Saxophones Yas 62 G neck on a YAS 32

I already surrendered on this argument. But in my defense, all I was trying to say was that I think buying a thing for 400, then spending 700 to make it function is a worse idea than spending that total amount on something better that already functions. Everyone who responded disagrees, and I'm ok with that. You all win. The whole situation changed midstream anyway, so the point is moot.

Enjoy the new horn.
Not to be defensive but thats not how it went down lol. I won it in auction for 680 advertised as very good playing condition..so i took a chance on the neck at 190 thinking id improve the sax and have a good sax for 870..still below the asking price of a 32..the neck is non returnable..only on assessment I was told of the need for a repad..I could return the sax and be left with the g1..I tried to get the sax for 350 but the seller wouldnt budge on 400..the body and neck are in very good condition with a few minor scratches..at that point i had a new decision to make but had already bought and received the neck..I probably wouldn't have if Id known how it was going to pan out..a used unfettled 32 goes for between 900 and 1k so to have one repadded at 900 in vgc is ok..the neck is my "stupid" a bit hasty and trusting ill have to live with that it has put me over budget..
 
Not to be defensive but thats not how it went down lol. I won it in auction for 680 advertised as very good playing condition..so i took a chance on the neck at 190 thinking id improve the sax and have a good sax for 870..still below the asking price of a 32..the neck is non returnable..only on assessment I was told of the need for a repad..I could return the sax and be left with the g1..I tried to get the sax for 350 but the seller wouldnt budge on 400..the body and neck are in very good condition with a few minor scratches..at that point i had a new decision to make but had already bought and received the neck..I probably wouldn't have if Id known how it was going to pan out..a used unfettled 32 goes for between 900 and 1k so to have one repadded at 900 in vgc is ok..the neck is my "stupid" a bit hasty and trusting ill have to live with that it has put me over budget..
Why not sell the neck on to offset some of the overhaul.
 
If it doesnt make a difference i will...Got to try tho..
A mouthpiece is so much more important than a neck, given that there is no problem with the neck in the first place.

And proper practicing plus lessons from a good teacher are more important then a mouthpiece (assuming the mouthpiece is OK in the first place)
 
Last edited:
A mouthpiece is so much more important than a neck, given that there is no problem with the neck in the first place.

And proper practicing plus lessons from a good teacher are more important then a mouthpiece (assuming the mouthpiece is OK in the first place)
All being done pete..Like i said im kinda stuck with the crook so ill try it and probably move it on..
 
Not to be defensive but thats not how it went down lol. I won it in auction for 680 advertised as very good playing condition..so i took a chance on the neck at 190 thinking id improve the sax and have a good sax for 870..still below the asking price of a 32..the neck is non returnable..only on assessment I was told of the need for a repad..I could return the sax and be left with the g1..I tried to get the sax for 350 but the seller wouldnt budge on 400..the body and neck are in very good condition with a few minor scratches..at that point i had a new decision to make but had already bought and received the neck..I probably wouldn't have if Id known how it was going to pan out..a used unfettled 32 goes for between 900 and 1k so to have one repadded at 900 in vgc is ok..the neck is my "stupid" a bit hasty and trusting ill have to live with that it has put me over budget..
It’s all good. Lots of numbers floating around, changes, unknowns and Monday morning quarterbacking. If I could withdraw all my earlier comments I would. Sounds like you have a workable solution for a reasonable amount of money. Hopefully you’ll be making music on the alto soon.
 
It’s all good. Lots of numbers floating around, changes, unknowns and Monday morning quarterbacking. If I could withdraw all my earlier comments I would. Sounds like you have a workable solution for a reasonable amount of money. Hopefully you’ll be making music on the alto soon.
I wouldnt want you to @lydian..it's your opinion..your always honest..Thats one of the reasons i respect your opinon..
 
Necks: In my experience, the difference between good necks is subtle; the difference between bad and good necks can be enormous (generally in intonation).

I haven’t played the Yamaha horns in this discussion. My experiences were with several Selmer tenor necks. A Selmer sterling silver Serie II neck had terrible intonation on my Serie III to the point that it was unplayable. When testing Reference 36/54 necks, I found that the Ref 54 necks tended to be stuffy compared to the Ref 36, and necks with measurably smaller IDs (measured at the cork end) were the worst.

On the other hand, when I test play really good necks (good response and intonation), it is much harder to rank them, and often settles to just personal preference (variations in frequency spectrum).

Bottom line: If your intonation is good and the horn responds well, shift your focus to dialing in your selection of mouthpiece and reeds, and don’t question your horn’s neck unless it gets damaged.

P.S. and OBTW: If the neck doesn’t fit well at either cork or tenon, that‘s a leak.
 
The PTFE tubing from this company would probably work:

 
That may work, but might be too flimsy for extension purposes. I'd try to find something more rigid. @eb424 , I'd punch a hole in a piece of paper using the octave pin and measure the diameter of that hole to confirm whatever you buy will fit. You may well find some sort of sleeve or tubing at your local hardware store. Even a sleeve cut from a rivet could work really well, assuming you can find one long enough and the right diameter.
images
 
When I got my Just Joe's with as metal hook, I bought a lifetimes supply of heat shrink tubing for £few, to cover the hook. If it's just a few mm, I'd try that. It cools quite stiff / hard (don't say anything) and is quite hard wearing
 
I use to play a yas62 with a selmer mkvi neck , after seeing and speaking to Nelson rangell over 20 years ago , really improved the sound of the 62 , but with the price of mkvi necks now it’s nearly as expensive as a used 62 , I do use a Boston heritage neck on my mkvi tenor good sound and less resistant
 
Ok so sax overhauled and back..went today to get the crook fitted wow what a difference..even the tech thought it played nicer more focused and depth..
This reinforces my unscientific belief that the main difference between a 32 and a 62 sound-wise is the neck.

I once compared my 32 bari sax with a 62 - there was hardly any difference when played loud, but the 62 was sweeter when played soft. (A pro player tried them too and agreed.) However, when I put the 62 neck on the 32 it was very close to the 62.
 

Similar threads... or are they? Maybe not but they could be worth reading anyway 😀

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,072
Messages
578,576
Members
8,133
Latest member
walthang
Back
Top Bottom