a cropper (I have) and end up with a large repair bill for something which looks OK at first glance.

I'd stick to a retailer where you have some come back. Those you mention from the sax shack are around what you'd generally see in the private ads anyway.

By the way, I prefer the 25 to the 275 (I've had a few) but the newer 280 is a fine horn albeit more pricey 2nd hand than the others as it's the current model.
I'd agree with this - if you feel you don't have the experience to buy confidently, then buy from a dealer or shop. If you are tempted to buy from eBay etc. Make sure you go to collect and pay on collection which negates potential damage from shipping and also if it's not as described i.e. it doesn't play properly for some reason or has been owned by a chain smoker etc.
 

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,072
Messages
578,584
Members
8,133
Latest member
walthang
Back
Top Bottom