Playing the saxophone Weakness with 3 1/2 Strength

ESJohn

Senior Member
Messages
1,653
Location
Ohio USA
A few weeks ago, I stopped at my local music store as I needed a few reeds. I normally use Rico Royals but he stocks only the traditional Ricos. The nice thing is that he sells them individually so I went ahead and purchased a variety including 2/1/2's, 3's and just one 3 1/2 as I wanted to see what I could do without making a heavy investment into a reed strength that wasn't suitable for me. Using the 3 1/2 strength would be a new experience.
I hitched up the 3 1/2 to my 5C* (custom built, not a name branded one). I liked the sound and, within a short time, was playing across all registers without much difficulty. Looking back, the practice sessions weren't more than 1/2 hour with that reed and I was focusing on selected portions of the tunes in front of me.
It was going well enough that I decided to use that combination during our regular rehearsal. We are practicing our Christmas music and the pieces are not especially difficult. Everything was fine for the first hour, but then I suddenly felt as though I had just ingested a large amount of alum. My lips and cheeks pulled together tightly and I could not make a sound. I rested for a minute and then began again and had the same results after 20-30 measures. This happened again and again for the next 1/2 hour until the rehearsal mercifully ended.
I'll go back to the 2 1/2's and3's for now.
Do you think I did too much too soon or is that reed strength just too much for me?
 
From the list of wise quotes ...
"If it hurts you're doing it wrong." 😉
Come down a strength, or go up a strength and see if your eyes pop out. 🙂

Royal are French cut.
Orange are American cut.
They play differently.

Your embouchure is flesh and blood. It has limits. Training may work to strengthen it and improve endurance but I suspect sound quality will suffer if you have to push too hard.

A softer reed will allow you to play more quietly with more subtlety.
A harder reed works well outside or where volume is the only criteria.

Reed selection is critical for performance.
 
What Colin said. 🙂 I know exactly what you mean. I always put on one of my softer reeds when playing in a long band rehearsal. When practicing you can take the mouthpiece out of your mouth and rest the embouchure muscles from time to time. In a rehearsal when your parts have only a few rests you can't do that unless you share the part with another player and can trade off from time to time. In concerts that usually last about 45 minutes rather than 1 1/2 to 2 hours like rehearsals I put on my best sounding reed and hope for the best.
 
I'll go back to the 2 1/2's and3's for now.
Do you think I did too much too soon or is that reed strength just too much for me?

It's not just about the strength number on the box, but also the characteristics of that particular reed - and then you also have to figure in how you're going to use it.

For example, a Vandoren Green Java 3 will not feel remotely like a traditional Vandoren blue or Vandoren ZZ of supposedly the same strength even though they're all Vandoren reeds.

But it's not just about finding the right strength. As you've just discovered, a reed that sounds great but destroys your emboucher before the end of the rehearsal, gig or show is not the reed for you. Yes, your endurance will increase the more you play but there are limits dictated by your personal physique.

Reed choice is a balancing act of tone, how it affects your endurance and how well it allows you to play the way you want to play. The numbers on the box are really only there to help you find the reed for you - they're for reference purposes only. Reed charts are very helpful in this respect. If you like the sound of a Rico Orange 3 but you'd prefer it to have a little less resistance so that you can play for longer, then a reed chart can help - which other Rico reeds are there that are slightly softer? What if an Orange 2.5 is too soft? It looks like a D'Addario (who make Rico) Reserve 2.5 is slightly softer than a Rico Orange 3 but harder than the 2.5.

Ask yourself what you need the reed to do, then have a look at a reed chart to see which reed to try that should take you closer to your goal.

Annoyingly, reed choice can often change when you change mouthpiece. It can also change when you find yourself in a new situation; you may need to play for longer, or you're being asked to play predominately at the extremes of the instrument.
 
I appreciate the comments and suggestions from everyone. I guess if this was easy it would be boring.
Now it's time to practice or I will sound lousy no matter which reed I choose!
 

Similar threads... or are they? Maybe not but they could be worth reading anyway 😀

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,076
Messages
578,675
Members
8,134
Latest member
banjo
Back
Top Bottom